============================= #onap-meeting: tsc-2018-03-22 ============================= Meeting started by kennypaul at 13:43:12 UTC. The full logs are available at http://ircbot.wl.linuxfoundation.org/meetings/onap-meeting/2018/onap-meeting.2018-03-22-13.43.log.html . Meeting summary --------------- * rollcall (kennypaul, 13:43:51) * Stephen Terrill, Ericsson (SteveT, 13:56:48) * Rajesh Gadiyar Intel (RajeshGadiyar, 13:59:51) * Chris Donley, Huawei (cdonley, 14:00:35) * Xinhui Li, VMware (xinhuili, 14:01:05) * Susana Sabater, Vodafone (Susana, 14:01:09) * Jason Hunt for IBM (unable to join the IRC session today) (phrobb, 14:02:56) * Ildiko Vancsa, OpenStack Foundation (ildikov, 14:03:10) * Lingli Deng, China Mobile (Lingli_Deng, 14:03:19) * Ranny Haiby, Nokia (RannyHaiby, 14:03:23) * Giles Heron, Cisco (proxy for Frank Brockners) (gilesheron, 14:03:37) * General Info (SteveT, 14:05:20) * ONAP recieved blackduck Open Source Rookie of the year. (SteveT, 14:05:42) * proxy Sanchita Pathak, TechMahindra (Sanchita, 14:05:54) * Trying to do one physical F2F a quater. (SteveT, 14:06:20) * David Sauvageau, Bell (davidsauvageau, 14:06:39) * Zhaoxing Meng, ZTE (Zhaoxing_Meng, 14:09:14) * proxy Yoav Kluger (Amdocs) (kennypaul, 14:09:16) * proxy Brian Freeman at&t (Brianfreeman, 14:09:54) * discussion of aligning F2F to release calendar (kennypaul, 14:12:50) * Discussion on whether to have a Virtual developers event. Different views were expressed, however there was gravity towards aligning the meetings around project milestones. (SteveT, 14:13:23) * Request to avoid having M4 around the F2F. (SteveT, 14:13:56) * Invitation for Cross Colloboration, Ildikó Váncsa, technical lead, open stack foundation. (SteveT, 14:15:29) * Ildiko presented some of the existing colloborations they had. Special call out for testing, highlighting openstack and OPNFV XCI (testing while developing, not waiting for the stable release), and others. Highlighted Interperability, HA and robustness testing. (SteveT, 14:22:22) * suggested areas for colloboration as well around cloud edge computing. (SteveT, 14:22:44) * Referred also to ETSI NFV collaboration as standards - Opensource collaboration (SteveT, 14:27:27) * Ildikó is attending ONS next week and is open for any discussion. (SteveT, 14:28:22) * There was a question whether there was a representation (graph) on the existing colloborations. (SteveT, 14:34:00) * The slides will be on the TSC meeting agenda wiki for today. (SteveT, 14:36:08) * Release Status, Gildas Lanilis. (SteveT, 14:36:18) * M4 Review is next week. Request to PTLs to have the M4 template filled in by Tuesday COB March 27 (SteveT, 14:37:24) * Code coverage. 70+ repos reached 50% target. 15 b/n 0-50%, but 13 reporting 0 testing linecoverage. (SteveT, 14:38:41) * REquest to fill in the vulnerability Thread Report. Note, also this will be used in the release note. Request to use the latest component, and also do some pruning. (SteveT, 14:42:43) * Preventing self commit is check restriction is now implemented. (SteveT, 14:43:07) * If there are no critical security issues, no need to fill out the template. (SteveT, 14:46:23) * ptl self-commit vote did not pass. (kennypaul, 14:50:47) * Votes needed to pass: 10, Votes cast: 11, Votes in favor: 7, Votes against: 4, Abstentions: 8 (kennypaul, 14:51:19) * Identified Risks. CII Badging. For beijing release, focus on Critical known vulnerabilities. This may have the consequence of some projects not reaching 100% passing for CII passing, but 95%. (SteveT, 14:51:45) * Risk 2, DM modelling implications on SDC. Risk is still there but progress is being made. (SteveT, 14:54:47) * LINK: https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/Beijing+Risks (kennypaul, 14:55:10) * Risk 3, Risk of late delivery of Nitrogon. APP-C has nitrogen and is working with it. Progressing, but still a risk. (SteveT, 14:55:55) * Risk 4 late delivery of AAF. APP-C has a early delivery this. Risk is medium, PTL is confident though. (SteveT, 14:56:45) * risk 5 Large code merge in SO. The code merge is done, now working on code coverage. PTL confident. (SteveT, 14:57:41) * risk 7 A solution is proposed for secure communication, still need to see how integration has access to a CA (SteveT, 15:01:23) * risk 8 OOM, large code drop and late commits comming at the end. Expect that updates are to be required after code freeze. (SteveT, 15:04:00) * Request to inform OOM of changes to container strategy to be taken into account at M3. (SteveT, 15:07:40) * risk 9 OOM/Heat - docker image download throttling causing timeouts. Suggestion to write up a best practice as a work-around. (SteveT, 15:10:12) * risk 10 VNF requirements - Trying to identify what are testable, still open. (SteveT, 15:13:50) * Multi VIM/Cloud R2 delivery risk (SteveT, 15:15:01) * R2 muti VIM/Cloud deliver has been blocked by "-2" (SteveT, 15:15:33) * Vote was held with majority pass; following the TSC charter. The question is about removing the -2 in gerrit. (SteveT, 15:17:45) * Technicality now on how to remove the -2. Request to see if the committer can remove the -2. (SteveT, 15:22:07) * Beijing Architecture (SteveT, 15:23:30) * LINK: https://wiki.onap.org/display/DW/Beijing+Architecture (kennypaul, 15:23:57) * question was raised about the overlap between VID and the UC UI. It was replied that this was required for short term, but the teams are talking. It was said that this should now be put on the backlog of the architecture team. (SteveT, 15:25:06) * phrobb votes +1 for Jason Hunt of IBM (phrobb, 15:27:00) * my vote proxy for Yoav Kluger (Amdocs) (kennypaul, 15:27:23) * VOTE: Voted on "Does the TSC approve the ONAP Beijing Architecture v2.0.3?" Results are, +1: 10 (kennypaul, 15:28:36) * gildaslanilis votes +1 for Lingli Deng of China Mobile (phrobb, 15:28:59) * AGREED: the TSC approves the ONAP Beijing Architecture v2.0.3 (kennypaul, 15:29:34) * New Seed Code (SteveT, 15:31:11) * SDC, monitoring design. Minor impact on clamp. (SteveT, 15:31:29) * not supporting any MVP features. Planed to use it for the close loop. (SteveT, 15:32:04) * The purpose is to make it available for people to understand the capabilities, and its a stretch code. It is stated that it won't risk the other activities. (SteveT, 15:34:19) * Requesting a new committer to come with it. (SteveT, 15:34:53) * This discussion will move to the mail-list (SteveT, 15:36:19) * Casablanca branch (SteveT, 15:37:07) * Request to start branch for CAsablanca for RC0 (SteveT, 15:37:35) Meeting ended at 15:39:02 UTC. People present (lines said) --------------------------- * SteveT (45) * kennypaul (15) * collabot` (9) * phrobb (5) * gildaslanilis (3) * Susana (2) * jamil (2) * gilesheron (2) * Zhaoxing_Meng (2) * xinhuili (2) * cdonley (2) * davidsauvageau (1) * ningso (1) * Brianfreeman (1) * RajeshGadiyar (1) * RannyHaiby__ (1) * ildikov (1) * RannyHaiby (1) * Sanchita (1) * Lingli_Deng (1) Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4