16:02:08 <yamahata_> #startmeeting neutron_northbound
16:02:08 <odl_meetbot> Meeting started Fri Mar 11 16:02:08 2016 UTC.  The chair is yamahata_. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html.
16:02:08 <odl_meetbot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
16:02:08 <odl_meetbot> The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_northbound'
16:02:25 <yamahata_> #chair rcurran asomya
16:02:25 <odl_meetbot> Current chairs: asomya rcurran yamahata_
16:02:39 <yamahata_> in case of network disconnection
16:02:47 <yamahata_> #topic agenda bashing and roll call
16:02:49 <yamahata_> #info yamahata
16:03:22 <yamahata_> any agenda topics in addition to usual topics?
16:04:42 <yamahata_> seems nothing
16:04:49 <yamahata_> #topic Announcements
16:05:03 <yamahata_> openstack mitaka-3 is past. feature freeze.
16:05:10 <yamahata_> mitaka release is fast approaching.
16:06:04 <yamahata_> next announce is, our proposal for openstack summit was accepted. Thank you. and please help with preparing presentation.
16:06:26 <yamahata_> the last one is, next week there is ONS and ODL mini summit.
16:06:37 <yamahata_> Is anyone attending it?
16:07:28 <rcurran> no
16:07:45 <yamahata_> any other announcement?
16:08:49 <yamahata_> #topic action items from last meeting
16:09:17 <yamahata_> all actions are related to patches.
16:09:34 <yamahata_> I suppose basically all are addressed. or needs reveiw.
16:09:50 <yamahata_> so let's discuss in patch review
16:10:12 <yamahata_> #topic patch review
16:10:35 <yamahata_> any patch requires attention?
16:10:47 <yamahata_> last week we discussed about https://review.openstack.org/#/c/290803/
16:10:54 <yamahata_> ODL v2: Improve L3 validation
16:11:00 <yamahata_> I'll review it today to merge it.
16:11:08 <rcurran> thanks
16:11:27 <yamahata_> Given mitaka-3 is released, I'd like to merge it first and fix issues later.
16:11:41 <yamahata_> so that we can test v2 driver.
16:11:50 <rcurran> agreed
16:12:33 <yamahata_> next patch is https://review.openstack.org/#/c/275142/
16:12:41 <yamahata_> Add sync_all process into v2 driver init
16:14:04 <yamahata_> I suppose we should understand the problem deeper. Yalei has started to write down a sort of spec in sync.rst
16:14:10 <yamahata_> #link https://review.openstack.org/#/c/275142/10/doc/source/sync.rst
16:15:01 <yamahata_> It would help to understand the problem and the patch.
16:15:19 <yamahata_> please review sync.rst and then we can make progress.
16:16:32 <yamahata_> The last one from me is, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/290264/
16:16:39 <yamahata_> devstack: switch default odl version to beryllium snapshot
16:16:51 <yamahata_> This is just heads up. It will change the default to use beryllium.
16:17:00 <yamahata_> I'll merge it today.
16:17:22 <yamahata_> That's all from me.
16:17:28 <yamahata_> any other patches to discuss?
16:17:40 <rcurran> odlv2 sg is still in q
16:17:42 <rcurran> queue
16:17:52 <rcurran> small change set
16:18:27 <yamahata_> oh, https://review.openstack.org/#/c/281490/ ?
16:18:55 <rcurran> yes
16:19:37 <rcurran> once this gets merged, yalei will change it to use new callback.PRECOMMIT code (once that is all merged)
16:19:44 <yamahata_> I see. I think I can merge it today.
16:19:50 <rcurran> this is using the older callback code
16:20:30 <yamahata_> It would take a while to fix precommit event
16:21:04 <yamahata_> https://review.openstack.org/#/c/281693/
16:21:04 <yamahata_> Pass the complete info of sg/rule db into PRECOMMIT callback
16:21:16 <rcurran> haven't been following the details but it does seem the neutron/ side is taking a while to complete
16:22:22 <yamahata_> any other patches?
16:22:48 <yamahata_> any patches on odl side?
16:23:42 <yamahata_> #topic bugs
16:24:07 <yamahata_> https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5478
16:24:08 <yamahata_> Null values received on neutron security-group-rule-delete and security-group-delete
16:24:22 <yamahata_> This bug was reported as blocker on ODL side
16:24:40 <yamahata_> Actually the patch has been floating around for a while
16:24:42 <yamahata_> https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/33957/
16:25:19 <yamahata_> If no objections, I'm going to merge it. (with rebase)
16:25:42 <yamahata_> another bug I'd like to raise is https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=4770
16:25:49 <yamahata_> Updated security rule fails to delete after instance termination
16:26:16 <yamahata_> It also needs attention.
16:27:01 <yamahata_> Right now, it seems many bugs related to security group and L3 routing are reported
16:27:14 <yamahata_> so it's the area to stabilize/harden.
16:27:39 <yamahata_> any issues on openstack side?
16:28:46 <yamahata_> okay next topic
16:28:54 <yamahata_> #topic ML2 ODL driver rewrite
16:29:15 <yamahata_> we've discussed patch review. anything else to discuss?
16:29:47 <rcurran> not from me
16:30:00 <asomya> none from me either, everything's been merged.. thanks :)
16:30:14 <yamahata_> after several patches are merged, we can start to test it.
16:30:34 <yamahata_> then we will see how well (or bad) v2 driver works. and bug fixes.
16:30:47 <rcurran> correct
16:30:48 <yamahata_> Then the default would be switched to v2.
16:31:09 <yamahata_> Hopefully we could eliminate v1. but it depends on test outcome.
16:31:26 <rcurran> agreed
16:32:07 <yamahata_> I hoped to merge fullsync patch. But I'm not sure if we can make it or not.
16:32:55 <yamahata_> any comments/thoughts for next steps?
16:34:03 <rcurran> steps on testing ODLv2?
16:34:04 <yamahata_> seems nothing.
16:34:10 <yamahata_> undo.
16:34:38 <yamahata_> testing or any further step for mitaka or newton
16:34:55 <rcurran> oh, no nothing from me outside of the ODLv2 topic
16:35:33 <yamahata_> I'd like to have a good documentation for setup with ODL so that people can give it a try.
16:36:07 <yamahata_> Right now our documents is only devstack/README.rst. it's good for developers, but not for operators/users/testers.
16:36:27 <yamahata_> I got several complain about it.
16:36:42 <yamahata_> I mean networking-odl/devstack/README.rst
16:37:04 <yamahata_> oops.
16:37:10 <yamahata_> #topic Open Mike
16:37:16 <yamahata_> I should've changed the topic
16:38:00 <yamahata_> any other topic to discuss?
16:40:54 <yamahata_> Is any plan/wishlist/any for v2 driver for newton cycle?
16:41:31 <yamahata_> we could discuss on it at the next openstack summit. I'm speculating
16:41:46 <rcurran> meaning additional functionality?
16:42:16 <yamahata_> yeah. or whatever necessary for networking-odl
16:43:02 <rcurran> full-sync (which yalei has already started)
16:44:07 <yamahata_> On ODL side, I'd like to support (centralized) SNAT
16:44:13 <yamahata_> for boron
16:45:22 <yamahata_> For Mitaka release, I'd like to fix all remaining tempest scenario failures.
16:45:50 <yamahata_> anything else to discuss?
16:46:06 <yamahata_> or giving back 15min...
16:46:56 <rcurran> not from e
16:46:57 <rcurran> me
16:47:11 <yamahata_> okay than you everyone
16:47:20 <rcurran> thanks
16:47:21 <yamahata_> #topic cookies
16:47:25 <yamahata_> #endmeeting