#onap-meeting: tsc-2018-01-18

Meeting started by kennypaul at 13:51:20 UTC (full logs).

Meeting summary

  1. rollcall (kennypaul, 13:53:59)
    1. Stephen Terrill, Ericsson (SteveT, 13:59:05)
    2. Xinhui Li, VMware (xinhuili, 13:59:35)
    3. Amir Levy, Cloudify (amir_levy, 13:59:58)
    4. mazin gilbert (AT&T) (gilbert, 14:00:37)
    5. Xiaojun Xie, China Telecom (Xiaojun, 14:00:48)
    6. Ranny Haiby, Nokia (RannyHaiby, 14:01:20)
    7. Frank Brockners, Cisco (frankbrockners, 14:01:59)
    8. Rajesh Gadiyar Intel (Rajesh, 14:02:57)
    9. Jason Hunt, IBM (JasonHunt, 14:03:02)
    10. Zhaoxing Meng, ZTE (Zhaoxing, 14:03:12)
    11. Chris Donley Huawei (cdonley, 14:03:14)
    12. proxy Jamil Chawki, Eric Debeau Orange (EricDebeau, 14:03:49)
    13. David Sauvageau, Bell (davidsauvageau, 14:04:31)
    14. Lingli Deng, CMCC (kennypaul, 14:08:07)

  2. Amsterdam Maint release (kennypaul, 14:09:19)
    1. proxy Sanchita Pathak, TechMahindra (Sanchita, 14:09:41)
    2. Gildas and Helen reviewed slides (kennypaul, 14:10:21)
    3. agreed that the maintenance release is approved (kennypaul, 14:11:19)

  3. M1 review (kennypaul, 14:11:33)
  4. AAF (kennypaul, 14:11:57)
    1. maturity- Sunil states that resilancy level will be 2 not 1 (kennypaul, 14:13:40)
    2. func req- not provided, may actually make sense (kennypaul, 14:15:46)
    3. StevetT must agree on expanded scope of CSM (kennypaul, 14:16:27)
    4. that will be a condition. (kennypaul, 14:16:45)

  5. AA1 (kennypaul, 14:16:55)
    1. maturity all 1s, (kennypaul, 14:17:31)
    2. Rajesh Gadiyar Intel joined again (Rajesh, 14:18:12)
    3. Jimmy- func req- don't believe that there is much coding needed (kennypaul, 14:18:31)
    4. Susana Sabater Vodafone (Susana, 14:18:42)
    5. epic needed for each use case for tracibility (kennypaul, 14:18:56)

  6. appc (kennypaul, 14:19:51)
    1. Randa- maturity - all filled in, func rec, scaling need addl resources and better requirements (kennypaul, 14:21:55)
    2. appc will support in place sw upgd (kennypaul, 14:22:54)
    3. change mgmt will be supported (kennypaul, 14:23:58)
    4. Agreed appc passes (kennypaul, 14:24:19)

  7. ccsdk (kennypaul, 14:24:32)
    1. Dan - s3p - need criteria for perf runtime (kennypaul, 14:25:55)
    2. questions as to what should be measured (kennypaul, 14:26:57)
    3. Jason need assistacne to validate what measurements should be (kennypaul, 14:28:05)
    4. Helen need 2-3 weeks to put in testing (kennypaul, 14:29:04)
    5. agreed that perf measurements set by M2 Jason & Helen (kennypaul, 14:30:45)
    6. agreed ccsdk passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:32:08)

  8. aai (kennypaul, 14:32:39)
    1. conditional approval also on scope expansion w/ image manager (kennypaul, 14:33:08)

  9. clamp (kennypaul, 14:33:22)
    1. s3p addressed, func req- no resources for autoscaling. (kennypaul, 14:34:06)
    2. Martial request MVP status (kennypaul, 14:35:17)
    3. MVP to be set next weel (kennypaul, 14:35:32)
    4. AGREED: clamp passes M1 (kennypaul, 14:35:57)

  10. cli (kennypaul, 14:36:24)
    1. s3p addressed, func req (kennypaul, 14:37:00)
    2. AGREED: cli passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:37:12)

  11. dcae (kennypaul, 14:37:49)
    1. I see no lot of progress on usability for many projects while it is very important to progress on the ONAP usage. (EricDebeau, 14:38:34)
    2. Lusheng - s3p some components are upstream from dcae prevents commuting to level 2 (kennypaul, 14:39:11)
    3. resiliency issue components are cdap and cloudify mgr (kennypaul, 14:42:02)
    4. level 2 ok with exception granted for cloudify (kennypaul, 14:43:25)
    5. condition w/ addl stateful component into (kennypaul, 14:43:49)
    6. AGREED: dcae passes M1 w/ conditions (kennypaul, 14:44:50)

  12. dmaap (kennypaul, 14:45:05)
    1. Ram- no issues (kennypaul, 14:45:21)
    2. agreed dmaap passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:45:36)

  13. aaf (kennypaul, 14:45:52)
    1. Ram- func req- no external components dependent on aaf (kennypaul, 14:47:20)
    2. no epics support func req - correct (kennypaul, 14:48:04)
    3. scope of csm - project definition change needed (kennypaul, 14:48:46)
    4. scope expansion vote to email (kennypaul, 14:50:22)
    5. condition still applies (kennypaul, 14:51:00)
    6. agreed doc passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:51:37)

  14. extapi (kennypaul, 14:52:20)
    1. Andy - need discussions w/ doc on use swagger (kennypaul, 14:53:55)
    2. AGREED: extapi passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:54:11)

  15. holmes (kennypaul, 14:54:27)
    1. Guangrong- s3p scaling may included need to check with CMCC (kennypaul, 14:55:28)
    2. AGREED: holmes passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:55:39)

  16. integration (kennypaul, 14:55:50)
    1. daily deployment and healtcheck (kennypaul, 14:56:35)
    2. Helen- maintenance releases too resource intensive (kennypaul, 14:57:44)
    3. AGREED: integration passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:58:00)

  17. logging (kennypaul, 14:58:15)
    1. Michael - s3p resilience depends on oom (kennypaul, 14:59:55)
    2. cii badging - nothing scoped (kennypaul, 15:01:46)
    3. ticket for getting code in sonar (kennypaul, 15:04:45)
    4. condition on reviewing security recommendations (kennypaul, 15:06:05)
    5. AGREED: logging passes m1 w./ condition (kennypaul, 15:06:36)

  18. modeling (kennypaul, 15:06:55)
    1. https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/CII+Badging+Program CII badgeing guide (kennypaul, 15:07:57)
    2. Deng - parser & hpa no requirements from hpa (kennypaul, 15:09:12)
    3. AGREED: modeling passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:09:24)

  19. msb (kennypaul, 15:09:40)
    1. Huabing - no func req alignment (kennypaul, 15:10:55)
    2. AGREED: msb passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:11:13)

  20. music (kennypaul, 15:11:24)
    1. s3p SteveT as a new project should all be 0 (kennypaul, 15:12:50)
    2. Bharath - code already running within AT&T confirmed that already meet reqs (kennypaul, 15:13:51)
    3. badging reg to be done (kennypaul, 15:14:13)
    4. AGREED: music passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:14:29)

  21. multicloud (kennypaul, 15:14:41)
    1. Xinhui - azure support - no response from MS yet. (kennypaul, 15:16:09)
    2. Michael will work with Xinhui to assist (kennypaul, 15:16:39)
    3. azure is a stretch goal for this release (kennypaul, 15:17:07)
    4. AGREED: multicloud passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:17:44)

  22. oof (kennypaul, 15:18:01)
    1. Shankar- no concerns (kennypaul, 15:18:43)
    2. for s3p need help from OOM for resiliency (kennypaul, 15:19:31)
    3. just need to create a jira (kennypaul, 15:19:50)
    4. AGREED: oof passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:20:10)

  23. oom (kennypaul, 15:20:18)
    1. Michael - s3p provides a std kubernetes framework (kennypaul, 15:22:52)
    2. need to to update s3p form carrier grade doc. (kennypaul, 15:24:16)
    3. func req oom does not do network functions (kennypaul, 15:25:39)
    4. AGREED: oom passes m1 with condition of s3p update (kennypaul, 15:26:47)
    5. topic (kennypaul, 15:26:54)
    6. Pam- func req scaling no resources from policy and appc teams (kennypaul, 15:28:31)
    7. AGREED: policy passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:29:05)

  24. portal (kennypaul, 15:29:34)
    1. Leiming cicd will be assisted w/ respoources from Tech Mahindra (kennypaul, 15:31:08)
    2. AGREED: portal passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:31:20)

  25. sdc (kennypaul, 15:31:37)
    1. Michael L - s3p manageability (kennypaul, 15:32:31)
    2. also covering vid in this context (kennypaul, 15:32:58)
    3. supporting manual scaling - Nokia and Intel resources assisting. (kennypaul, 15:34:15)
    4. AGREED: sdc passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:35:08)

  26. vid (kennypaul, 15:35:18)
    1. Michael L - s3p performance (kennypaul, 15:35:44)
    2. should be 1 not 0 (kennypaul, 15:36:06)
    3. same sdc manageability note applies (kennypaul, 15:36:49)
    4. AGREED: vid passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:36:58)

  27. sdnc (kennypaul, 15:37:19)
    1. Dan- benchmark to measurement (kennypaul, 15:38:17)
    2. by m2 (kennypaul, 15:38:24)
    3. agreed sdnc passes m1 with conditon (kennypaul, 15:38:47)

  28. so (kennypaul, 15:39:07)
    1. Seshu - s3p resilience is 1 component but should be 2 at platform level (kennypaul, 15:40:15)
    2. risks updated - resources promised, needed by M2 (kennypaul, 15:41:44)
    3. also code migration upstream possible risk (kennypaul, 15:44:00)
    4. AGREED: so passes m1 with condition of resources (kennypaul, 15:44:49)

  29. usecaseui (kennypaul, 15:45:04)
    1. Shentao - epics were inconsistent - has now been corrected. (kennypaul, 15:46:18)
    2. AGREED: usecaseui passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:46:38)

  30. vfc (kennypaul, 15:46:48)
    1. Yan - s3p lack of resources is a risk for component level scalability (kennypaul, 15:48:45)
    2. func req somewhat unclear for autoscaling (kennypaul, 15:50:53)
    3. Peng will provide the info needed. (kennypaul, 15:52:00)
    4. vfc can commit if other projects can commit (kennypaul, 15:54:16)
    5. polic dependancy (kennypaul, 15:55:47)
    6. AGREED: vfc passes m1 - will need resources for m2 (kennypaul, 15:56:35)

  31. vnfrqts (kennypaul, 15:58:00)
    1. AGREED: vnfrqts passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:58:16)

  32. vnfsdk (kennypaul, 15:59:01)
    1. AGREED: vnfsdk passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:59:17)

  33. vvp (kennypaul, 15:59:23)
    1. scope change proposed (kennypaul, 15:59:41)
    2. to be discussed before m2 (kennypaul, 16:00:10)
    3. not reviewed. (kennypaul, 16:00:28)

  34. functional requirements (kennypaul, 16:00:40)
    1. Alla can we approve? (kennypaul, 16:00:52)
    2. Lingli resources for manual and auto scaling for vfs (kennypaul, 16:01:37)

  35. vfc (kennypaul, 16:03:20)
    1. removing autoscaling conditons from vfc (kennypaul, 16:04:02)
    2. to condition to be moved to func req approval. (kennypaul, 16:04:39)

  36. func reqs (kennypaul, 16:04:49)
    1. vdns and volte autoscaling impacted by resources (kennypaul, 16:06:00)
    2. functional requirements that have e-2-e commitment from projects HPA (kennypaul, 16:07:32)
    3. change management also fully supported and PNF (kennypaul, 16:08:00)
    4. also manual scaling (kennypaul, 16:10:07)
    5. Alla to send email summarizing. (kennypaul, 16:12:02)


Meeting ended at 16:12:13 UTC (full logs).

Action items

  1. (none)


People present (lines said)

  1. kennypaul (163)
  2. collabot (7)
  3. frankbrockners (2)
  4. Rajesh (2)
  5. EricDebeau (2)
  6. davidsauvageau (1)
  7. RannyHaiby (1)
  8. amir_levy (1)
  9. JasonHunt (1)
  10. xinhuili (1)
  11. SteveT (1)
  12. cdonley (1)
  13. Susana (1)
  14. gilbert (1)
  15. Xiaojun (1)
  16. Sanchita (1)
  17. Zhaoxing (1)
  18. phrobb (0)


Generated by MeetBot 0.1.4.