=========================================== #opnfv-meeting: Weekly Technical Discussion =========================================== Meeting started by bh526r at 13:03:49 UTC. The full logs are available at http://ircbot.wl.linuxfoundation.org/meetings/opnfv-meeting/2017/opnfv-meeting.2017-05-18-13.03.log.html . Meeting summary --------------- * Reference VNFs (bh526r, 13:04:56) * LINK: https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/EUAG/Reference+VNFs (dmcbride, 13:05:04) * LINK: https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/EUAG/Reference+VNFs (bh526r, 13:05:11) * David M introduced background - Steven W chaired EUAG and listed priorities from end user perspective (bh526r, 13:07:32) * pain points (bh526r, 13:07:44) * One of top pain points is reference VNFs (bh526r, 13:08:08) * Meanwhile, SampleVNF project is approved (bh526r, 13:08:24) * David M communicated with Deepak S and Kannan regarding using SampleVNF to support reference VNFs pain points (bh526r, 13:09:09) * Deepak S asked if there is a deployment scenario that needs to be supported? (bh526r, 13:09:49) * David M indicated that it needs Steven W's input in terms of deployment scenario (bh526r, 13:10:40) * Deepak asked if there are specific VNFs Steven W is looking for (bh526r, 13:12:28) * David M explained that Steven W might just want the catalog work to get started (bh526r, 13:12:55) * Deepak asks if there is a detailed list of VNFs (dmcbride, 13:15:15) * Bryan S indicated that EUAG group might not have prioritized anything yet. Everything on the list is subject to further discussion, and further work (bh526r, 13:15:28) * bryan_att questions requirement for "production-quality" (dmcbride, 13:17:45) * SampleVNF is not targeted for "production-ready" VNF (bh526r, 13:20:32) * while EUAG requires "production-ready" VNFs (bh526r, 13:20:58) * will all reference VNFs be open source? (dmcbride, 13:21:26) * The question is if there is a match to use SampleVNF project to address EUAG requirement (bh526r, 13:21:28) * Another question is if "production-quality" is really EUAG requirement (bh526r, 13:22:24) * David M takes action to confirm with Steven W (bh526r, 13:22:42) * ACTION: dmcbride confirms with Steven W if "production-quality" is EUAG requirement or not (bh526r, 13:23:40) * dneary says that any VNF in the catalog should be freely available and useable without restriction (dmcbride, 13:27:01) * LINK: http://ec2-34-210-8-241.us-west-2.compute.amazonaws.com:3000/ (jose_lausuch, 13:34:17) * dmcbride clarifies that his goal is to satisfy the EUAG pain point looking for a list of VNFs - he sees the SampleVNF as potentially a good owner of the list (dneary, 13:34:35) * Julien (Julien-zte, 13:35:16) * dneary clarifies that SampleVNF is subject to OPNFV licensing rules - they could add VNFs under open source licenses other than Apache v2 but would need an exception, but there is nothing preventing them from collecting a list of VNFs. (dneary, 13:35:38) * The concern voiced by bryan_att was to avoid a situation where this list means something (eg. VNFs tested by OPNFV on our infrastructure) - running and testing proprietary VNFs could bring us down a slippery slope - but the team should be able to maintain a list of VNFs without restriction (dneary, 13:37:11) * LINK: http://ec2-34-210-8-241.us-west-2.compute.amazonaws.com:3000/ (dneary, 13:37:56) * LINK: https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/DEV/VNF+Catalogue (morgan_orange, 13:41:04) * bryan_att says that first paragraph falls outside the scope of simply having a catalog of VNFs. MANO problem. (dmcbride, 13:44:07) Meeting ended at 14:02:34 UTC. Action items, by person ----------------------- * dmcbride * dmcbride confirms with Steven W if "production-quality" is EUAG requirement or not People present (lines said) --------------------------- * bh526r (20) * dneary (6) * dmcbride (6) * collabot (3) * morgan_orange (2) * Julien-zte (2) * jose_lausuch (1) Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4