15:00:53 <yamahata> #startmeeting neutron_northbound
15:00:53 <odl_meetbot> Meeting started Mon May 22 15:00:53 2017 UTC.  The chair is yamahata. Information about MeetBot at http://ci.openstack.org/meetbot.html.
15:00:53 <odl_meetbot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic #startvote.
15:00:53 <odl_meetbot> The meeting name has been set to 'neutron_northbound'
15:00:58 <jhershbe_> yamahata, can we add discussing the slides for the DDF to the agenda or would oyu rather do that a little later
15:01:01 <yamahata> #chari rajivk
15:01:04 <yamahata> #char jhershbe_
15:01:24 <yamahata> jhershbe_: then let's do it early as I need to go early.
15:01:30 <yamahata> #topic agenda bashing and roll call
15:01:33 <jhershbe_> yamahata, k
15:01:36 <yamahata> #info yamahata
15:01:46 <yamahata> #link https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NeutronNorthbound:Meetings meeting agenda
15:01:47 <rajivk_> #info rajiv
15:02:22 <yamahata> after announcement and action items, we'll discuss about the slides for the DDF
15:02:31 <yamahata> do we have anything else?
15:02:43 <yamahata> inaddition to bugs/patches.
15:02:59 <mkolesni> hi
15:03:05 <mkolesni> #info mkolesni
15:03:18 <yamahata> mkolesni: hi. Isaku need to go early today.
15:03:21 <yamahata> #chair mkolesni
15:03:21 <odl_meetbot> Current chairs: mkolesni yamahata
15:03:28 <yamahata> #chair jhershbe_
15:03:28 <odl_meetbot> Current chairs: jhershbe_ mkolesni yamahata
15:03:33 <yamahata> #char rajivk
15:03:41 <yamahata> #chair rajivk
15:03:41 <odl_meetbot> Current chairs: jhershbe_ mkolesni rajivk yamahata
15:03:56 <yamahata> mkolesni: do you have any agenda items?
15:04:15 <mkolesni> yamahata, no just some patches
15:04:31 <yamahata> sure.
15:04:33 <yamahata> #topic Announcements
15:04:49 <yamahata> opendaylight carbon RC2 was released.
15:04:52 <yamahata> let's test it.
15:05:13 <yamahata> ODL DDL is approaching. so let's sort out topics for it.
15:05:32 <yamahata> anything else for announcement?
15:06:05 <yamahata> ok move on
15:06:07 <yamahata> #topic action items from last meeting
15:06:17 <yamahata> so far last action items are all patch review etc.
15:06:31 <yamahata> #topic pike/nitrogen planning
15:06:39 <yamahata> jhershbe_: now you're on stage
15:06:44 <jhershbe_> k
15:06:55 <jhershbe_> slides for discussion of next phase for DDF...
15:07:04 <jhershbe_> https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1gJmpsZsCxwzUMyDS3RUYIu-nIHP_kcYAX2CsS0-IsfQ/edit#slide=id.g1f44ace190_0_18
15:07:24 <yamahata> #link https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1gJmpsZsCxwzUMyDS3RUYIu-nIHP_kcYAX2CsS0-IsfQ/edit#slide=id.g1f44ace190_0_18 ddf slides
15:07:31 <jhershbe_> yamahata, I put in some more comments. Including a new, 3rd proposal
15:07:34 <yamahata> Is the slide viewable by anyone?
15:07:41 <jhershbe_> ah, let me check
15:08:49 <jhershbe_> yamahata, it's in my redhat acct and it seems they make it so you need to explicitly add viewers so if anyone wants to see, please send me your email
15:09:15 <yamahata> I can view the slide. I just wanted the slide public.
15:09:19 <jhershbe_> yamahata, can I confirm that we are still on track with the original two approaches. Those are the ones we're presenting, correct?
15:09:21 <rajivk_> jhershbe_, I just requested for permission.
15:09:52 <yamahata> Not only for approved people, but also for anyone else.
15:10:02 <yamahata> jhershbe_: yes.
15:10:32 <jhershbe_> yamahata, I left some questions in there for you in comments. Plus would appreciate you taking a look at my new 3rd option
15:10:37 <yamahata> My big concern is, can we address any other neutron resource? and unplug case can be addressed without big change?
15:11:40 <jhershbe_> yamahata, the only issue is for when there is a disconnect. Generally speaking unplug is supported
15:11:42 <yamahata> For now those two don't have to be addressed immediately, but I'd like to make it sure that the implementation can be easily extended for those cases.
15:12:29 <yamahata> With proposal 1, I don't see easy way for unplug case.
15:12:34 <yamahata> Can you please elaborate on it?
15:13:05 <jhershbe_> it would be nice if we can have an implementation that can be easily extended to handle other resources and unplug, if not, I'd settle for not putting in too much work for now, i.e., keeping it similar to current implementation
15:14:01 <jhershbe_> yamahata, supporting unplug requires something like 2-phase/journal. 2-phase is on the slides. That handles unplug.
15:14:51 <yamahata> okay
15:14:57 <jhershbe_> anyway, I don't think we need to hash out the pros/cons now. Just to make sure there is enough material (and hte right material) on the slides to facilitate a good convo at the DDF
15:15:42 <yamahata> jhershbe_: yeah. I think we have enougth materials to fuel discussion.
15:15:44 <yamahata> at DDF
15:16:10 <yamahata> I'll check your additional comments later.
15:16:46 <jhershbe_> yamahata, excellent. I'm going to sit with Sam and M. Vorburger on the slides before the summit so that we can have more people familiar with the issues going into the discussion.
15:17:09 <yamahata> very great.
15:17:25 <yamahata> I'm not sure I can attend tomorrow ovsdb/netvirt meeting.
15:17:43 <jhershbe_> yamahata, that, and my two outstanding gerrits are ready to go from my perspective so if we could move those fwd that would be great
15:17:54 <yamahata> sure.
15:18:01 <yamahata> oh, now I have to go.
15:18:01 <jhershbe_> yamahata, it's not on the netvirt meeting agenda, I will sit with them privately
15:18:10 <jhershbe_> thanks. ttyl
15:18:11 <yamahata> now boarding has started.
15:18:18 <jhershbe_> have a good flight
15:18:37 <jhershbe_> mkolesni, I'm going to leave as well
15:18:38 <mkolesni> have a good flight isaku
15:18:43 <mkolesni> jhershbe_, ok
15:21:19 <mkolesni> is there a quorum to continue or can we call it?
15:51:55 <mkolesni> #endmeeting