14:00:22 <klou> #startmeeting nitrogen release review
14:00:22 <odl_meetbot> Meeting started Wed Sep 13 14:00:22 2017 UTC.  The chair is klou. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html.
14:00:22 <odl_meetbot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
14:00:22 <odl_meetbot> The meeting name has been set to 'nitrogen_release_review'
14:01:00 <klou> Good Morning! We are starting the first segment of Day 3 Nitrogen Release Review
14:01:14 <vrpolak> #info Vratko Polak for Inegration/Distribution
14:01:30 <klou> #topic INTEGRATION/DISTRIBUTION
14:01:56 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/63095 - release notes
14:02:52 <klou> Vratko - Thank you for your efforts testing! Do you have any concerns or blocking issues at this point?
14:03:54 <vrpolak> There are two regressions. For Bug 9044 we do not have a clean fix, just a workaround for test to make them work.
14:05:03 <klou> I understand you are working on a patch for 9044.  What is the other issue?
14:05:22 <vrpolak> The other regression is ODL boot-up time. Due to number of features and inefficiencies in Karaf 4.0.9 some users might think it got stuch, while it finishes booting up in 3 minutes or so. I vaguely remember having open bugs for that, but workaround of "wait a wile longer" works, so not a blocker I think.
14:06:08 <klou> Will this go into the release notes?
14:06:10 <vrpolak> The slow boot should be documented somewhere, I am not sure whether Int/Dist release notes is the correct place though.
14:07:18 <vrpolak> I can add it to Int/Dist release notes, let me find a Bug number.
14:08:02 <klou> Thanks Vrakto! Let's discuss in TSC if you think we need to document the slow boot problem in other places.
14:08:58 <klou> Do you have anything else you want to bring up?
14:10:33 <vrpolak> Other than that, no issues from Integration/Distribution. I guess some project do not have their features in odl-integration-all due to Odlparent 2.0.4 not having flexibility for heap usage during SingleFeatureTest, but that is not Int/Dist problem, Odlparent has improvements contributed already.
14:10:51 <vrpolak> That is all from me.
14:11:47 <klou> #info INTEGRATION/DISTRIBUTION approved for nitrogen release! Congrats and Thank you!
14:12:23 <vrpolak> Well, maybe I should comment on distribution-oofline-nitrogen failing, as it does not have Bug 9044 workaround applied yet, but I will have a fix for that soon, so it does not really matter.
14:13:01 <vrpolak> klou: Thanks.
14:13:02 <klou> #info Assumption is we will not release until all blockers (including 9044) have resolution
14:13:22 <klou> vrpolak: thank you!
14:13:35 <klou> Do we have representative for of-config project?
14:13:42 <wei_> yes
14:13:54 <klou> #topic OF-CONFIG
14:14:13 <klou> #info Wei Meng represents OF-CONFIG
14:14:32 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/63078/ - release notes
14:14:57 <klou> Wei: Have you tested RC3?  Any blockers/concerns?
14:15:26 <wei_> yes and no issues found
14:16:43 <klou> I see that we did not receive an M5 milestone status for OF-CONFIG.  Have you looked at the sonar report?
14:17:50 <klou> #link https://sonar.opendaylight.org/component_issues/index?id=org.opendaylight.of-config%3Aofconf#resolved=false
14:18:12 <klou> #info Sonar Report for OF-CONFIG shows no blocker/critical issues
14:18:27 <wei_> i have posted m5 milestone on of-config mailling list
14:19:00 <klou> Can you send it to release mailing list also?
14:19:09 <wei_> sure
14:19:17 <klou> thank you
14:19:49 <klou> #info OFCONFIG has no CSIT problems
14:20:10 <klou> Do yo have anything you want to add?
14:20:27 <wei_> nothing
14:20:59 <klou> #info OFCONFIG approved for nitrogen release.  Congrats and thank you!
14:21:15 <wei_> thank you.
14:21:30 <klou> Do we have representative for vtn project?
14:21:40 <gvrangan> yes gvrangan here for VTN
14:21:56 <gvrangan> release notes in WIP: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/63100 will update in another 2 hours
14:22:17 <klou> #info release in progress
14:22:24 <gvrangan> CSIT currently has a few failures due to Openflowplugin bug: 9088
14:23:05 <gvrangan> All the features are stable other than this problem
14:23:35 <klou> 9088 is not a blocker - should it be?
14:24:02 <gvrangan> no it is just a particular scenario failure
14:24:10 <gvrangan> We have tests passing after that suite also
14:24:18 <klou> #undo
14:24:18 <odl_meetbot> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0x142b950>
14:24:28 <klou> #info release notes in progress
14:25:21 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - thank you!
14:25:57 <klou> Thank you for the info thus far!  Do you have anything else to add?
14:26:21 <gvrangan> that is all from my end I will complete the release notes and amend the patch
14:26:29 <klou> #info gvrangan represents VTN
14:27:00 <klou> #info VTN approved for nitrogen release pending completion of release notes update.  Congrats and thank you!
14:27:19 <gvrangan> thanks klou
14:27:49 <klou> Do we have representative for yangtools project?
14:30:38 <rovarga> klou: yeah, right here :)
14:31:06 <klou> Hi Robert!
14:31:13 <rovarga> key Kit :)
14:31:14 <klou> #topic YANGTOOLS
14:31:18 <rovarga> hey rather :)
14:31:28 <klou> #info Robert Varga represents YANGTOOLS
14:31:48 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/62958/ - release notes
14:32:24 <klou> Have you tested RC3?  Any blockers/concerns?
14:33:14 <rovarga> klou: RC3 is not showing any concerns, yangtools is good to go
14:33:28 <klou> sounds good
14:33:38 <rovarga> we do have some issues, but those are already postponed to SR1
14:33:52 <rovarga> issues/improvements
14:34:17 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout not captured in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet but sonar report looks good
14:34:40 <rovarga> klou: yeah, I failed to send out the readouts, it's still on my plate :(
14:34:48 <rovarga> klou: I hope to catch that up over the weekend
14:35:08 <klou> no problem rovarga - good to go
14:35:25 <klou> #info YANGTOOLS approved for nitrogen release!  Congrats and thank you!
14:36:01 <rovarga> klou: thanks
14:36:18 <klou> Do we have representative for packetcable project?
14:36:31 <kkershaw> yes - Kevin Kershaw representing packetcable here
14:36:40 <klou> #topic PACKETCABLE
14:36:56 <klou> #info kkershaw represents PACKETCABLE
14:37:12 <klou> I see that you are working on release notes today
14:37:39 <klou> Have you tested RC3?  Any blockers/concerns?
14:37:49 <kkershaw> yes - that's correct - no significant change but needs update to nitrogen info
14:38:01 <kkershaw> also - no significant concerns -  we have tested RC3
14:38:19 <kkershaw> there were no problems
14:38:45 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and captured in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - thank you!
14:38:58 <kkershaw> you're welcome
14:39:02 <klou> #info PACKETCABLE has no CSIT problems
14:39:28 <klou> everything looks good pending update of release notes - anything else you want to add?
14:39:53 <kkershaw> no - we should have release notes done by COB here (us MTN time) today
14:40:10 <klou> #info PACKETCABLE approved for nitrogen release pending release notes update!  Thank you!
14:40:20 <kkershaw> thank you klou
14:40:53 <klou> Do we have representative for ALTO project?
14:40:56 <kai> Jensen and I will represent ALTO.
14:41:01 <jensen_zhang> yes
14:41:07 <klou> #topic ALTO
14:41:24 <klou> #info kai and jensen_zhang represent ALTO
14:42:07 <klou> Have you updated your release notes for nitrogen?
14:42:21 <kai> Yes
14:42:30 <kai> https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/63076/
14:42:57 <klou> thank you!
14:43:10 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/63076/ - release notes
14:43:36 <klou> #info M5 milestone status readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - thank you!
14:43:47 <klou> Have you tested RC3? Any blockers/concerns?
14:44:09 <jensen_zhang> I have tested rc3. no blocking issue.
14:44:27 <klou> #info ALTO has no CSIT problems
14:44:44 <klou> Looks good - do you have anything else you want to add?
14:45:02 <kai> Not from me.
14:45:18 <klou> Jensen?
14:45:24 <jensen_zhang> not from me
14:45:38 <klou> #info ALTO approved for nitrogen release!  Congrats and thank you!
14:45:43 <kai> Thank you!
14:45:49 <jensen_zhang> thank you!
14:46:55 <klou> We have time to do another project if ready - please chime in within the next 3 minutes otherwise we will end this first segment of review
14:48:08 <Chinning> Chinning for ocpplugin
14:48:26 <klou> Hi Chinning
14:48:39 <klou> #topic OCPPLUGIN
14:48:39 <Chinning> Hi
14:48:56 <klou> #info Chinning represents OCPPLUGIN
14:49:15 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/63072/ - release notes
14:49:30 <klou> Have you tested RC3? Any blockers/concerns?
14:49:54 <Chinning> Yes, and no blocker issue
14:50:15 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking sheet - thank you!
14:50:29 <klou> #info OCPPLUGIN has no CSIT problems
14:50:41 <klou> everything looks good - do you have anything else you want to add?
14:50:56 <Chinning> no, nothing to add
14:51:00 <klou> #info OCPPLUGIN approved for nitrogen release!  Congrats and thank you!
14:51:25 <Chinning> Thank you, klou !
14:52:21 <klou> Thank you to all project leads/representatives for participating in this 1st segment of review!
14:52:29 <klou> #endmeeting