============================= #onap-meeting: tsc-2018-01-18 ============================= Meeting started by kennypaul at 13:51:20 UTC. The full logs are available at http://ircbot.wl.linuxfoundation.org/meetings/onap-meeting/2018/onap-meeting.2018-01-18-13.51.log.html . Meeting summary --------------- * rollcall (kennypaul, 13:53:59) * Stephen Terrill, Ericsson (SteveT, 13:59:05) * Xinhui Li, VMware (xinhuili, 13:59:35) * Amir Levy, Cloudify (amir_levy, 13:59:58) * mazin gilbert (AT&T) (gilbert, 14:00:37) * Xiaojun Xie, China Telecom (Xiaojun, 14:00:48) * Ranny Haiby, Nokia (RannyHaiby, 14:01:20) * Frank Brockners, Cisco (frankbrockners, 14:01:59) * Rajesh Gadiyar Intel (Rajesh, 14:02:57) * Jason Hunt, IBM (JasonHunt, 14:03:02) * Zhaoxing Meng, ZTE (Zhaoxing, 14:03:12) * Chris Donley Huawei (cdonley, 14:03:14) * proxy Jamil Chawki, Eric Debeau Orange (EricDebeau, 14:03:49) * David Sauvageau, Bell (davidsauvageau, 14:04:31) * Lingli Deng, CMCC (kennypaul, 14:08:07) * Amsterdam Maint release (kennypaul, 14:09:19) * proxy Sanchita Pathak, TechMahindra (Sanchita, 14:09:41) * Gildas and Helen reviewed slides (kennypaul, 14:10:21) * agreed that the maintenance release is approved (kennypaul, 14:11:19) * M1 review (kennypaul, 14:11:33) * AAF (kennypaul, 14:11:57) * maturity- Sunil states that resilancy level will be 2 not 1 (kennypaul, 14:13:40) * func req- not provided, may actually make sense (kennypaul, 14:15:46) * StevetT must agree on expanded scope of CSM (kennypaul, 14:16:27) * that will be a condition. (kennypaul, 14:16:45) * AA1 (kennypaul, 14:16:55) * maturity all 1s, (kennypaul, 14:17:31) * Rajesh Gadiyar Intel joined again (Rajesh, 14:18:12) * Jimmy- func req- don't believe that there is much coding needed (kennypaul, 14:18:31) * Susana Sabater Vodafone (Susana, 14:18:42) * epic needed for each use case for tracibility (kennypaul, 14:18:56) * appc (kennypaul, 14:19:51) * Randa- maturity - all filled in, func rec, scaling need addl resources and better requirements (kennypaul, 14:21:55) * appc will support in place sw upgd (kennypaul, 14:22:54) * change mgmt will be supported (kennypaul, 14:23:58) * Agreed appc passes (kennypaul, 14:24:19) * ccsdk (kennypaul, 14:24:32) * Dan - s3p - need criteria for perf runtime (kennypaul, 14:25:55) * questions as to what should be measured (kennypaul, 14:26:57) * Jason need assistacne to validate what measurements should be (kennypaul, 14:28:05) * Helen need 2-3 weeks to put in testing (kennypaul, 14:29:04) * agreed that perf measurements set by M2 Jason & Helen (kennypaul, 14:30:45) * agreed ccsdk passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:32:08) * aai (kennypaul, 14:32:39) * conditional approval also on scope expansion w/ image manager (kennypaul, 14:33:08) * clamp (kennypaul, 14:33:22) * s3p addressed, func req- no resources for autoscaling. (kennypaul, 14:34:06) * Martial request MVP status (kennypaul, 14:35:17) * MVP to be set next weel (kennypaul, 14:35:32) * AGREED: clamp passes M1 (kennypaul, 14:35:57) * cli (kennypaul, 14:36:24) * s3p addressed, func req (kennypaul, 14:37:00) * AGREED: cli passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:37:12) * dcae (kennypaul, 14:37:49) * I see no lot of progress on usability for many projects while it is very important to progress on the ONAP usage. (EricDebeau, 14:38:34) * Lusheng - s3p some components are upstream from dcae prevents commuting to level 2 (kennypaul, 14:39:11) * resiliency issue components are cdap and cloudify mgr (kennypaul, 14:42:02) * level 2 ok with exception granted for cloudify (kennypaul, 14:43:25) * condition w/ addl stateful component into (kennypaul, 14:43:49) * AGREED: dcae passes M1 w/ conditions (kennypaul, 14:44:50) * dmaap (kennypaul, 14:45:05) * Ram- no issues (kennypaul, 14:45:21) * agreed dmaap passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:45:36) * aaf (kennypaul, 14:45:52) * Ram- func req- no external components dependent on aaf (kennypaul, 14:47:20) * no epics support func req - correct (kennypaul, 14:48:04) * scope of csm - project definition change needed (kennypaul, 14:48:46) * scope expansion vote to email (kennypaul, 14:50:22) * condition still applies (kennypaul, 14:51:00) * agreed doc passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:51:37) * extapi (kennypaul, 14:52:20) * Andy - need discussions w/ doc on use swagger (kennypaul, 14:53:55) * AGREED: extapi passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:54:11) * holmes (kennypaul, 14:54:27) * Guangrong- s3p scaling may included need to check with CMCC (kennypaul, 14:55:28) * AGREED: holmes passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:55:39) * integration (kennypaul, 14:55:50) * daily deployment and healtcheck (kennypaul, 14:56:35) * Helen- maintenance releases too resource intensive (kennypaul, 14:57:44) * AGREED: integration passes m1 (kennypaul, 14:58:00) * logging (kennypaul, 14:58:15) * Michael - s3p resilience depends on oom (kennypaul, 14:59:55) * cii badging - nothing scoped (kennypaul, 15:01:46) * ticket for getting code in sonar (kennypaul, 15:04:45) * condition on reviewing security recommendations (kennypaul, 15:06:05) * AGREED: logging passes m1 w./ condition (kennypaul, 15:06:36) * modeling (kennypaul, 15:06:55) * LINK: https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/CII+Badging+Program CII badgeing guide (kennypaul, 15:07:57) * Deng - parser & hpa no requirements from hpa (kennypaul, 15:09:12) * AGREED: modeling passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:09:24) * msb (kennypaul, 15:09:40) * Huabing - no func req alignment (kennypaul, 15:10:55) * AGREED: msb passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:11:13) * music (kennypaul, 15:11:24) * s3p SteveT as a new project should all be 0 (kennypaul, 15:12:50) * Bharath - code already running within AT&T confirmed that already meet reqs (kennypaul, 15:13:51) * badging reg to be done (kennypaul, 15:14:13) * AGREED: music passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:14:29) * multicloud (kennypaul, 15:14:41) * Xinhui - azure support - no response from MS yet. (kennypaul, 15:16:09) * Michael will work with Xinhui to assist (kennypaul, 15:16:39) * azure is a stretch goal for this release (kennypaul, 15:17:07) * AGREED: multicloud passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:17:44) * oof (kennypaul, 15:18:01) * Shankar- no concerns (kennypaul, 15:18:43) * for s3p need help from OOM for resiliency (kennypaul, 15:19:31) * just need to create a jira (kennypaul, 15:19:50) * AGREED: oof passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:20:10) * oom (kennypaul, 15:20:18) * Michael - s3p provides a std kubernetes framework (kennypaul, 15:22:52) * need to to update s3p form carrier grade doc. (kennypaul, 15:24:16) * func req oom does not do network functions (kennypaul, 15:25:39) * AGREED: oom passes m1 with condition of s3p update (kennypaul, 15:26:47) * topic (kennypaul, 15:26:54) * Pam- func req scaling no resources from policy and appc teams (kennypaul, 15:28:31) * AGREED: policy passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:29:05) * portal (kennypaul, 15:29:34) * Leiming cicd will be assisted w/ respoources from Tech Mahindra (kennypaul, 15:31:08) * AGREED: portal passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:31:20) * sdc (kennypaul, 15:31:37) * Michael L - s3p manageability (kennypaul, 15:32:31) * also covering vid in this context (kennypaul, 15:32:58) * supporting manual scaling - Nokia and Intel resources assisting. (kennypaul, 15:34:15) * AGREED: sdc passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:35:08) * vid (kennypaul, 15:35:18) * Michael L - s3p performance (kennypaul, 15:35:44) * should be 1 not 0 (kennypaul, 15:36:06) * same sdc manageability note applies (kennypaul, 15:36:49) * AGREED: vid passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:36:58) * sdnc (kennypaul, 15:37:19) * Dan- benchmark to measurement (kennypaul, 15:38:17) * by m2 (kennypaul, 15:38:24) * agreed sdnc passes m1 with conditon (kennypaul, 15:38:47) * so (kennypaul, 15:39:07) * Seshu - s3p resilience is 1 component but should be 2 at platform level (kennypaul, 15:40:15) * risks updated - resources promised, needed by M2 (kennypaul, 15:41:44) * also code migration upstream possible risk (kennypaul, 15:44:00) * AGREED: so passes m1 with condition of resources (kennypaul, 15:44:49) * usecaseui (kennypaul, 15:45:04) * Shentao - epics were inconsistent - has now been corrected. (kennypaul, 15:46:18) * AGREED: usecaseui passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:46:38) * vfc (kennypaul, 15:46:48) * Yan - s3p lack of resources is a risk for component level scalability (kennypaul, 15:48:45) * func req somewhat unclear for autoscaling (kennypaul, 15:50:53) * Peng will provide the info needed. (kennypaul, 15:52:00) * vfc can commit if other projects can commit (kennypaul, 15:54:16) * polic dependancy (kennypaul, 15:55:47) * AGREED: vfc passes m1 - will need resources for m2 (kennypaul, 15:56:35) * vnfrqts (kennypaul, 15:58:00) * AGREED: vnfrqts passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:58:16) * vnfsdk (kennypaul, 15:59:01) * AGREED: vnfsdk passes m1 (kennypaul, 15:59:17) * vvp (kennypaul, 15:59:23) * scope change proposed (kennypaul, 15:59:41) * to be discussed before m2 (kennypaul, 16:00:10) * not reviewed. (kennypaul, 16:00:28) * functional requirements (kennypaul, 16:00:40) * Alla can we approve? (kennypaul, 16:00:52) * Lingli resources for manual and auto scaling for vfs (kennypaul, 16:01:37) * vfc (kennypaul, 16:03:20) * removing autoscaling conditons from vfc (kennypaul, 16:04:02) * to condition to be moved to func req approval. (kennypaul, 16:04:39) * func reqs (kennypaul, 16:04:49) * vdns and volte autoscaling impacted by resources (kennypaul, 16:06:00) * functional requirements that have e-2-e commitment from projects HPA (kennypaul, 16:07:32) * change management also fully supported and PNF (kennypaul, 16:08:00) * also manual scaling (kennypaul, 16:10:07) * Alla to send email summarizing. (kennypaul, 16:12:02) Meeting ended at 16:12:13 UTC. People present (lines said) --------------------------- * kennypaul (163) * collabot (7) * frankbrockners (2) * Rajesh (2) * EricDebeau (2) * davidsauvageau (1) * RannyHaiby (1) * amir_levy (1) * JasonHunt (1) * xinhuili (1) * SteveT (1) * cdonley (1) * Susana (1) * gilbert (1) * Xiaojun (1) * Sanchita (1) * Zhaoxing (1) * phrobb (0) Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4