=========================================== #opendaylight-meeting: boron release review =========================================== Meeting started by anipbu at 14:30:30 UTC. The full logs are available at http://meetings.opendaylight.org/opendaylight-meeting/2016/boron_release_review/opendaylight-meeting-boron_release_review.2016-08-30-14.30.log.html . Meeting summary --------------- * roll call (anipbu, 14:30:34) * PTL and TSC members please #info in (anipbu, 14:30:38) * anipbu (anipbu, 14:30:43) * colindixon for TSC, docs, and ttp (colindixon, 14:30:45) * gdavid_comp for unimgr (gdavid_comp, 14:30:49) * ravit_ for infrautils (ravit_, 14:31:04) * Vratko Polak for Integration/Test (vrpolak, 14:32:31) * UNIMGR (anipbu, 14:33:18) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Unimgr:BoronReleaseReview <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:33:22) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Unimgr:BoronReleaseNotes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:33:27) * gdavid_comp is representing UNIMGR (anipbu, 14:33:35) * LINK: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zImtd764e-hOgJAxoJKl85fxHCPu2agLfqsBtf13zQY/edit#gid=1708916020 <---- the release review schedule (colindixon, 14:37:15) * CSIT in good condition https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/unimgr-dev/2016-August/000226.html (anipbu, 14:41:43) * LINK: https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6558 major bug discovered in RC2 for unimgr, should be fixed by RC3 spin (anipbu, 14:42:03) * UNIMGR approved for Boron pending. Congratulations! (anipbu, 14:44:30) * INFRAUTILS (anipbu, 14:44:38) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Infrautils:BoronReleaseReview <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:44:42) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Infrastructure_Utilities:BoronReleaseNotes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:44:47) * ravit_ is representing INFRAUTILS (anipbu, 14:45:04) * LINK: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/44844/ documentation in flight (anipbu, 14:47:03) * infrautils has system test waiver (anipbu, 14:48:26) * ACTION: ravit_ to complete system test plan for infrautils (anipbu, 14:50:12) * all infrautils features are experimental (anipbu, 14:51:02) * suggestion for infrautils to break features up: call out the individual features vs. the -all version (anipbu, 14:53:05) * INFRAUTILS approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 14:53:17) * OF-CONFIG (anipbu, 14:53:29) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OF-CONFIG:Boron:Release_Review (wei____, 14:54:04) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OF-CONFIG:Boron:Release_Notes (wei____, 14:54:17) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OF-CONFIG:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:54:46) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OF-CONFIG:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:54:51) * wei____ is representing OF-CONFIG (anipbu, 14:55:19) * ofconfig has tested RC2 and found no blockers (anipbu, 14:57:49) * ACTION: wei____ to update the release review with list of features and their related attributes (anipbu, 15:00:51) * Release Review page links to CSIT jobs, but they do not test OF-config at all. Every feature should be considered experimental. https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/integration-dev/2016-August/008007.html (anipbu, 15:01:08) * supports both of-config 1.1.1 and 1.2 (anipbu, 15:02:13) * ACTION: wei____ to move wiki documentation to restructuredtext (anipbu, 15:03:44) * ACTION: wei____ to update the release notes with the missing sections: changes, bug fixed, migration, compatibility, deprecation: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Sample_Release_Notes (anipbu, 15:04:50) * of-config follow up to complete the content in the release notes and release review (anipbu, 15:08:13) * ACTION: anipbu to follow up with of-config (anipbu, 15:08:15) * OF-CONFIG approved for Boron pending action items, follow up to complete release review and release notes. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:09:48) * NETCONF (anipbu, 15:09:55) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NETCONF:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:10:00) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NETCONF:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:10:03) * tcere is representing NETCONF (anipbu, 15:10:11) * tcere has tested RC2 and found no problems (anipbu, 15:16:12) * ACTION: tcere to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 15:20:00) * ACTION: anipbu to follow up with netconf on experimental tag for features (anipbu, 15:22:51) * netconf to follow up on relevant action items, including assigning of experimental tag to features, etc (anipbu, 15:23:43) * NETCONF approved for Boron pending action items and follow up. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:25:15) * NATAPP (anipbu, 15:25:21) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NATApp_Plugin:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:25:26) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NATApp_Plugin:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:25:30) * TLee is representing NATAPP (anipbu, 15:25:43) * all NATAPP features are experimental for Boron. (jamoluhrsen, 15:26:30) * ACTION: natapp will test RC2 and update the spreadsheet. (anipbu, 15:27:14) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/natapp-dev/2016-August/000047.html csit analysis email for NATAPP (jamoluhrsen, 15:28:33) * TLee has agree to marked the natapp features as experimental (anipbu, 15:31:06) * ACTION: TLee to update the release review wiki to state the feature is experimental (anipbu, 15:31:51) * ACTION: natapp will update the target environment: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NATApp_Plugin:Boron_Release_Notes (anipbu, 15:33:30) * ACTION: TLee to remove duplicate patch 410171 (anipbu, 15:35:31) * NATAPP approved for Boron pending action items and follow up. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:36:12) * USECPLUGIN (anipbu, 15:36:18) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Controller_Shield:_Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:36:22) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Controller_Shield:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:36:27) * TLee is representing USECPLUGIN (anipbu, 15:36:30) * ACTION: usecplugin will test RC2 and update the spreadsheet. (anipbu, 15:37:22) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/usecplugin-dev/2016-August/000140.html email for usecplugin csit analysis (jamoluhrsen, 15:37:35) * LINK: I'm still waiting for feedback on docs here here: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/39165/ (colindixon, 15:37:41) * all usecplugin features are experimental (jamoluhrsen, 15:37:47) * ACTION: TLee will update the release review wiki with target environment (anipbu, 15:37:48) * ACTION: TLee to follow up on CSIT tests (anipbu, 15:39:31) * usecplugin has agreed to mark the features as experimental for now, but will fix CSIT and follow up. (anipbu, 15:41:13) * ACTION: TLee to update the release review template and change the features as experimental. TLee will follow up on CSIT suites. (anipbu, 15:42:03) * ACTION: TLee to follow up on feedback on docs here here: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/39165/ (anipbu, 15:44:18) * LACP (anipbu, 15:44:28) * USECPLUGIN approved for Boron pending action items and follow up. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:44:46) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/LACP:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:44:51) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/LACP:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:44:55) * kalai is representing LACP (anipbu, 15:45:12) * LACP verified with RC1, RC2 verification pending (anipbu, 15:45:53) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/lacp-dev/2016-August/000156.html email with CSIT analysis for LACP (jamoluhrsen, 15:46:07) * all LACP features are experimental by definition. (jamoluhrsen, 15:46:20) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/integration-dev/2016-August/007910.html (kalai, 15:47:17) * LINK: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/44403/ <--- LACP user guide (anipbu, 15:48:46) * ACTION: kalai: jamoluhrsen: to follow up on the CSIT failures and the experimental tag (anipbu, 15:49:53) * LINK: http://docs.opendaylight.org/en/stable-boron/user-guide/link-aggregation-control-protocol-user-guide.html?highlight=lacp (colindixon, 15:50:55) * ACTION: kalai to update the release review with documentation links to rst/asciidocs, etc. (anipbu, 15:51:34) * LACP approved for Boron pending action items and follow up. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:53:33) * CAPWAP to reschedule again. (anipbu, 15:55:14) * DIDM (anipbu, 15:55:28) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/DIDM:_Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:55:34) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/DIDM:_Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:55:38) * subh is representing DIDM (anipbu, 15:55:44) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/didm-dev/2016-August/000548.html email for DIDM csit analysis (jamoluhrsen, 15:56:05) * ACTION: didm to update release review wiki with links to documentation rst/asciidocs (anipbu, 16:00:18) * ACTION: subh to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 16:02:42) * all of didm features are experimental for now (anipbu, 16:05:59) * ACTION: subh to mark features as experimental. Will fixed the CSIT and follow up on the features experimental tags. (anipbu, 16:06:51) * DIDM approved for Boron pending action items and follow up. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:08:35) * CARDINAL (anipbu, 16:08:39) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Cardinal:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 16:08:42) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Cardinal:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:08:46) * Rajani is representing CARDINAL (anipbu, 16:08:50) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/cardinal-dev/2016-August/000043.html csit analysis email (jamoluhrsen, 16:11:01) * all cardinal features are experimental (jamoluhrsen, 16:11:11) * LINK: https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6586 <--- Cardinal open bug (parthaDatta, 16:11:51) * Rajani has agreed to mark features as experimental (anipbu, 16:12:54) * ACTION: Rajani to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 16:13:22) * Vina Ermagan for LISP Flow Mapping (vina_ermagan, 16:13:54) * ACTION: Rajani to add the documentation links to restructuredtext in the release review (anipbu, 16:15:32) * LINK: http://docs.opendaylight.org/en/stable-boron/developer-guide/cardinal_-opendaylight-monitoring-as-a-service.html (colindixon, 16:16:51) * CARDINAL approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:20:08) * CENTINEL (anipbu, 16:20:11) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Centinel:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 16:20:15) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Centinel:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:20:18) * sumit_ is representing CENTINEL (anipbu, 16:20:26) * Abhishek Guest18385 is representing CENTINEL (anipbu, 16:21:24) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/centinel-dev/2016-August/000137.html email with Centinel CSIT analysis (jamoluhrsen, 16:21:41) * all centinel features are experimental (jamoluhrsen, 16:21:51) * Guest18385 centinel has tested RC2 and found no blockers (anipbu, 16:23:07) * all documentation are up to date (even though though they were last updated on 11/2015) (anipbu, 16:25:14) * ACTION: Guest18385 to approve patch for docs https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/44323 (anipbu, 16:25:43) * Guest18385 has agreed that all in centinel are experimental (anipbu, 16:26:25) * ACTION: Guest18385 to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 16:27:05) * ACTION: centinel team to follow up on the critical issue of whether the features can load at all (anipbu, 16:27:57) * ACTION: jamoluhrsen sumit_ to follow up on whether centinel features can even load up at all and provide bug id as appropriate (anipbu, 16:29:51) * ACTION: Guest18385 sumit_ to update compatibility, migration, deprecation, changes, bugs, in the release notes (anipbu, 16:33:34) * ACTION: sumit_ centinel to follow up on adding centinel to the features-test https://github.com/opendaylight/integration-distribution/blob/stable/boron/features-test/src/main/resources/features.xml (anipbu, 16:35:48) * CENTINEL approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:37:37) * LISPFLOWMAPPING (anipbu, 16:37:43) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_Lisp_Flow_Mapping:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 16:37:48) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_Lisp_Flow_Mapping:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:38:05) * vina_ermagan is representing LISPFLOWMAPPING (anipbu, 16:38:32) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/lispflowmapping-dev/2016-August/000802.html email for CSIT analysis for lispflowmapping (jamoluhrsen, 16:39:18) * all features covered in CSIT can be released without experimental labal. (jamoluhrsen, 16:39:37) * vina_ermagan lispflowmapping has tested RC2 and found no blockers (anipbu, 16:40:34) * ACTION: vina_ermagan to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 16:42:36) * ACTION: vina_ermagan to add link to user guide for the "developer guide" section, since they cover both. (anipbu, 16:47:10) * LISPFLOWMAPPING approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:47:16) * OVSDB (anipbu, 16:47:19) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_OVSDB:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 16:47:24) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_OVSDB:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:47:28) * vishnoianil is representing OVSDB (anipbu, 16:47:32) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/ovsdb-dev/2016-August/003762.html email with CSIT analysis for OVSDB (jamoluhrsen, 16:49:03) * ovsdb southbound features are good with CSIT, so no experimental label there. (jamoluhrsen, 16:49:29) * hw vtep has no CSIT, so needs experimental label for Boron (jamoluhrsen, 16:49:48) * vishnoianil ovsdb has tested RC2 and CSIT test runs looks good. No blockers founds. (anipbu, 16:50:43) * ACTION: vishnoianil to follow up on updating the user guide (anipbu, 16:51:46) * developers guide is something that pretty much same, but user guide is something that ovsdb needs to update. (anipbu, 16:52:59) * OVSDB approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:53:55) * ATRIUM (anipbu, 16:54:40) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Atrium:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 16:54:44) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Atrium:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:54:48) * Manoj-atrium is representing ATRIUM (anipbu, 16:54:52) * ACTION: Manoj-atrium atrium will test RC2 and provide update on the test status (anipbu, 16:57:00) * atrium has a system test waiver (anipbu, 16:58:01) * ACTION: Manoj-atrium to update the boron test plan with test results (anipbu, 17:00:00) * ATRIUM approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 17:02:59) * PACKETCABLE (anipbu, 17:04:07) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/PacketCablePCMM:BoronReleaseReview <--- Release Review (anipbu, 17:04:11) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/index.php?title=PacketCablePCMM:BoronReleaseNotes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 17:04:19) * kkershaw is representing PACKETCABLE (anipbu, 17:04:23) * LINK: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/packetcable-dev/2016-August/000138.html email with CSIT analysis for packetcable boron release (jamoluhrsen, 17:04:55) * all packetcable features experimental (jamoluhrsen, 17:05:05) * LINK: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/34925/ (colindixon, 17:07:17) * ACTION: kkershaw to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 17:09:41) * ACTION: kkershaw to update the user guide (anipbu, 17:11:14) * ACTION: packetcable to follow up on the "experimental" tag after fixing the CSIT tests. (anipbu, 17:14:15) * ACTION: kkershaw to update the release notes with section on migration (anipbu, 17:16:10) * PACKETCABLE approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 17:17:39) * cookies (anipbu, 17:18:36) Meeting ended at 17:18:42 UTC. Action items, by person ----------------------- * anipbu * anipbu to follow up with of-config * anipbu to follow up with netconf on experimental tag for features * Guest18385 * Guest18385 to approve patch for docs https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/44323 * Guest18385 to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes * Guest18385 sumit_ to update compatibility, migration, deprecation, changes, bugs, in the release notes * jamoluhrsen * kalai: jamoluhrsen: to follow up on the CSIT failures and the experimental tag * jamoluhrsen sumit_ to follow up on whether centinel features can even load up at all and provide bug id as appropriate * kalai * kalai: jamoluhrsen: to follow up on the CSIT failures and the experimental tag * kalai to update the release review with documentation links to rst/asciidocs, etc. * kkershaw * kkershaw to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes * kkershaw to update the user guide * kkershaw to update the release notes with section on migration * Manoj-atrium * Manoj-atrium atrium will test RC2 and provide update on the test status * Manoj-atrium to update the boron test plan with test results * Rajani * Rajani to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes * Rajani to add the documentation links to restructuredtext in the release review * ravit_ * ravit_ to complete system test plan for infrautils * subh * subh to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes * subh to mark features as experimental. Will fixed the CSIT and follow up on the features experimental tags. * sumit_ * jamoluhrsen sumit_ to follow up on whether centinel features can even load up at all and provide bug id as appropriate * Guest18385 sumit_ to update compatibility, migration, deprecation, changes, bugs, in the release notes * sumit_ centinel to follow up on adding centinel to the features-test https://github.com/opendaylight/integration-distribution/blob/stable/boron/features-test/src/main/resources/features.xml * tcere * tcere to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes * TLee * TLee to update the release review wiki to state the feature is experimental * TLee to remove duplicate patch 410171 * TLee will update the release review wiki with target environment * TLee to follow up on CSIT tests * TLee to update the release review template and change the features as experimental. TLee will follow up on CSIT suites. * TLee to follow up on feedback on docs here here: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/39165/ * vina_ermagan * vina_ermagan to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes * vina_ermagan to add link to user guide for the "developer guide" section, since they cover both. * vishnoianil * vishnoianil to follow up on updating the user guide * wei____ * wei____ to update the release review with list of features and their related attributes * wei____ to move wiki documentation to restructuredtext * wei____ to update the release notes with the missing sections: changes, bug fixed, migration, compatibility, deprecation: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Sample_Release_Notes * **UNASSIGNED** * natapp will test RC2 and update the spreadsheet. * natapp will update the target environment: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NATApp_Plugin:Boron_Release_Notes * usecplugin will test RC2 and update the spreadsheet. * didm to update release review wiki with links to documentation rst/asciidocs * centinel team to follow up on the critical issue of whether the features can load at all * packetcable to follow up on the "experimental" tag after fixing the CSIT tests. People present (lines said) --------------------------- * anipbu (293) * colindixon (98) * jamoluhrsen (70) * vrpolak (27) * TLee (26) * Rajani (17) * wei____ (17) * subh (16) * kalai (14) * kkershaw (14) * Guest18385 (14) * ravit_ (13) * vina_ermagan (12) * vishnoianil (11) * odl_meetbot (10) * tcere (9) * Manoj-atrium (9) * gdavid_comp (8) * sumit_ (7) * davidmichaelkarr (1) * parthaDatta (1) Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4