08:30:39 <rbbratta> #startmeeting yardstick work meeting
08:30:39 <collabot> Meeting started Mon Jun 19 08:30:39 2017 UTC.  The chair is rbbratta. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
08:30:39 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
08:30:39 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'yardstick_work_meeting'
08:30:55 <rbbratta> #topic roll call
08:31:03 <kubi001> #info kubi
08:31:07 <rbbratta> #info Ross
08:31:14 <abhijitsinha> #info Abhijit
08:31:22 <JackChan> #info Jack
08:31:25 <JingLu> #info JingLu
08:31:29 <Mingjiang> #info Rex
08:31:34 <Kanglin> #info Kanglin
08:32:16 <rbbratta> #topic action items follows up
08:32:56 <zhihui_> #info zhihui
08:33:25 <Ace____> #info Ace____
08:33:27 <kubi001> rbbratta: how about your trip
08:33:38 <rbbratta> trip was good
08:34:04 <rbbratta> still getting back into sync
08:34:49 <rbbratta> let's see, we talked to OpenRetriever team as summit, right?  so we can close that action point
08:35:17 <kubi001> rbbratta: yes, agree
08:35:47 <JackChan> rbbratta: yes, I have talked with Ruijing.
08:35:59 <rbbratta> #info: AP2: we talked to OR team at summit, have plan for Kubernetes support
08:36:34 <rbbratta> JackChan: have we made a Jira task for Kuberenetes support?
08:37:06 <JackChan> rbbratta: Current no, I will create it soon.
08:37:49 <JackChan> Now I have installed k8s. I plan to write a test case this days as the first step.
08:37:58 <rbbratta> Initially we planned to support pre-deploy k8s containers using pod.yaml, then add k8s context at some point.
08:38:43 <JackChan> rbbratta: agree.
08:39:29 <rbbratta> #info Initial plan to support pre-deployed k8s containers using pod.yaml node context, then add k8s context
08:40:14 <ds1> #info deepak
08:40:52 <rbbratta> next AP was to plan a backlog scrub at summit, we didn't do that, we should scrub backlog and Danube 3.0 tasks\
08:42:51 <kubi001> oh, yes, we can do that at US time slot meeting with gotomeeting
08:42:56 <rbbratta> okay
08:43:45 <rbbratta> #action backlog scrub at US time slot meeting
08:44:23 <rbbratta> AP4 was to talk to David about MS4 requirements.
08:44:36 <rbbratta> That can happen at the release meeting tomorrow
08:45:19 <rbbratta> Do you guys go to the APAC release meeting?
08:45:27 <rbbratta> I need to find the timeslot for that
08:46:21 <kubi001> APAC release is bi-weeks meeting
08:46:26 <rbbratta> #info follow up on MS4 requirements at release meeting
08:46:50 <rbbratta> kubi001: can you forward me the APAC release meeting invite?
08:46:59 <kubi001> rbbratta: sure
08:47:19 <rbbratta> AP5 was SNAPS-OO Heat gerrit review, that has already been merged
08:47:59 <rbbratta> #info SNAPS-OO Heat support review  https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/35753 has been merged
08:48:18 <rbbratta> anything else for action points?
08:48:39 <kubi001> rbbratta: Done for invitation
08:48:40 <Mingjiang> about SNAPS-OO i take the action to rewrite Ping to use SNAPs first.
08:49:15 <rbbratta> Mingjiang: okay, please make Jira task for it
08:49:24 <Mingjiang> okay
08:49:42 <rbbratta> next topic, summit
08:50:18 <rbbratta> #topic OPNFV Summit 2017 Beijing
08:50:57 <rbbratta> Everyone had a good time?  It was good to meet you all.  :)
08:51:16 <Mingjiang> nice meeting you all, too
08:51:33 <Mingjiang> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=5734608
08:51:40 <rbbratta> Thank you all for your hospitality
08:51:55 <Mingjiang> any slides or demo video could be uploaded here.
08:51:57 <kubi001> :)
08:52:43 <rbbratta> Has the GUI demo video been uploaded?
08:52:48 <JackChan> #link https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3qbJDp6QBk
08:53:10 <JackChan> rbbratta: yes, I have just uploaded it.
08:53:27 <rbbratta> #info everyone please watch Yardstick GUI Demo  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3qbJDp6QBk
08:54:20 <rbbratta> where there any other Yardstick presentations?
08:54:32 <Mingjiang> JackChan: you can also add the link into yardstick wiki so everyone knows about it.
08:55:12 <JackChan> Mingjiang: yes, I will do it right now.
08:55:26 <Mingjiang> rbbratta: i've uploaded mine in the wiki.
08:55:44 <kubi001> i will upload mine soon
08:55:47 <rbbratta> kubi001: did you have slide for your other talk?
08:56:10 <kubi001> rbbratta: yes, will upload soos, slide with trevor
08:56:11 <JackChan> Mingjiang: Done!
08:56:31 <rbbratta> also the one with China Mobile
08:56:52 <kubi001> sure
08:57:57 <rbbratta> #action everyone please add slides and videos to wiki
08:58:31 <rbbratta> There was a presentation by Morgan about measuring power utilization using IPMI during testing
08:58:50 <rbbratta> Energy Audit aaS with OPNFV
08:58:53 <kubi001> that's a interesting topic
08:59:18 <rbbratta> They have a python library already written and used in functest
08:59:37 <rbbratta> I need to find the slides, but there is a developer at Orange that worked on that.
09:00:13 <rbbratta> We should add it as a feature request and scope it out.  I will create Jira ticket
09:01:24 <kubi001> okay
09:01:28 <rbbratta> #action Ross: find slides for Energy Audit aaS and create Jira story for it
09:02:14 <rbbratta> There was also discussion in a another session about using linking the Pod Descriptor File to the test results, so people can track hardware
09:02:33 <rbbratta> this is related to the current task for gathering hardware info
09:02:52 <rbbratta> the hardware is already defined in some cases in the PDF
09:03:19 <Mingjiang> rbbratta: can you create a jira task for it or updated existed jira?
09:04:23 <rbbratta> #action Ross: create Jira story for link PDF to test results for recording HW info
09:04:41 <kubi001> Which Pod Descriptor File?
09:04:44 <Mingjiang> rbbratta: do you mean the pharos userguide.pdf that contains the hardware info of pods
09:04:57 <rbbratta> PDF -> POD Descriptor File
09:05:06 <Mingjiang> ok
09:05:09 <rbbratta> The PDF from the dynamic CI business
09:05:12 <Mingjiang> got it
09:05:42 <rbbratta> I think Uli suggested it
09:05:48 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Alexandru Nemes proposed yardstick: Configure Yardstick flavor to give more RAM to ARM instances  https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/36179
09:06:13 <rbbratta> Where they any other ideas/tasks from the summit?
09:06:49 <rbbratta> did we have more ideas from the SNAPS tutorial?
09:07:39 <rbbratta> did we talk about ansible something?
09:07:49 <Mingjiang> it could help to clean the code.
09:09:48 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Alexandru Nemes proposed yardstick: Configure Yardstick flavor to give more RAM to ARM instances  https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/36179
09:10:08 <rbbratta> I can't remember any additional ansible ideas, if we have any we can add to exists jira
09:10:17 <rbbratta> any other comments on the summit?
09:10:32 <rbbratta> any interesting sessions?
09:11:29 <rbbratta> next topic Dovetail docker tag
09:11:58 <Mingjiang> Leo from Dovetail asked to add tag of cvp in yardstick docker image.
09:12:01 <rbbratta> #topic Dovetail requires Yardstick docker tag
09:12:37 <rbbratta> what is cvp tag supposed to represent?
09:12:42 <rbbratta> which version?
09:13:40 <Mingjiang> they want to tag yardstick docker image so dovetail can use it to specify which version of yardstick is related to dovetail
09:13:56 <Mingjiang> they would also add tag on dovetail docker image
09:13:59 <rbbratta> sure, but do they only want release versions?
09:14:17 <rbbratta> I assume they want Danube 3.0, etc.
09:14:36 <rbbratta> So the concern would be Dovetail using a non-git-tagged yardstick version
09:14:55 <rbbratta> this also seems like a release meeting decision
09:14:58 <Mingjiang> not release versions, but a specific commit that dovetail have verified.
09:15:23 <Mingjiang> no need on git
09:15:34 <Mingjiang> no need to tag on git
09:15:35 <rbbratta> I'm not unopposed, but I suspect we don't want to start using un-released versions, since that defeats the purpose of having releases
09:16:57 <Mingjiang> dovetail do not sync with opnfv release, i think that's why they need to tag it.
09:17:22 <rbbratta> other projects and the public in general should only officially consume tagged released yardstick versions
09:18:18 <rbbratta> because released versions are the only ones we support
09:18:38 <rbbratta> is there an email thread or something on tech-discuss?
09:19:33 <Mingjiang> i don't think so, I can ask him to create a thread about it.
09:19:40 <rbbratta> please do
09:20:03 <Mingjiang> sure
09:20:18 <rbbratta> we are flexible, but we don't want to create bad process
09:21:08 <kubi001> when will we have Danube 3.0 ?
09:21:11 <rbbratta> #action Rex: follow up on Dovetail request to create docker tag for Yardstick version to use with Dovetail
09:21:22 <rbbratta> okay, next topic Danube 3.0
09:21:43 <rbbratta> #topic Danube 3.0
09:22:13 <rbbratta> so I tagged Danube 3.0 already before summit, because I didn't see the defer email
09:22:52 <rbbratta> I think we resolved and moved all the Danube 3.0 issues
09:23:08 <rbbratta> Are there critical issues that we need to revisit?
09:24:49 <Mingjiang> kanglin: what about ha test case
09:25:48 <Kanglin> Mingjiang: Discussed with Fu Qiao, but she seems to be busy these days, the detail HA test case design will be discussed later.
09:26:27 <Mingjiang> there's a problem about ha test case to run on https SUT
09:27:11 <Mingjiang> currently the cli command ha test case use do not support insecure way when connect to https SUT
09:28:31 <Kanglin> Got it, can you make an issue on jira?
09:29:09 <Mingjiang> Kanglin: I will
09:31:04 <Kanglin> Mingjiang: OK, I'll deal with it.
09:32:11 <rbbratta> okay, so if we have fix in time, we can cherry-pick to stable and re-tag Danube 3.0.
09:32:33 <Mingjiang> Kanglin: https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/YARDSTICK-683
09:32:58 <rbbratta> #info looking at https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/YARDSTICK-683 for Danube 3.0
09:33:07 <rbbratta> #link https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/YARDSTICK-683
09:33:47 <rbbratta> can we close the other 3.0 issues  https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/YARDSTICK-683
09:34:28 <rbbratta> kubi001, JingLu: can we close the Danube 3.0 issues?
09:35:41 <rbbratta> err, what is the correct Jira process, do we close or resolve?
09:37:32 <kubi001> both will be OK
09:37:44 <rbbratta> okay, so Jira is good for 3.0
09:37:50 <kubi001> developer would use resolve
09:38:04 <kubi001> the creater of task and PTl would use close
09:38:05 <rbbratta> any other items for 3.0?
09:39:32 <rbbratta> #topic AoB
09:40:40 <rbbratta> https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/30509/ is ready for merging, everyone please review
09:40:47 <rbbratta> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/30509/
09:40:57 <rbbratta> #info https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/30509/ is ready for merging, please review
09:41:29 <kubi001> will do
09:41:45 <rbbratta> The other NSB releated patches from Deepak are squashed and review
09:41:53 <rbbratta> reviewed
09:43:06 <Mingjiang> ok
09:43:13 <rbbratta> we have a whole bunch of reviews in the queue
09:43:48 <rbbratta> maybe we can discuss at the US time-slot meeting
09:44:07 <rbbratta> okay, anything else?
09:45:00 <kubi001> not from me
09:45:54 <rbbratta> okay, thanks everyone
09:45:59 <rbbratta> #endmeeting