14:00:25 #startmeeting SFC-week-32 14:00:25 Meeting started Wed Aug 8 14:00:25 2018 UTC. The chair is mbuil. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 14:00:25 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 14:00:25 The meeting name has been set to 'sfc_week_32' 14:00:27 Im on, where are you?!?!? 14:00:33 #link https://zoom.us/j/5014627785 14:00:39 #topic rollcall 14:00:45 #info Manuel Buil 14:01:13 #info Dimitrios Markou 14:01:18 #info Brady Johnson 14:07:39 #topic Spam in our IRC channel 14:08:23 #info Infra guys will provide instructions about how to solve it in the next days 14:10:01 #topic OVS 2.9 support in ODL Fluorine 14:10:21 #info code freeze was reached yesterday 14:10:32 #info From SFC perspective it looks very promising 14:10:53 #info COngratulations to ODL-SFC work! 14:11:16 Big thanks to Jaime Camaaño from SUSE for doing most of this work. 14:11:27 #info We should try from OPNFV 14:12:30 #topic Fixing tacker in HA scenarios 14:13:02 #info Panos is on vacation. Barbican is giving Panos some troubles 14:14:15 #info Apparently Barbican is not integrating well with Tacker 14:15:27 #topic ODL-COE with SFC 14:16:05 #info COE - Container Orchestration Engine 14:17:13 #info Bill progressing. He will compare ODL config in openstack and K8s 14:20:04 #topic SFC with baremetal 14:22:24 #info SFC works in baremetal 14:22:48 #aob 14:23:46 #topic OPNFV/SFC test with Fortigate 14:29:23 #info There is a limitation in networking-sfc which does not allow to have different classifiers with almost the same parameters 14:36:11 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 14:36:13 link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/59995/6 14:36:15 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 14:36:18 #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/59995/6 14:36:20 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 14:36:23 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 14:36:27 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 15:25:47 mbuil, mardim, guys I've just tested XCI with a double chain going through a single VNF 15:26:21 since now I'm using a different client and server to the ones used for the first chain, I no longer get the "Flow Classifier conflict", which is fine 15:26:39 however the operation can not be completed, I think it is not supported, as mardim pointed out 15:27:17 now I get an error saying that the port pair for ingress and egress port is already used... I suppose these ones refer to the ports in the VNF (the FortiGate) 15:27:24 this is the error: 15:27:51 https://hastebin.com/pesucavafo.sql 15:28:50 I guess we need to wait for the "multiple forwarding paths" patch to be merged 15:31:40 mangelm: ok, good to know. You will need to deploy another VNF I guess 15:32:31 mbuil, yep, but the purpose of the test is also to check if the FortiGate VNF can allocate properly different chains to different security profiles 15:32:55 mangelm ok, shit 15:33:07 mangelm, hi 15:33:23 I added new feature to fix that, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/554435 15:35:35 phuoc, cool!!! 15:35:46 I see it is merged... but maybe XCI is not getting it yet? 15:36:57 hmmm it's dated almost 5 months ago, so it should be already in XCI 15:37:28 I think it's not availabled in quuens version 15:37:29 phuoc, it's great!!! let me see why this is not working in my case 15:39:37 phuoc, ok, you are right, it may not be included in XCI 15:40:20 mangelm, I hope that patch can help you 15:40:54 phuoc, Yes, it will. It is actually what I am testing right now. This patch is great!! 15:43:27 phuoc, Not sure if I will be able to test it before it is included in XCI... I'll talk to Manuel 15:43:31 phuoc, Thanks a lot! 15:44:03 mangelm, np :) 15:53:55 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 15:53:55 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 15:54:01 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 15:54:01 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 15:54:05 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 16:23:12 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 16:23:12 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 16:23:18 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 16:23:18 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 16:23:22 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 16:37:35 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 16:37:35 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 16:37:44 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 16:37:44 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 16:37:44 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 17:29:54 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 17:29:59 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 17:30:03 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 17:30:06 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 17:30:10 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 17:41:56 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 17:42:00 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 17:42:05 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 17:42:08 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 17:42:12 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 18:15:38 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 18:15:43 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 18:15:47 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 18:15:50 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 18:15:54 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 18:41:38 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 18:41:38 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 18:41:44 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 18:41:44 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 20:10:56 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 20:11:01 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 20:11:05 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 20:11:08 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 20:39:39 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 20:39:43 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 20:39:47 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 20:39:50 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 20:39:54 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 20:53:05 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 20:53:09 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 20:53:13 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 20:53:16 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 20:53:20 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 21:28:41 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 21:28:41 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 21:28:47 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 21:28:47 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 21:28:51 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 03:52:27 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 03:52:27 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 03:52:32 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 03:52:35 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 03:52:39 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 04:25:28 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 04:25:28 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 04:25:33 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 04:25:33 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 04:25:36 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 05:18:05 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 05:18:05 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 05:18:09 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 05:18:09 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 05:18:13 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 05:30:56 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 05:30:56 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 05:31:00 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 05:31:00 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 05:31:04 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 06:26:30 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 06:26:35 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 06:26:39 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 06:26:42 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 06:26:46 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 06:54:48 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 06:54:48 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 06:54:52 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 06:54:52 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 06:54:56 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 08:01:48 Venkata Harshavardhan Reddy Allu proposed sfc: Added unit tests for 'openstack_utils.py' module https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/59995 08:07:42 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 08:07:47 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 08:07:50 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 08:07:53 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 08:07:58 Don't support freenode and their ICO scam, switch to a network that hasn't been co-opted by corporate interests. OFTC or efnet might be a good choice. Perhaps even https://matrix.org/ 09:11:56 Christel just posted this "denial" on the freenode blog https://freenode.net/news/spam-shake Why does this blog post mention "10.2 million" THREE times? 09:11:56 This blog is essentially an ad for the Handshake ICO scam with a one-line "denial" of involvement mixed in there. It's obviously very unethical of Christel to not mention her own involvement in the scam which the blog post promotes. 09:12:01 Consider Andrew Lee's involvement, Andrew Lee is Christel's boss at London Trust Media and he also controls the majority of freenode voting rights. Andrew Lee also heads the handshake ICO scam. Coincidence? 09:12:04 Oh, and about those donations she speaks of: https://twitter.com/ISCdotORG/status/1025461692132519936 10:02:59 #endmeeting