16:00:28 <klou> #startmeeting nitrogen release review
16:00:28 <odl_meetbot> Meeting started Wed Sep 13 16:00:28 2017 UTC.  The chair is klou. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html.
16:00:28 <odl_meetbot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:00:28 <odl_meetbot> The meeting name has been set to 'nitrogen_release_review'
16:00:48 <klou> We are starting the 2nd segment of nitrogen release review for today
16:01:54 <klou> Do we have a representative for odlparent?
16:02:42 <skitt> yes
16:02:52 <skitt> but odlparent was scheduled in 10 min
16:02:52 <klou> #topic ODLPARENT
16:03:08 <klou> #Stephen Kitt represents ODLPARENT
16:03:14 <klou> undo
16:03:27 <klou> #undo
16:03:27 <odl_meetbot> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Topic object at 0x1424d50>
16:03:32 <skitt> let's go for it ;-)
16:03:37 <klou> #info Stephen Kitt represents ODLPARENT
16:03:52 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/63033 - release notes
16:04:27 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout not recorded in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - have you looked at the sonar report for odlparent?
16:04:41 <skitt> I sent the M5 readout a while ago
16:04:56 <skitt> I have looked at the Sonar report, yes
16:04:58 <skitt> and the CLM report
16:05:13 <klou> any concerns or actions we should take?
16:05:31 <skitt> let me find the readout
16:06:04 <klou> #link https://sonar.opendaylight.org/component_issues/index?id=org.opendaylight.odlparent%3Aodlparent-aggregator#resolved=false|severities=BLOCKER - latest sonar report
16:06:43 <skitt> nothing nasty from my pov
16:07:00 <klou> sounds good
16:07:15 <klou> #info nothing signifcant in sonar report
16:07:36 <klou> Have you tested RC3 or later?  Any blockers/concerns?
16:07:46 <skitt> #link M5 readout: https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/release/2017-August/011853.html
16:07:49 <skitt> yes, no blockers
16:08:10 <klou> Thank you for the link skitt!
16:08:34 <skitt> you're very welcome
16:08:43 <klou> #info no CSIT problems
16:08:58 <klou> everything looks good to me - anything else you want to add?
16:09:05 <skitt> no, thanks
16:09:18 <klou> #info ODLPARENT approved for nitrogen release! Congrats! and Thank you!
16:09:24 <skitt> thank you ;-)
16:10:11 <klou> Do we have a representative for snmp4sdn?
16:10:22 <ChristineH> yes
16:10:28 <ChristineH> ChristineH for snmp4sdn
16:10:31 <klou> #topic SNMP4SDN
16:10:45 <klou> #info ChristineH represents SNMP4SDN
16:11:07 <ChristineH> Thanks
16:11:13 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/63090/ - release notes
16:11:54 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - thank you!
16:12:10 <klou> Have you tested RC3 or later? Any blockers/concerns?
16:12:29 <ChristineH> yes, testd. no blockers/concerns
16:12:34 <ChristineH> tested
16:12:42 <klou> thank you
16:12:52 <klou> #info no CSIT problems
16:13:15 <klou> Everything looks good - do you have anything else you want to add?
16:13:24 <ChristineH> no
16:13:36 <klou> #info SNMP4SDN approved for nitrogen release!  Congrats and Thank you!
16:13:44 <ChristineH> Thanks!
16:14:08 <klou> Do we have a representative for sfc?
16:14:39 <bjohnson> Yes, I will be representing SFC
16:14:45 <klou> #topic SFC
16:14:45 <bjohnson> #info Brady Johnson representing Service Function Chaining (SFC)
16:15:00 <klou> #info bjohnson represents SFC
16:15:18 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/63066 - release notes
16:15:54 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - thank you!
16:16:00 <bjohnson> You're welcome!
16:16:09 <klou> Have you tested RC3 or later?  Any blockers/concerns?
16:16:18 <bjohnson> #info We have tested RC3, but we need RC3.1
16:16:27 <bjohnson> #info These 3 patches were merged post-RC3, so we need RC3.1
16:16:29 <bjohnson> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/62550/
16:16:30 <bjohnson> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/62561/
16:16:32 <bjohnson> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/62552/
16:16:49 <bjohnson> #info We havent tested with RC3.1 yet, since I dont believe its ready yet.
16:17:08 <klou> FYI: RC3.1 is just out - RC4 will be our true release candidate
16:17:30 <bjohnson> Ok, do you have the RC3.1 link? I can test it right after this meeting
16:17:45 <klou> #info no CSIT problems
16:18:03 <klou> please check email - I just sent it out a little while ago
16:18:08 <bjohnson> ok, thanks!
16:18:35 <klou> everything looks good to me - do you have anything else you want to bring up?
16:18:41 <bjohnson> no
16:19:01 <klou> #info SFC approved for nitrogen release.  Congrats and Thank you!
16:19:08 <bjohnson> Ok, great, thanks!
16:19:50 <klou> We are ahead of schedule. Do we have a rep for netconf?
16:21:50 <klou> jmorvay?
16:23:11 <klou> Any project want to go first?
16:23:46 <jmorvay> Hi, we can do Netconf
16:23:54 <klou> sounds good!
16:23:57 <vishnoianil> klou i can go with the ovsdb project
16:24:03 <klou> #topic NETCONF
16:24:20 <klou> #info jmorvay represents NETCONF
16:24:35 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/63102 - release notes
16:24:58 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking spredsheet - thank you!
16:25:12 <klou> Have you tested RC3 or later?  Any blockers/concerns?
16:25:52 <jmorvay> We have tested RC3 with our releng suites.
16:26:05 <jmorvay> No blockers nor concerns
16:26:28 <klou> #info CSIT problems accounted for
16:26:50 <klou> things look good - anything else you want to add?
16:27:15 <jmorvay> No, nothing else regarding that.
16:27:35 <klou> #info NETCONF approved for nitrogen release!  Congrats and Thank you!
16:27:49 <jmorvay> Cool, thanks
16:28:13 <klou> vishnoianil - ready for ovsdb?
16:28:18 <vishnoianil> klou yes
16:28:23 <klou> #topic OVSDB
16:28:34 <klou> #info vishnoianil represents OVSDB
16:28:50 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/63009/ - release notes
16:29:21 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - thank you!
16:29:35 <klou> Have you tested RC3 or later?  Any blockers/concerns?
16:29:55 <vishnoianil> It's been Test in our CSIT jobs and through netvirt jobs
16:30:22 <vishnoianil> I don't see any blocker reported by downstream project, neither we discover anything in our CSIT tests
16:30:55 <klou> There is one CSIT failure related to ovsdb - you updated as OKAY for RC1
16:31:05 <klou> Can you review and update for RC2, RC3, RC3.1?
16:31:17 <vishnoianil> klou yes, that's known and non-critical bug
16:31:35 <klou> Is this something we can address for oxygen and beyond?
16:31:40 <vishnoianil> i believe jamo updated those test, but i can do that
16:31:54 <vishnoianil> yes, we will address that bug in oxygen
16:32:18 <klou> sounds good - things look good - anything else you want to add?
16:33:23 <vishnoianil> klou I looked at the CLM report, and it's looks like there is no voilation for OVSDB
16:33:38 <vishnoianil> we did not add any new library after previous release
16:33:43 <klou> that's good!
16:34:01 <klou> #info OVSDB approved for nitrogen release! Congrats and Thank you!
16:34:11 <vishnoianil> thanks klou
16:36:08 <klou> We are quite a bit ahead of schedule.  Do we have any project ready for the review?
17:00:04 <klou> evanz - ready to go?
17:00:44 <evanz> @klou sure
17:01:11 <klou> #topic L2SWITCH
17:01:37 <klou> #info evanz (Evan Zeller) represents L2SWITCH
17:01:58 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/62927/ - release notes
17:02:32 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout not captured in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet
17:03:16 <klou> #info Sonar report https://sonar.opendaylight.org/component_issues/index?id=org.opendaylight.l2switch%3Al2switch#resolved=false shows no blocker or critical issues
17:03:37 <klou> Have you tested RC3 or later?  Any blockers or concerns?
17:04:34 <evanz> Yes, looks good. No blockers or concerns from my side
17:05:02 <klou> #info no CSIT problems
17:05:17 <klou> things look good - anything else you want to add?
17:06:08 <evanz> Nope, this was just karaf 4 for us. So thanks to others who did hard work on that elsewhere
17:06:25 <klou> #info L2SWITCH approved for nitrogen release! Congrats and thank you!
17:07:10 <evanz> thanks @klou
17:07:22 <klou> Thank you evanz!
17:08:10 <klou> Do we have opflex rep?
17:08:12 <readams> I'm here now if you want to go early
17:08:28 <klou> Thank you readams!
17:08:38 <klou> #topic OPFLEX
17:08:49 <readams> Sorry for last minute everything I was on PTO :-)
17:08:53 <klou> #info readams (Rob Adams) represents OPFLEX
17:09:21 <klou> np Rob - understood!
17:09:51 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/63110 - release notes
17:10:49 <klou> I do not see an M5 milestone readout for opflex - can you comment on whether you have CLM violations?
17:11:04 <readams> Sorry I sent the M5 literally 5 minutes ago
17:11:21 <readams> It's basically N/A N/A N/A down the line :-)
17:11:28 <klou> ok np - sounds good
17:11:52 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided - nothing of concern for CLM
17:12:08 <klou> Have you tested RC3 or later?  Any blockers/concerns?
17:12:23 <readams> Also N/A but we'll just say yes
17:12:49 <klou> #info no CSIT problems
17:13:03 <klou> Things look good - do you have anything else you want to add?
17:13:27 <readams> Things should be simpler this time around since there are release jobs to push to Nexus now
17:13:43 <klou> #info OPFLEX approved for nitrogen release! Congrats and thank you!
17:13:46 <readams> So thanks to Anil for that
17:14:11 <readams> Thanks folks congrats on another release
17:14:42 <klou> Thanks readmas!  We are close but not quite there yet
17:15:30 <klou> Is openflowplugin ready to go?
17:18:35 <klou> abhijitkumbhare?
17:24:07 <abhijitkumbhare_> Hi klou - let me know when you want to go
17:24:16 <klou> #topic OPENFLOWPLUGIN
17:24:59 <klou> #info abhijitkumbhare (Abhijit Kumbhare) represents OPENFLOWPLUGIN
17:25:19 <klou> #link https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/63019/ - release notes
17:25:19 <abhijitkumbhare_> Please use abhijitkumbhare_
17:25:52 <klou> #info abhijitkumbhare_ represents OPENFLOWPLUGIN
17:26:16 <klou> #info M5 milestone readout provided and documented in nitrogen tracking spreadsheet - thank you
17:26:43 <klou> abhijitkumbhare_: Have you tested RC3 or later?  Any blockers/concerns?
17:27:11 <abhijitkumbhare_> Yes - we use the automated tests
17:28:04 <abhijitkumbhare_> I believe we will likely raised a blocker based on one of those test results on MD-SAL
17:28:31 <abhijitkumbhare_> But still investigating that bug
17:28:44 <klou> ok please do that as soon as possible
17:28:49 <abhijitkumbhare_> LuisGomez is investigating that bug
17:29:06 <abhijitkumbhare_> https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9145
17:29:48 <abhijitkumbhare_> The blocker we have on OpenFlow Plugin is: 9038
17:30:03 <abhijitkumbhare_> https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9038
17:30:07 <klou> Thank you!
17:30:15 <abhijitkumbhare_> It is in progress
17:30:26 <klou> Any ETA on 9038?
17:31:37 <klou> Are all the CSIT failures related to openflowplugin accounted for?
17:31:51 <abhijitkumbhare_> From last status from the bug: I believe Jozef has asked for input on his changes to Michael Vorburger - who is in turn needing input from some test team
17:32:29 <abhijitkumbhare_> Yes - for RC3 (RC3.1 from today morning has not been analyzed
17:32:48 <abhijitkumbhare_> failures on RC3.1 I mean
17:33:01 <klou> thank you!
17:33:18 <klou> Anything else you want to add?
17:33:26 <abhijitkumbhare_> No - nothing else
17:34:06 <klou> We can approve openflowplugin for release pending resolution of 9038
17:34:21 <abhijitkumbhare_> There is another issue that Sam / NetVirt have with OpenFlow Plugin - but we will prioritize it.
17:34:31 <abhijitkumbhare_> Yes - we can
17:35:01 <abhijitkumbhare_> It has not been raised to blocker yet
17:35:30 <klou> #info OPENFLOWPLUGIN approved for nitrogen release pending resolution of blocker bugs (9038 and others, if any). Thank you!
17:36:15 <klou> abhijitkumbhare_: Thank you for providing the details!
17:36:33 <abhijitkumbhare_> Thanks klou for stepping in
17:36:53 <abhijitkumbhare_> Stepping into release manager shoes :)
17:37:28 <klou> Thank you!
17:38:01 <klou> Do we have any other project ready for review?  Will end the meeting in 3 minutes if no one steps up.
17:40:03 <klou> Due to short notice (my mistake) and other reasons, we have the following projects still needing to go through nitrogen release review:
17:40:42 <klou> cardinal, infrautils, mdsal, dlux, dluxapps, aaa, unimgr, ttp
17:41:58 <klou> If you represent any of these projects, please let me know when you want to go through the review or you can submit an email to complete the review
17:42:21 <klou> #endmeeting