============================= #onap-meeting: tsc-2018-04-19 ============================= Meeting started by kennypaul at 13:46:36 UTC. The full logs are available at http://ircbot.wl.linuxfoundation.org/meetings/onap-meeting/2018/onap-meeting.2018-04-19-13.46.log.html . Meeting summary --------------- * rollcall (kennypaul, 13:47:29) * Stephen Terrill, Ericsson (SteveT, 13:59:04) * Rajesh Gadiyar Intel (RajeshGadiyar, 13:59:10) * Chris Donley Huawei (cdonley, 13:59:43) * Eric Debeau, Orange (EricDebeau, 14:00:13) * Frank Brockners, Cisco (frankbrockners, 14:00:17) * Jason Hunt, IBM (JasonHunt, 14:02:17) * Ranny Haiby, Nokia (RannyHaiby, 14:02:26) * David Sauvageau, Bell (davidsauvageau, 14:02:30) * Dhananjay Pavgi, Tech Mahindra Ltd (DhananjayPavgi, 14:04:22) * Xiaojun Xie, China Telecom (Xiaojun, 14:04:50) * Housekeeping (SteveT, 14:06:29) * Meeting change requests, please use the template (SteveT, 14:06:54) * There is community feedback page, open to feedback and additions. (SteveT, 14:07:18) * - TSC attendance tracking is avaible. (SteveT, 14:08:23) * Xinhui Li, VMware (xinhuili, 14:09:26) * The June developers event is posted on the onap wiki. (SteveT, 14:13:46) * murat Tupcuu Turk Telecom (kennypaul, 14:14:28) * Still seeking feedback on whether there is value in colocating OPNFV & ONAP developer event. (SteveT, 14:15:59) * Lingli Deng, China Mobile (kennypaul, 14:16:16) * Suggestion to push Dublin Release F2F to January rather than december (kennypaul, 14:17:44) * Known Vulnerability Analysis update  (kennypaul, 14:18:04) * SteveT presented his slides (kennypaul, 14:18:31) * Ning So, Reliance Jio (ningso, 14:18:31) * [policy] will be addressed today. (kennypaul, 14:20:10) * APEX PDP in ONAP Policy Framework (kennypaul, 14:21:10) * Liam Fallon shared his slided (kennypaul, 14:21:33) * Policy is the decision making component of onap (kennypaul, 14:22:38) * other components responsible for enforcing the rules policy provides to them (kennypaul, 14:23:30) * technology agnostic (kennypaul, 14:23:43) * supports moltiple PDP types (kennypaul, 14:24:09) * PDP-X for XACML, PDP-D for Drools (kennypaul, 14:25:35) * PDP-x best for fine-grained policy, PDP-D best fot stateful policies (kennypaul, 14:26:24) * APEX is a new code contribution for ONAP (kennypaul, 14:26:46) * APEX extends the policy framework in design time and runtime (kennypaul, 14:28:47) * runtime requires a single JSON file to be pushed (kennypaul, 14:29:18) * Other plugins can be written (kennypaul, 14:29:50) * supports large deployments. policy monitoring (kennypaul, 14:30:29) * Q- multiple policy engines ? (kennypaul, 14:31:07) * A- captured via policy modles and then translated. (kennypaul, 14:31:40) * discussion od implementation (kennypaul, 14:32:44) * main take away here is that there is a new code contribution coming in that the community needs to be aware of (kennypaul, 14:33:40) * please attend the policy meeting or offline (kennypaul, 14:35:24) * request preso to Arch Sub meeting (kennypaul, 14:35:41) * Beijing RC0 Review (kennypaul, 14:36:21) * gildaslanilis shared his slide decl (kennypaul, 14:37:16) * healthchecks OOM 9done, Heat 16 done, WIP- OOM 16, Heat 8 (kennypaul, 14:38:23) * CSIT 19 projects pass, 4 WIP, 1 no plan (kennypaul, 14:39:18) * ~ 30 pending commits to be reviewed (kennypaul, 14:40:11) * clamp good (kennypaul, 14:41:48) * ccsdk no heat/oom needed (kennypaul, 14:42:26) * dmaap had met M4 delioverabes (kennypaul, 14:43:10) * holmes passed M4 (kennypaul, 14:43:25) * modeling good (kennypaul, 14:43:42) * msb good (kennypaul, 14:44:00) * vid cist is wip, oom healthcheck is now passing (kennypaul, 14:46:02) * appc csit 1 failure coce coverage now > 50% (kennypaul, 14:47:06) * aai oom now passing (kennypaul, 14:47:31) * vulnerability will be asddressed by RC1 (kennypaul, 14:47:57) * multicloud, so, vfc, oom, integration, vnfrts, doc all palss (kennypaul, 14:49:08) * policy should padss my today (kennypaul, 14:49:25) * vnfsdc healthcheck should be complete today (kennypaul, 14:49:59) * dcae - eta for oom apr 26 (kennypaul, 14:51:07) * cli - oom patch submitted eta tomorrow, heat healthcheck passing (kennypaul, 14:52:35) * healthchecks need to be run by the person submitting the patch first. (kennypaul, 14:53:17) * music at this stage only libraries. passes in heat, N/A for OOM in this release. embedded in portal (kennypaul, 14:54:49) * portal - csit and oom wip- blocker for integration (kennypaul, 14:55:30) * csit passing now. (kennypaul, 14:55:59) * cassandra dependencies. issues identified and being worked on (kennypaul, 14:57:16) * cassandra fix has been submitted - need updated version of Kubernetes 1.8.10 (kennypaul, 15:00:43) * extapi - cist still failing - fix applied to be tested, heat now working (kennypaul, 15:03:20) * oom heralthcheck apr 26 (kennypaul, 15:03:39) * sdnc- csit now passing and heat. oom still failing (kennypaul, 15:04:05) * oom issues unknown. will contact james for debuggin assisatance (kennypaul, 15:05:38) * sdc- heat heat by tomorrow, oom april 26?? code coverage- code broken fixed (kennypaul, 15:07:34) * will be back to 30% by end of week, other is passing internally, but not with onap (kennypaul, 15:08:59) * eta RC1 for 50% code coverage (kennypaul, 15:09:16) * aaf- code coverage not met - 2 people assigend (kennypaul, 15:10:32) * working on heat first priority, eta tomorrow - marco assisting (kennypaul, 15:13:17) * oom eta april 26 (kennypaul, 15:13:47) * priority working system, heat, oom and then code coverage (kennypaul, 15:15:28) * oof- 17 jiras that should have been addresses are still open, healthchecks fialing (kennypaul, 15:16:49) * heat eta tomorrow, oom reviewing eta apr 26 (kennypaul, 15:17:33) * 17 pending jiras will be addressed by RC1 (kennypaul, 15:18:55) * so is dependent on oof - no testing of this yet (kennypaul, 15:19:21) * requesting help with oom (kennypaul, 15:20:16) * asking for expedited reviews of optf-has commit - sastry ooo (kennypaul, 15:23:41) * catherine will provide resources to oof team, so team will also provide help (kennypaul, 15:25:20) * vvp passes m4 noe, says Heat is an N/A item (kennypaul, 15:26:36) * logging - no Heat n/a . code coverage blocked by a shared java/python pom file (kennypaul, 15:28:48) * no csit plan- no library now, casablanca deliverable. Michael O to write something. (kennypaul, 15:30:49) * usecase-ui M4- not finding codecoverage and FOSS (kennypaul, 15:33:18) * shentow needs to provide an update (kennypaul, 15:33:54) * no longer at quorom, but consensus of those on call all pass m4 and are approved for RC0 (kennypaul, 15:37:30) * integration (kennypaul, 15:37:42) * helenchen shared her status page - most pairwise testing not done. (kennypaul, 15:39:05) * request to review again on PTL meeting. (kennypaul, 15:40:09) * suggestion that we have NOT passed M4 (kennypaul, 15:41:59) * discussions of checklists (kennypaul, 15:43:43) * gildaslanilis recommends that any runtime projects that pass oom healthcheck pass RC0 (kennypaul, 15:44:55) * need more stringent enforcement as we move from Rc0 -> Rc1 > Rc2 (kennypaul, 15:47:21) * need to agree what each gate specifically means (kennypaul, 15:51:01) * brian f recommends that no one cuts a beijing branch until they pass oom healthcheck (kennypaul, 15:54:18) * "unless the jira ticket comes from helen folks shouldn't be working on it at this point" (kennypaul, 15:55:14) * ptls should check with helen on status of pairwise testing (kennypaul, 15:57:59) * mazin suggests clear definition of RC0 for Beiging, may be different for Casablanca (kennypaul, 15:58:35) * mazin would like to see pairwise testing included as an RC0 (kennypaul, 15:59:18) * helen points out critaria set at santaclara (kennypaul, 15:59:56) * much discussion over deliverables / requiorements (kennypaul, 16:03:38) * mazin concerned over changing the dates (kennypaul, 16:04:46) * action gildaslanilis to send email on what projects passed from his perspective. (kennypaul, 16:05:31) * Will review again at next week's meeting and then present options to the TSC. (kennypaul, 16:08:56) * helen reviewed S3P requirements we committed to (kennypaul, 16:09:37) * correction - gildaslanilis to present status at the next PTL Meeting - NOT via email. (kennypaul, 16:13:13) Meeting ended at 19:27:52 UTC. People present (lines said) --------------------------- * kennypaul (102) * SteveT (7) * collabot` (6) * Bf1936 (2) * DhananjayPavgi (2) * davidsauvageau (1) * frankbrockners (1) * Xiaojun (1) * ningso (1) * RajeshGadiyar (1) * JasonHunt (1) * xinhuili (1) * cdonley (1) * RannyHaiby (1) * EricDebeau (1) * phrobb (0) * gildaslanilis (0) Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4