#opnfv-functest: Functest weekly meeting September 13rd

Meeting started by morgan_orange at 08:00:24 UTC (full logs).

Meeting summary

  1. call role (morgan_orange, 08:00:28)
    1. morgan Richomme (morgan_orange, 08:00:33)
    2. Viktor Tikkanen (viktor_t, 08:00:36)
    3. Juha Kosonen (juhak, 08:00:40)
    4. Cristina Pauna (ENEA) (CristinaPauna, 08:00:45)
    5. Jose Lausuch (jose_lausuch, 08:00:52)
    6. Luke Hinds (lhinds, 08:00:58)
    7. agenda https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/functest/Functest+Meeting (morgan_orange, 08:01:19)

  2. action point follow-up (morgan_orange, 08:02:09)
    1. Jun Li (MatthewLi, 08:02:23)
    2. http://ircbot.wl.linuxfoundation.org/meetings/opnfv-functest/2016/opnfv-functest.2016-09-06-08.00.html (morgan_orange, 08:02:35)
    3. AP1 jose_lausuch ollivier find best way to coloradoize our docker and try to keep a master to be able to test changes without breaking colorado gate (morgan_orange, 08:02:42)
    4. done, using arg, 2 docker files availables (morgan_orange, 08:02:47)
    5. AP2 jose_lausuch sync for apex/bgpvpn (morgan_orange, 08:02:57)
    6. AP3 jose_lausuch sync for apex/sfc (morgan_orange, 08:03:54)
    7. https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/APEX-219 (jose_lausuch, 08:04:24)
    8. apex-sfc has the same status as fuel-sfc, there has been some failures in the boron releases, currently testing Boron RC3.5 which came out yesterday and it's the release candidate (jose_lausuch, 08:05:20)
    9. patch submitted for SFC, new try, new hope... (morgan_orange, 08:05:31)
    10. AP4 May-meimei sync for apex/onos and apex/onos-sfc (morgan_orange, 08:05:40)
    11. if that still gives us problems, we will report that in the release notes and leave the test failing (known upstream bug) (jose_lausuch, 08:05:41)
    12. raghavendrachari (raghav, 08:07:43)
    13. https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/apex/job/functest-apex-apex-daily-colorado-daily-colorado/157/console (morgan_orange, 08:08:00)
    14. ACTION: morgan_orange sync with apex/onos (morgan_orange, 08:09:41)
    15. AP5 May-meimei sync compass/onos-sfc (morgan_orange, 08:09:47)
    16. idem AP4 (morgan_orange, 08:09:59)
    17. AP6 SerenaFeng sync fuel/doctor (morgan_orange, 08:10:04)
    18. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/20663/ (morgan_orange, 08:10:53)
    19. discussions on how to fix doctor in fuel pending..is there any date before moving from Colorado 1.0 to colorado 2.0 (morgan_orange, 08:11:35)
    20. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/20627/ was abandoned (CristinaPauna, 08:11:53)
    21. fuel team in the patch mentioned a possible fix beginning of this week from doctor (morgan_orange, 08:11:54)
    22. fuel scenarios are fine, it is just a decision from release management to see until when we try ... (morgan_orange, 08:12:24)
    23. AP done (it is more a question for release management, Doctor/fuel team) (morgan_orange, 08:12:44)
    24. AP7 viktor_t review scenarios where tempest is not fully sunny (morgan_orange, 08:12:51)
    25. AP8 juhak review scenarios where rally is not fully sunny (morgan_orange, 08:13:16)
    26. there were failed cases on os-nosdn-lxd-ha/noha scenarios, corrected along with FUNCTEST-460 and FUNCTEST-464 (juhak, 08:13:27)
    27. AP9 morgan_orange test rally black list on lxd scenario (morgan_orange, 08:13:48)
    28. done, lxd scenario now both OK for joid (morgan_orange, 08:13:53)
    29. AP10 morgan_orange add push to DB in odl_sfc (morgan_orange, 08:13:57)
    30. patch created by José, review in progress https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/20929 (morgan_orange, 08:14:01)
    31. ACTION: morgan_orange wait for merge before enabling it in reporting (morgan_orange, 08:14:19)
    32. AP11 SerenaFeng Raghav review Yardstick documentation (morgan_orange, 08:15:55)
    33. ACTION: raghav review yardstick (morgan_orange, 08:16:39)
    34. AP12 morgan_orange add CristinaPauna and Alex Avadanii in Functest doc review (morgan_orange, 08:16:49)
    35. I didn't get any review invitation for documentation containg arm references (CristinaPauna, 08:16:54)
    36. done for CristinaPauna, Alex not found in gerrit reviewers (morgan_orange, 08:16:57)
    37. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/20315/ does not contain diffs for arm (CristinaPauna, 08:17:29)
    38. I did see thoug in the existing docs some referenced to arm that I would like to modify (CristinaPauna, 08:17:59)
    39. ACTION: morgan_orange check arm ref and add them in the doc review for CristinaPauna (morgan_orange, 08:18:30)
    40. AP13 morgan_orange pushich topic 2 and 6 (morgan_orange, 08:18:36)
    41. done +1 with topic on VNF catalog (morgan_orange, 08:18:43)
    42. https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/DEV/Intern-projects-page (morgan_orange, 08:19:12)
    43. AP14 everybody review and comment D wiki page (morgan_orange, 08:19:18)

  3. Colorado (morgan_orange, 08:20:57)
    1. I reported to Release management that from Functest perspective, it would be possible to release today as most of the scenarios are OK and all the remaining errors are understood and documented in the release note. (morgan_orange, 08:21:20)
    2. apex: first green scenario light on monday (morgan_orange, 08:22:43)
    3. http://testresults.opnfv.org/reporting/functest/release/colorado/index-status-apex.html (morgan_orange, 08:23:17)
    4. issues already discussed in AP follow up section (morgan_orange, 08:23:28)
    5. note all the odl_l3 scenarios will be failed whatever the installer (morgan_orange, 08:23:47)
    6. compass (morgan_orange, 08:23:52)
    7. http://testresults.opnfv.org/reporting/functest/release/colorado/index-status-compass.html (morgan_orange, 08:23:55)
    8. work in progress in moon (apparently Tempest OK and moon OK, issue on odl known and documented) (morgan_orange, 08:24:14)
    9. fuel (morgan_orange, 08:24:29)
    10. http://testresults.opnfv.org/reporting/functest/release/colorado/index-status-fuel.html (morgan_orange, 08:24:32)
    11. already some green scenarios...without doctor most of them will be green (morgan_orange, 08:24:47)
    12. fix on noha scenarios merged yesterday (test excluded in HA but not in noha) (morgan_orange, 08:25:10)
    13. joid (morgan_orange, 08:25:16)
    14. http://testresults.opnfv.org/reporting/functest/release/colorado/index-status-joid.html (morgan_orange, 08:25:23)
    15. most of the scenarios OK (morgan_orange, 08:25:29)
    16. no objection for Colorado releasing from Functest (morgan_orange, 08:31:18)

  4. Security Audit is coming... (morgan_orange, 08:32:11)
    1. in fact it came, errors shared with core developpers (morgan_orange, 08:32:27)
    2. no critical issues, yesterday patch abandonned due to confusion json.yaml load/safe_load (morgan_orange, 08:32:52)

  5. D release: discussion with OAI (morgan_orange, 08:36:14)
    1. https://wiki.opnfv.org/rest/documentConversion/latest/conversion/thumbnail/7767229/1 (morgan_orange, 08:37:05)
    2. discussion on vEPC/OAI integration - maybe a scenario is needed (kvm like) to be tested on existing OPNFV (morgan_orange, 08:52:04)

  6. Meetup (morgan_orange, 08:52:13)
    1. ACTION: morgan_orange prepare pool for Functest meetup in Lannion (morgan_orange, 08:55:48)

  7. AOB (morgan_orange, 08:56:25)
    1. https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/SDNVPN-54 (jose_lausuch, 08:56:49)
    2. most of the bgpvpn scenarios are failing in CI due to a timeout (jose_lausuch, 08:57:04)
    3. the tests are working, its simply the calls to neutron/nova api take too long, but they work (jose_lausuch, 08:57:26)
    4. for example, tempest 100% successful but takes 1 hour for the smoke, same for rally sanity (jose_lausuch, 08:57:59)
    5. bgpvpn scenario blacklist rally completelly for Colorado.1.0, and enable it again for Colorado.2.0 which comes with boron (morgan_orange, 09:02:41)
    6. ACTION: morgan_orange contact bitergia / ELK (morgan_orange, 09:04:19)


Meeting ended at 09:05:01 UTC (full logs).

Action items

  1. morgan_orange sync with apex/onos
  2. morgan_orange wait for merge before enabling it in reporting
  3. raghav review yardstick
  4. morgan_orange check arm ref and add them in the doc review for CristinaPauna
  5. morgan_orange prepare pool for Functest meetup in Lannion
  6. morgan_orange contact bitergia / ELK


Action items, by person

  1. CristinaPauna
    1. morgan_orange check arm ref and add them in the doc review for CristinaPauna
  2. morgan_orange
    1. morgan_orange sync with apex/onos
    2. morgan_orange wait for merge before enabling it in reporting
    3. morgan_orange check arm ref and add them in the doc review for CristinaPauna
    4. morgan_orange prepare pool for Functest meetup in Lannion
    5. morgan_orange contact bitergia / ELK
  3. raghav
    1. raghav review yardstick


People present (lines said)

  1. morgan_orange (166)
  2. jose_lausuch (58)
  3. Rohit_openairint (29)
  4. lhinds (15)
  5. SerenaFeng (11)
  6. OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot (8)
  7. CristinaPauna (6)
  8. juhak (3)
  9. viktor_t (3)
  10. collabot` (3)
  11. raghav (2)
  12. MatthewLi (1)
  13. May-meimei (1)


Generated by MeetBot 0.1.4.