14:29:53 <edwarnicke> #startmeeting Karaf Happy Hour
14:29:53 <odl_meetbot> Meeting started Wed Sep  3 14:29:53 2014 UTC.  The chair is edwarnicke. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html.
14:29:53 <odl_meetbot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:29:53 <odl_meetbot> The meeting name has been set to 'karaf_happy_hour'
14:30:15 <edwarnicke> #topic Roll call
14:30:30 <gzhao> #info George Zhao
14:30:45 <ChristineH> @info Christine for SNMP4SDN
14:31:30 <rafat> #info rafat for sdni
14:31:31 <mlemay_away> devinavery:  huh command providers need to be migrated ideally otherwise you can kill the command using the odl-base-dummy-console feature
14:31:37 <colindixon> #info colindixon for TTP (and mischief)
14:31:50 <mlemay_away> #info mlemay for mlemay
14:32:07 <edwarnicke> mlemay_away: You are failing at being away :)
14:33:29 <mlemay_away> edwarnicke: indeed..
14:34:11 <edwarnicke> 2 more minutes for roll call
14:34:33 <gzhao> xsited: a.y.t
14:34:44 <devinavery> #info devinavery for ... devinavery. :)
14:35:56 <devinavery> mlemay_away: mlemay: Where is the "odl-base-dummy-console" feature defined?
14:36:31 <mlemay> Controller/features/base
14:36:38 <mlemay> I might have done a typo
14:37:29 <mlemay> Adding this will mock equinox shell but will disable the command but at least bundle will run
14:37:50 <JYOTI_13> #info jyoti (plugin2oc)
14:38:54 <edwarnicke> #topic Status
14:39:06 <tbachman> #info tbachman Group Based Policy
14:39:10 <tbachman> drat
14:39:15 <tbachman> just a minute too late :)
14:39:18 <edwarnicke> What is everyone's status?
14:39:18 <devinavery> mlemay: thanks - I don't think we need the commands right now - they are statistics only. :)
14:39:28 * tbachman wonders what project mischief is
14:40:02 <tbachman> #info Group Based Policy: fixed configuration file issue, now doing some tweaking on packaging and integration features
14:40:14 <edwarnicke> tbachman: So stuff is working?
14:40:26 <tbachman> edwarnicke: yeah — tho I still have some work ahead of me
14:40:35 <tbachman> not bad — but need to get this into integration
14:40:52 <tbachman> also, just need to move stuff from outside the distro, and repush my existing gerrit
14:40:55 <tbachman> (amend)
14:41:02 <gzhao> ChristineH: How is snmp4sdn?
14:41:22 * tbachman forsees little sleep ahead
14:41:50 <gzhao> JYOTI_13: what is opencontrail's karaf status?
14:41:51 <colindixon> #info TTP: karaf feature working, building the integration patch as we speak,
14:42:12 <tbachman> folks — have to go offline for a bit…. catch you all later
14:42:29 <ChristineH> gzhao: there's a testing failure when maven building the feature
14:42:38 <gzhao> rafat: did you see features now?
14:42:59 <gzhao> ChristineH: ok, I will info you
14:43:05 <rafat> #info SDNi Reached till the end without any failure. But not able to see our feature (sdninterfaceapp) in the feature:list -i and also not able to install the same, while running ./karaf
14:43:14 <rafat> we need to check again
14:43:24 <gzhao> #info snmp4sdn testing failure after feature build
14:43:28 <ChristineH> gzhao: so I skip the test, then build success. Finally, the snmp4sdn feature can be loaded in Karaf
14:43:52 <edwarnicke> rafat: Do you have a link to a gerrit?
14:43:59 <gzhao> ChristineH: that is great.
14:44:04 <ChristineH> snmp4sdn's feature is here: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/gitweb?p=snmp4sdn.git;a=commit;h=03556dcf71739f73e9ff476f277c560006fabca7
14:44:27 <rafat> I am going to create one after this meeting..
14:44:38 <rafat> was trying today as well..
14:45:42 <gzhao> ChristineH: do you have error log for your testing failure?
14:45:51 <JYOTI_13> facing some issues in feature.xml
14:45:55 <rafat> Also, feature:list  command didn't list our project.
14:46:41 <colindixon> rafat: does feature:install work?
14:47:03 <ChristineH> gzhao: ok, let me produce one...
14:47:33 <rafat> feature:install sdninterfaceapp gives an error
14:47:50 <rafat> which is "Error executing command: No feature named 'sdninterfaceapp' with version '0.0.0' available"
14:48:12 <colindixon> rafat: I had that error too
14:48:20 <rafat> and how to fix it ?
14:48:22 <rafat> :-)
14:48:32 * colindixon looks to see what happened
14:48:36 <mlemay> Rafat are following the naming convention ? odl-(project name)-(feature name)
14:48:57 <mlemay> Colin: this error occur when feature doesn't exist
14:49:45 <mlemay> Feature:list | grep 'sdninterface'
14:49:54 <rafat> but we could get past this.Had a feature.xml also generated successfully
14:50:05 <mlemay> You can also feature:repo-list to make sure your repo is included
14:50:34 <rafat> feature:list -i does not list our project.
14:50:59 <edwarnicke> rafat: Do you have a link to a gerrit?
14:51:26 <rafat> No Ed.Nothing latest.It will be the one we did for M4 upload.
14:53:17 <edwarnicke> rafat: If you can publish a gerrit so I can see what you are doing, then I can look at it
14:53:24 <ChristineH> gzhao: the failure is here: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/10700/   the comment at bottom, thanks
14:53:25 <edwarnicke> rafat: Without it its hard to understand your issue
14:54:10 <rafat> Sure Ed..I am planning to upload right after this meeting.
14:54:24 <rafat> will share it then.
14:55:22 <colindixon> rafat: you can always push a draft “git review -D” and then just add some people as reviewers if you’re worried about people seeing incomplete code
14:55:55 <colindixon> and then abandon it later, then create a new gerrit by removing the change-id and letting git review make you a new one
14:56:33 <rafat> Thanks colin.I was not aware of it..I did some upload and abandoned the changes due to some build failed today :-(
14:56:49 <gzhao> ChristineH: that is the same error as in https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/integration-dev/2014-June/001192.html
14:57:41 <gzhao> edwarnicke: mlemay : I need to go to document meeting, could you help Christine on this error https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/10700/
14:58:31 <gzhao> Madhu said should copy LispFlowmapping
15:00:59 <gzhao> JYOTI_13: how is sb plugin for oc doing?
15:02:48 <JYOTI_13> i am working on karaf integration with plugin2oc having commons and neutron module
15:03:15 <JYOTI_13> now in feature.xml file i have provided neutron as bundle.
15:03:36 <Madhu> back guys
15:03:54 <Madhu> anything i can help with ?
15:04:08 <JYOTI_13> when i am doing mvn clean install on feature.xml it is giving error of missing import
15:04:48 <JYOTI_13> there are some dependecies in neutron do i need to add all these as bundles in feature.xml??
15:05:33 <devinavery> edwarnicke: Would you like me to create a bug for the fact that openflow-plugin features depend on a console but are missing at a min the dummy console import?
15:05:52 <edwarnicke> devinavery: If you would please
15:06:00 <edwarnicke> devinavery: Though I've already pinged MichalR to fix it
15:06:12 <edwarnicke> JYOTI_13: What is the error?
15:06:17 <devinavery> edwarnicke: ok. I will create a bug for a place holder
15:06:52 <ChristineH> Madhu: gzhao just mentioned that maybe you know how to fix this failure which is also encountered in snmp4sdn currently.   https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/integration-dev/2014-June/001192.html
15:07:43 <JYOTI_13> Error executing command: Could not start bundle mvn:org.opendaylight.plugin2oc/plugin2oc.neutron/0.1 in feature(s) odl-features-plugin2oc-0.1: The bundle "org.opendaylight.plugin2oc.neutron_0.1.0 [50]" could not be resolved. Reason: Missing Constraint: Import-Package:
15:08:48 <edwarnicke> What is the rest of the statmenet :)  the interesting part was cut off :)
15:09:08 <Madhu> edwarnicke: +1
15:09:16 <JYOTI_13> wait...
15:09:25 <JYOTI_13> i am sending
15:09:37 <colindixon> just posted TTP’s integration patch: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/10702/
15:10:00 <Madhu> ChristineH: i didn't spend time after identifying the fact that it is the same issue as in lispflowmapping
15:10:09 <Madhu> and lori might have the fix already :)
15:10:18 <Madhu> lori: were u able to fix that ?
15:10:22 * edwarnicke does a happy dance :)
15:10:41 <ChristineH> Madhu: oh, thanks!
15:10:54 <lori> I missed the context Madhu, sorry, wasn't paying attention
15:11:01 <lori> will read the scrollback buffer
15:11:11 <Madhu> lori: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/integration-dev/2014-June/001192.html
15:11:18 <Madhu> is that solved in lispflowmapping ?
15:11:25 <Madhu> if yes, can u help ChristineH who is facing the same issue
15:11:44 <devinavery> #link Created bug https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1681 for the openflowplugin feature dependency on the console.
15:12:02 <devinavery> edwarnicke: pasted link above to bug posted.
15:12:06 <lori> Madhu: ah, that;  we moved from point releases to SNAPSHOTs
15:12:17 <lori> Madhu: let me check commit history to find the fix
15:12:56 <ChristineH> lori: thanks :)
15:13:04 <JYOTI_13> Error executing command: Could not start bundle mvn:org.opendaylight.plugin2oc/plugin2oc.neutron/0.1 in feature(s) odl-features-plugin2oc-0.1: The bundle "org.opendaylight.plugin2oc.neutron_0.1.0 [50]" could not be resolved. Reason: Missing Constraint: Import-Package: com.google.common.collect
15:13:21 <Madhu> thanks lori ChristineH ... hope you guys will be able to move forward.
15:13:22 <gzhao> lori: thanks, worth to #info in the fix
15:13:30 <edwarnicke> JYOTI... looks like a missing guava dependency
15:13:36 <edwarnicke> In your feature
15:14:06 <JYOTI_13> i have added guava as bundle in feature..
15:14:07 <lori> gzhao: if I find the fix I'll info in
15:14:21 <Madhu> ChristineH: lori gzhao david just replied to my email with the fix
15:14:29 <edwarnicke> And you are still getting that error?
15:15:26 <Madhu> #info https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/lispflowmapping-dev/2014-September/000154.html from David to fix the problem ChristineH was facing as mentioned in https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/integration-dev/2014-June/001192.html
15:15:34 <gzhao> Madhu: fantanstic
15:15:39 <JYOTI_13> and it solves the problem...but the problem is each time it is giving missing import error for some other package..so i am adding respective bundle in feature.xml..
15:16:13 <Madhu> JYOTI_13: the simplest option would be to add all the dependencies that you usually have for your component in the feature.xml
15:16:16 <edwarnicke> JYOTI_13: There is often an iterative process
15:16:22 <Madhu> JYOTI_13: doing it one by one will be difficult
15:16:41 <edwarnicke> JYOTI_13: Madhu is right... do your best to add the dependencies you know about... but even after that there is usually a bit of iteration ;)
15:16:58 <Madhu> edwarnicke: yep. agreed :) we all have learnt the hard way :)
15:17:21 <JYOTI_13> ok...
15:17:24 * edwarnicke considers showing off the scars, thinks better of it ;)
15:18:34 <Madhu> edwarnicke: all our late night battles are our scars :) just checking emails during odd hours are the proof
15:18:56 <edwarnicke> Madhu: True :)
15:28:12 <colindixon> ok, should we wrap this meeting up in preparation for the pre-RC0 meeting?
15:32:12 <colindixon> phrobb: are we doing a pre-RC0 meeting?
15:36:55 <phrobb> colindixon:  It seemed very premature given that we are not past M5
15:37:06 <colindixon> phrobb: fair point
15:37:13 <colindixon> so, do we want to move it to Monday?
15:37:28 <colindixon> during the TWS slot maybe?
15:37:38 <phrobb> Yes, that would be my suggestion, but I wanted to ask the TSC tomorrow
15:37:51 <colindixon> I’m assuming that Madhu and networkstatic would be fine with that
15:37:51 <colindixon> ok
15:38:15 <Madhu> colindixon: +1
15:38:19 <Madhu> release is more important
15:38:52 <colindixon> so, that sounds good, phrobb feel free to propose the TWS call as the slot for the pre-RC0 meeting
15:38:56 * colindixon goes back to hacking :p
15:39:15 <hideyuki> Madhu: +1
15:39:43 * phrobb goes off to send an email regarding Pre-RC0 meeting…
15:40:06 <colindixon> phrobb: I can do that if you it makes your life easier
15:43:22 <phrobb> No worries Colin.  The theory is that the folks on the Release dist. list are used to seeing Releaes oriented emails from me
15:43:39 <colindixon> fair enough, that makes sense
15:49:10 <Madhu> colindixon: we have to make ur life easy at this point in time
15:49:23 <colindixon> Madhu: bah!
15:50:14 <colindixon> https://twitter.com/colin_dixon/status/507174882099355648
16:04:06 <gzhao> xsited: how is pcmm doing for Karaf?
16:25:50 <mlemay> @Colin: heheh nice
16:52:09 <devinavery> Any karaf / feature folks still here?
20:20:12 <tykeal> #endmeeting