18:23:28 <anipbu> #startmeeting Armoury Weekly
18:23:28 <odl_meetbot> Meeting started Mon Oct 12 18:23:28 2015 UTC.  The chair is anipbu. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html.
18:23:28 <odl_meetbot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
18:23:28 <odl_meetbot> The meeting name has been set to 'armoury_weekly'
18:23:38 <anipbu> #topic Roll Call
18:23:45 <anipbu> #info anipbu
18:23:52 <anipbu> please pound in for ppl attending the meeting
18:23:52 <subh> #info subh
18:24:02 <ariel_noy> #info ariel_noy
18:24:23 <edwarnicke> #info edwarnicke
18:24:29 <anipbu> Today we will discuss the following...
18:24:33 <anipbu> #On going tasks
18:24:36 <anipbu> #info On going tasks
18:24:48 <anipbu> #info Be release plan
18:25:00 <anipbu> #info Interaction workflow
18:25:09 <anipbu> #info SFC use case with Tacker
18:25:16 <anipbu> #info feature list
18:25:36 <anipbu> Do you guys have anything you would like to discuss?
18:26:27 <anipbu> #topic On Going Tasks
18:27:30 <anipbu> any updates from folks on their tasks?
18:27:34 <edwarnicke> mmarsale1: You there?
18:27:51 <edwarnicke> anipbu: Do we have a list of who is working on what?
18:28:29 <subh> anipbu: i am working on driver-registry model. I discussed with Alexis about this in last meeting. https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/28265/
18:28:34 <anipbu> #info https://trello.com/b/zsERKgeV/odl-armoury
18:28:41 <anipbu> #undo
18:28:41 <odl_meetbot> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0x1ab7850>
18:28:45 <anipbu> #link https://trello.com/b/zsERKgeV/odl-armoury
18:28:52 <edwarnicke> subh: I can't view that link, is it a draft?
18:28:57 <subh> yes
18:29:28 <subh> what should I do to make it visible ?
18:31:01 <anipbu> I cannot access the link as well as well.
18:32:17 <subh> anipbu: should I try to add odl-armooury in reviewer ?
18:33:12 <anipbu> I'm not familiar with the draft capability.  I normally upload my drafts as a normal patch but with the WIP in the message.
18:33:24 <edwarnicke> subh: If you would make it visible it would be easier for folks to see it :)
18:33:50 <edwarnicke> anipbu: I tend to do what you just suggested myself...  (In fact, I think I was the one who started doing that at ODL :) )
18:33:51 <subh> ok please go ahed, I will try to look for the option and let you know
18:34:24 <anipbu> #action subh to make driver-registry model patch visible for community
18:34:40 <anipbu> I have also updated the trello with the link to the patch
18:34:51 <anipbu> https://trello.com/c/Gb6QcQ9b/3-driver-registery-model
18:35:35 <anipbu> subh: any comments you would like to make on the driver registry model before we move on?
18:36:06 <subh> I think I need the comments on the model.
18:36:16 <subh> i have discussued with Alexis once
18:36:48 <subh> that I think we can do it over mails .
18:37:00 <anipbu> when you have made the patch visibility for the rest of the community, please send an email to the mailing list.  thanks.
18:37:15 <subh> sure anipbu :)
18:39:01 <anipbu> Any other updates from folks on on going tasks?
18:40:58 <ariel_noy> I will need guide how to import object from other modules that is not in the base
18:41:45 <edwarnicke> ariel_noy: Say more
18:41:49 <edwarnicke> ariel_noy: I don't quite follow you
18:41:55 <ariel_noy> As the workload manager use the catalog and drivers it need it
18:42:17 <edwarnicke> ariel_noy: I would advocate a structure like this
18:42:23 <edwarnicke> Catalog Manager - standalone
18:42:34 <edwarnicke> Workload Manager - depends on Catalog Manager
18:42:49 <edwarnicke> Various drivers - depend on Workload manager
18:42:59 <edwarnicke> That way if you have n possible drivers, you can install only the m you want
18:43:03 <ariel_noy> Network Function in the Catalog but not in the front and Work load manger need to return it
18:43:19 <edwarnicke> ariel_noy: I don't follow that last sentence
18:43:20 <ariel_noy> If you prefer to work in String which is ID that is possible
18:43:41 <edwarnicke> ariel_noy: Could you say more... I'm a bit lost
18:43:47 <ariel_noy> If we want it to be yang object than I need to be able to point to that interface
18:45:08 <ariel_noy> for example catalogVNFType should be an object VNF Type from catalog and not object of work load manager
18:45:33 <ariel_noy> Maybe this is just symantics of yang that I do not know how
18:45:47 <edwarnicke> ariel_noy: I think I'm following you and *probably* agree
18:45:51 <edwarnicke> My basic point is that stacking
18:45:57 <edwarnicke> CatalogManager should be able to stand alone
18:46:11 <ariel_noy> I agree
18:46:11 <edwarnicke> Workload Managers should be agnostic as to drivers (but depend on Catalog Manager)
18:46:23 <ariel_noy> But work load manager should not
18:46:25 <edwarnicke> Drivers should depend on Workload Manager (so folks can pick and choose :) )
18:46:43 <ariel_noy> Should be able to reference type from the catalog
18:46:46 <edwarnicke> When you say Workload Manager shouldn't stand alone, do you mean it should depend on VNF Catalog?
18:47:00 <ariel_noy> yes
18:47:52 <ariel_noy> We can take it offline and have a talk some time
18:48:22 <anipbu> yes, I think this needs more discussion over email.
18:48:38 <anipbu> ariel_noy: could oyu start a email thread to discuss in more details?
18:48:48 <ariel_noy> ok
18:49:00 <edwarnicke> ariel_noy: I agree with you that Workload Manager should depend on VNF Catalog
18:50:05 <anipbu> #action ariel_noy to start email thread for guidance on how to import object from other modules that is not in the base.
18:51:44 <anipbu> For catelog, I don't think there's been any updates on that discussion.  I'll leave the status unchanged https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/26641/1
18:52:25 <anipbu> Any other updates on on going tasks?
18:54:06 <ariel_noy> Need to drop a few minute early
18:54:29 <anipbu> #info Please try to keep the trello board up to date on any updates you have for the corresponding tasks: https://trello.com/b/zsERKgeV/odl-armoury
18:54:36 <anipbu> ariel_noy: okay
18:54:57 <anipbu> #topic Be release plan
18:55:07 <anipbu> #link https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Armoury/Beryllium_Release_Plan
18:55:14 <anipbu> this is our finalized release plan
18:55:23 <anipbu> any comments please email the mailing list
18:55:37 <anipbu> #topic Interaction workflow
18:56:17 <anipbu> I would like to table this discussion when there is more members on the meeting
18:56:35 <anipbu> #info Interaction workflow discussion tabled for next week
18:56:51 <anipbu> #topic SFC use case with Tacker
18:57:20 <anipbu> I also think this topic should be tabled until next week
18:57:37 <anipbu> because alagalah and adetalhouet and not on the meeting.
18:57:52 <anipbu> #info SFC use case with Tacker discussion tabled for next week
18:58:05 <anipbu> #topic feature list
18:58:25 <anipbu> #link https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/armoury-dev/2015-October/000048.html
18:58:42 <anipbu> there an email thread right now to discus the feature list.
18:58:54 <anipbu> folks should feel free to respond to the email thread for feedback.
19:00:02 <anipbu> anyone else have topics they would like to discuss?
19:00:05 <anipbu> is anybody else in the meeting?
19:01:26 <anipbu> Okay.  thanks everyone.
19:01:28 <anipbu> #topic cookies
19:01:51 <anipbu> #endmeeting