15:58:07 #startmeeting MD-SAL Interest Call 15:58:07 Meeting started Tue Jul 26 15:58:07 2016 UTC. The chair is Sai_. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html. 15:58:07 Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote. 15:58:07 The meeting name has been set to 'md_sal_interest_call' 15:58:23 #topic - last-meeting-minutes 15:58:33 #link - https://meetings.opendaylight.org/opendaylight-meeting/2016/md_sal_interest_call/opendaylight-meeting-md_sal_interest_call.2016-07-19-16.06.html 15:58:38 #topic - Agenda 16:00:15 #info - 1. Call for any topics 16:00:23 #info - 2. Review Action Items 16:00:55 #info - 3. Review Blocking bugs 16:01:38 #info - 4. Review the new Dashboards - Core Patches Merged & Modified in last 7 days 16:04:38 #topic - Call for any topics 16:05:12 #info - 1. Restconf draft 15 16:05:37 #info - 2. Binding spec v2 review / opinions 16:06:12 #info - 3. netconf / restconf bugzilla is obselete in controller project. 16:07:13 #Action - TomP to followup with helpdesk to remove restconf/netconf bugs from bugzilla 16:07:56 #info - 4. Beryllium SR3 from An 16:08:09 #topic - Review Action items 16:09:17 #info - [DONE] skitt (or somebody else if they have time in the next few weeks) to look at trying to purge some of these (which we think are erroneous at this point) - https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/RelEng/Autorelease/Orbit https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5973 16:11:21 #Action - [IN PROGRESS] Ryan to followup wrt bug 6148 and report back if it has cyclic dependencies and solution. 16:11:31 #chair colindixon 16:11:31 Current chairs: Sai_ colindixon 16:11:39 #info - DONE Bug 5923 - Ryan to followup with author on the status Will be solved with upgrade to karaf 3.0.7; an actual JCE problem in some environments 16:11:56 #Action - [IN PROGRESS] Bug 6152 - Ryan to followup with author on the status Added Tom P. as a watcher; he has taken the lead on CSS issues this release. 16:12:16 #info - [DONE] - Robert follows up with team wrt API change [ gerrit id 40592 ] 16:12:33 #Action - [IN PROGRESS] Bug 5099 - Igor still need more info on circumstances. Igor to followup with Ambika. Igor followed up, seems that more info is still needed to reproduce. 16:12:47 #Topic - Restconf Draft 15 16:12:51 #info - In progress 16:13:13 #info we're currently working on draft 11, but there are supposedly no (or only minor) technical changes between 11 and 15 16:13:33 #info - plan to support for yang 1.1 (switches xml to any data) 16:13:34 #info Martin Ciglan points out that YANG 1.1 is required to support draft 11/15 16:13:50 #info the plan is to support YANG 1.1 as part of Carbon efforts 16:14:31 #info - colindixon presented this to advisory group and general consensus is to eventually migrate it. 16:17:52 #info - This includes difficult design decisions and there is a need to document the plan. 16:18:28 #topic - Binding Spec v2 16:18:44 #info the key point is that there are at least three layers: RESTCONF draft 11 or draft 15, YANG model 1.1 vs. 1.0, and NETCONF using YANG 1.0 or 1.1 16:19:11 #info as an aside, it's pretty ridiculous that the IETF has tied RESTCONF to a particular version of YANG vs. having it be a transport and not caring, but I guess it's done 16:19:15 #info - Martin sent e-mail to md-sal dev / controller-dev and awaiting feedback 16:19:51 #link https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/mdsal-dev/2016-July/000398.html 16:20:05 #link - https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/mdsal-dev/2016-July/000398.html 16:20:56 #info - colindixon suggests to present binding v2 spec in TWS call 16:21:06 #action colindixon to work with martin ciglan to get a binding v2 spec TWS call 16:21:41 #topic - Beryllium SR3 16:22:28 #info - An says there are distribution test failures in AAA & Netconf for SR3. 16:23:00 #Action - Ryan / Tomas to look in to distribution test failures wrt Ber SR3 16:23:13 #topic - Weekly Sync IRC Meeting 16:24:19 #info - An says started from M5, 10 AM PST is likely 16:24:32 #info - colindixon suggests 7 AM PST 16:25:31 #Action - An to sent an e-mail regarding scheduled times of weekly sync IRC meeting 16:25:44 #topic - DCL Removal plans 16:26:54 #info - Toaster doesn't have many children and it relatively easy to switch from DCL to DTCL 16:27:15 #info - Stephen says they haven't finished in ovsdb 16:28:22 #info - change in granularity / rework events / react in a different way are hurdles in ovsdb as of now 16:28:42 #info skitt says that the change in granularity of events means that you either don't get any speed benefit or you have to react ina substantively different way 16:28:59 #info - Since deprecated in Boron it can be removed in Carbon. But Ryan suggests NOT to remove in Carbon 16:31:23 #info - Consensus is NOT to remove in carbon cycle. 16:32:51 #topic - Blocking bugs 16:33:03 #link - https://bugs.opendaylight.org/buglist.cgi?bug_severity=blocker&bug_severity=critical&list_id=46270&order=changeddate%20DESC%2Cbug_status%2Cpriority%2Cassigned_to%2Cbug_id&product=aaa&product=controller&product=mdsal&product=netconf&product=odlparent&product=yangtools&query_based_on=&query_format=advanced&resolution=--- 16:33:48 #info - Bug 6271 16:34:56 #info - Vrakto says there is possibility that it happens only in auto-release builds 16:35:35 #info - Bug 6209 16:36:22 #info - Martin added comments 16:38:07 #Action - Ryan to look in to enhancement bug wrt Bug 6209 16:38:30 #info - Bug 6152 16:41:11 #info - Move it to topoprocessing project 16:41:29 #info - TomP says it is not config system error 16:42:13 #info - Bug 5923 16:43:14 #info - Ryan built with auto release and see sporadic failures. 16:44:34 #info - Ryan plan to move karaf parent to odlparent 16:44:40 #undo 16:44:40 Removing item from minutes: 16:44:44 #info - Ryan plans to move karaf parent to odlparent 16:45:01 * colindixon has to run, but you're in good hands with Sai_ 16:47:05 #info - In that case we don't need to bump karaf parent everytime 16:47:31 #info - Bug 6148 16:47:51 #Ryan to followup with Mohammed wrt Bug 6148 16:47:55 #undo 16:47:55 Removing item from minutes: 16:48:01 #Action - Ryan to followup with Mohammed wrt Bug 6148 16:48:23 #topic - Review the new Dashboards 16:48:35 #info - Core Patches Merged In Last 7 Days 16:48:44 #link - https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/dashboard/?title=Core+Patches+Merged+In+Last+7+Days&odlparent+patches=project:odlparent+status:merged+NOT+age:7d&yangtools+Patches=project:yangtools+status:merged+NOT+age:7d&mdsal+Patchs=project:mdsal+status:merged+NOT+age:7d&controller+patches=project:controller+status:merged+NOT+age:7d&netconf+patches=project:netconf+status:merged+NOT+age:7d&AAA+Patches=project:aaa+status:merge 16:49:00 #info - Good thing to have bug Id for every gerrit 16:50:32 #info - checkstayle rules / Google Truth / PMD CPD are some of the important merged patches in odlparent 16:52:34 #info - patches include deprecations in yangtools 16:53:05 #info - increasing code coverage in mdsal 16:56:46 #info - place to store the xml files / change in auto-down feature 16:58:36 #Action - Sai to add change in auto-down feature to release notes 17:00:32 #info - Bug fixes for Be / Boron in netconf 17:00:38 #info - document fixes in AA 17:00:42 #undo 17:00:42 Removing item from minutes: 17:00:44 #info - document fixes in AAA 17:00:49 #topic - participants 17:02:01 #info - Sai / Ryan / An / Colin / Igor / Martin / Stephen / TomP / Tomas / Vaclav / Vratko 17:02:06 #endmeeting