========================== #opendaylight-meeting: tsc ========================== Meeting started by dfarrell07 at 16:58:38 UTC. The full logs are available at http://meetings.opendaylight.org/opendaylight-meeting/2018/tsc/opendaylight-meeting-tsc.2018-12-06-16.58.log.html . Meeting summary --------------- * TSC members please #info in (dfarrell07, 16:59:46) * skitt (skitt, 16:59:53) * Daniel Farrell for Thanh Ha (dfarrell07, 16:59:56) * premsankar (premsankar, 17:00:06) * faseelak (faseelak, 17:00:12) * LINK: https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/TSC:Meeting#Agenda agenda in the normal place (dfarrell07, 17:00:22) * LuisGomez (LuisGomez, 17:00:31) * jamoluhrsen (jamoluhrsen, 17:00:55) * shague (shague, 17:02:38) * abelur (abelur, 17:02:42) * anipbu (anipbu, 17:02:45) * Abhijit is sick and Ariel is at some manager meeting, so both not here I think (dfarrell07, 17:02:52) * TSC members, please remember to vote for the TSC chair (skitt, 17:03:18) * shague #project netvirt serviceutils odltools ovsdb (shague, 17:03:25) * if you haven't received an email with the Condorcet link, ping CaseyLF (skitt, 17:03:30) * TSC chair election (dfarrell07, 17:04:01) * voting is open, please go vote TSC members (dfarrell07, 17:04:10) * LF closure (dfarrell07, 17:04:24) * there will be a holiday shutdown for LF folks (dfarrell07, 17:04:54) * if you need casey he will be on IRC (dfarrell07, 17:05:07) * if you need IT support check lf-releng IRC and helpdesk (dfarrell07, 17:05:16) * LF it support channel is #lf-releng (CaseyLF, 17:05:23) * Releases (skitt, 17:05:45) * Fluorine SR1 is out, officially (skitt, 17:06:06) * Luis says it's getting a bit more clear how to do these MR releases, just need to remember that it's a bit more work/time after release (dfarrell07, 17:06:55) * skitt asks if it's all doc'd, LuisGomez says yes because he has no memory so he's always reading the doc (dfarrell07, 17:07:19) * Releasing the distro is now the same as releasing a release-managed project (skitt, 17:07:19) * Oxygen SR4 is on-going, with a number of last-minute patches, and we now have a build (skitt, 17:07:46) * We are waiting for sign-offs (skitt, 17:07:52) * LINK: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dYOY99twqHV_Q0YorAOOxmL0aFc3icNXg8qA_zGwKyA/edit#gid=1286339548 (abelur, 17:07:59) * LINK: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dYOY99twqHV_Q0YorAOOxmL0aFc3icNXg8qA_zGwKyA/edit#gid=1286339548 <- oxy sr4 csit sign-off (jamoluhrsen, 17:08:01) * there are still lots of projects that need sign-off (dfarrell07, 17:09:06) * vorburger (vorburger, 17:09:10) * Anil Vishnoi (vishnoianil, 17:09:28) * jamoluhrsen had concern that bgpcep had signed-off first totally-bad result as okay, turns out bgpcep doesn't know who did that, but the actual lead is actually auditing (dfarrell07, 17:09:52) * question about when to do SR2 Fl, since SR1 was quite late (dfarrell07, 17:12:02) * can either bump it out and maybe also adjust other SR dates, or maybe just drop the SR and only have 3 for fl (dfarrell07, 17:12:27) * SR3 is scheduled for Feb 7, so that's pretty good timing anyway (dfarrell07, 17:13:11) * AGREED: Fluorine SR2 will happen on SR3 orig date, SR3 on SR4 date, and no SR4 (dfarrell07, 17:14:42) * release (dfarrell07, 17:22:42) * we went through dashboard but didn't take notes, all is okay (dfarrell07, 17:22:52) * ONAP Edge using ODL (dfarrell07, 17:23:15) * Prem brings discussion about ODL usage in ONAP Edge effort (dfarrell07, 17:23:28) * Prem would like to see us work on reducing footprint and bring down startup time for ODL to be more useful in ONAP Edge (dfarrell07, 17:24:01) * Ildiko is talking with Prem about some usage of ODL in ONAP as well (dfarrell07, 17:24:22) * vorburger has some efforts, old-simple, that would help with bringing down footprint/startup (dfarrell07, 17:25:03) * some +1s to bringing group together who have interests in this, but mainly need people working in the trenches to make progress (dfarrell07, 17:25:40) * basically we need devs who want this to step up and do work, but can start a group and then hope we pull in those people (dfarrell07, 17:26:23) * ODL rep for ONAP (dfarrell07, 17:26:43) * Prem has been attending various ONAP meetings and noticed a need/ask for ODL people to come and be in their conversations (dfarrell07, 17:27:19) * Prem gives info about SDNC and SDNR usage of ODL in ONAP (dfarrell07, 17:29:06) * For SDNR, they want netconf to be very performate so can handle large yang models (dfarrell07, 17:29:38) * tl;dr there are many consumers of ODL in ONAP and we should do a better job of interacting with them (dfarrell07, 17:30:13) * maybe prem can come back and give some more detailed presentations about ODL in ONAP and help drive better collaboration, help us understand what users need (dfarrell07, 17:30:57) * dfarrell07 suggests we can combine this with thoughts about getting people who get value from ODL supporting ODL (dfarrell07, 17:32:19) * maybe we can work with these folks using ODL to teach them how to support/improve the parts they care about (dfarrell07, 17:32:42) * anil V suggests we have something like the old advisor group, but for these open source projects vs companies (dfarrell07, 17:34:32) * LuisGomez points out that a huge user for ODL is various other Open source projects, so really should work on supporting those downstreams (dfarrell07, 17:34:57) * there are companies that have lots of devs working on ODL, but they are just doing it in ONAP, which is very, very sad (dfarrell07, 17:35:35) * Prem says there are lots of not-shared ~forks of ODL in various places in ONAP, need to get those people working with us (dfarrell07, 17:36:21) * ACTION: dfarrell07 to bring idea to TAC to start having periodic, maybe monthly, meetings with projects that consume ODL to get feedback (dfarrell07, 17:38:14) * CII badging for ONAP ODL work (dfarrell07, 17:40:12) * ONAP is doing lots of scanning to do CII badging (dfarrell07, 17:40:27) * they have told us a number of times that they are picking up issues with ODL (dfarrell07, 17:40:45) * they didn't get back to us with details of what they are seeing, per our request (dfarrell07, 17:40:56) * the current email thread also doesn't have the detail we need (dfarrell07, 17:41:07) * LINK: https://clm.opendaylight.org/assets/index.html ODL CLM should also show these issues (dfarrell07, 17:41:45) * they have quite a few components that we don't care about, like DLUX, that are likely pulling in many problems (dfarrell07, 17:42:19) * they also are on oxygen sr3, and oxygen sr4 is about to go out the door, then no more oxygen, so bit late for that version (dfarrell07, 17:42:42) * ACTION: skitt will follow-up on ONAP email regarding vulns (dfarrell07, 17:44:03) * michael has sent one reply, but bounced, skitt will send properly to ONAP TSC list (dfarrell07, 17:46:07) * there has also been discussion about hiring an intern to clean up CLM, but that will not happen right away (dfarrell07, 17:52:46) * infra (dfarrell07, 17:52:48) * abelur gives updates about recent infra issues (dfarrell07, 17:52:57) * just went to CentOS 7.6, which seems to have fixed some load issues (dfarrell07, 17:53:15) * there also seems to be issue between a proxy and nexus, working on understanding (dfarrell07, 17:53:47) * jobs with many small files might be more impacted (dfarrell07, 17:54:10) * workaround is to retrigger jobs (dfarrell07, 17:54:15) * vexxhost team is kinda blocker at the moment, so no eta (dfarrell07, 17:54:54) * javadocs jobs seem to be main jobs impacted, verify and publish, most other seem to be stable at this point (dfarrell07, 17:55:34) * many small files are causing sockets to go into wait, then run out of sockets (dfarrell07, 17:56:41) * tomp says he's seeing CSIT controller job fails, jamoluhrsen says that's likely the autorelease malformed URL issue (dfarrell07, 17:57:15) * if you see a mountain of red in jobs triggered from autorelease, keep this in mind (dfarrell07, 17:58:02) * cookies (dfarrell07, 17:58:32) Meeting ended at 17:58:35 UTC. Action items, by person ----------------------- * dfarrell07 * dfarrell07 to bring idea to TAC to start having periodic, maybe monthly, meetings with projects that consume ODL to get feedback * skitt * skitt will follow-up on ONAP email regarding vulns People present (lines said) --------------------------- * dfarrell07 (71) * skitt (12) * odl_meetbot (5) * abelur (4) * LuisGomez (3) * vorburger (2) * faseelak (2) * premsankar (2) * jamoluhrsen (2) * anipbu (2) * shague (2) * vishnoianil (2) * CaseyLF (1) * rovarga (0) * phrobb (0) Generated by `MeetBot`_ 0.1.4