16:01:07 <narinder> #startmeeting JOID 16:01:07 <collabot> Meeting started Wed Jul 26 16:01:07 2017 UTC. The chair is narinder. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 16:01:07 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 16:01:07 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'joid' 16:07:44 <narinder> #info Narinder Gupta 16:08:00 <rprakash> #info rprakash 16:10:19 <narinder> https://etherpad.opnfv.org/p/joid 16:12:54 <rprakash> #link https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/joid/ 16:14:22 <rprakash> #link https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/joid/job/joid-os-nosdn-nofeature-ha-baremetal-daily-master/ 16:15:17 <rprakash> #link https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/joid/job/joid-os-ocl-nofeature-ha-baremetal-daily-master/ 16:18:53 <rprakash> #info for OCL scenario fails because failed to connect to BMC on Server Hardware , may be firmware issue 16:19:59 <rprakash> #machine #1 , #5 or ok but #2,#3,#4 Juniper pod-1 16:22:28 <rprakash> #verify 4-core 32GB s 4-core with 64GB, appear 64 GB works but 32GB fails 16:23:50 <rprakash> #may require MS5 exception once Pod BMC is fixed bundle should work. 16:26:39 <rprakash> #info akash working on OVN charm bestpractices, integration works 16:30:05 <rprakash> #info ovn4nfv 16:30:10 <rprakash> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/38027/ 16:30:22 <rprakash> #info openbaton 16:31:23 <rprakash> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/37865/ 16:38:25 <rprakash> #info (Michael) This patchset should serve as a post install step for joid installer in order to install/configure openbaton + juju vnfm 16:39:26 <rprakash> #joid build should be empty for os-nosdn-openbaton-ha or non-ha 16:43:53 <narinder> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/37535/ 16:51:57 <narinder> https://build.opnfv.org/ci/user/narindergupta/my-views/view/joid/job/joid-k8-ovn-lb-noha-baremetal-daily-master/ 16:52:41 <narinder> https://build.opnfv.org/ci/user/narindergupta/my-views/view/joid/job/joid-k8-ovn-lb-noha-baremetal-daily-master/4/ 13:56:03 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Narinder Gupta proposed joid: changing the bundle which works for OCL. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38279 13:56:56 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Merged joid: changing the bundle which works for OCL. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38279 15:42:31 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Stuart Mackie proposed joid: Change Contrail repo and key https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38289 16:01:29 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Merged joid: Change Contrail repo and key https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38289 16:33:43 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Narinder Gupta proposed joid: modified the bundle for HA. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38295 16:34:25 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Merged joid: modified the bundle for HA. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38295 13:01:32 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Stuart Mackie proposed joid: Added keys into bundle for ocl https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38335 13:25:59 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Merged joid: Added keys into bundle for ocl https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38335 17:20:02 <narindergupta> fenar, hi good morning 07:34:24 <Martin_nokia> Hi, has anyone experienced the error "No rack controllers can access the BMC of node" during node commissioning? (I can access and control the IPMI from the jumphost without any issues) 13:06:21 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: can we get more logs and see and also please check whether IPMI over lan is enabled or not for few system? 13:06:53 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: are you able to run ipmi commands from jumphost and check the power status of the nodes. 13:10:32 <Martin__nokia> Hi Narinder, turns out that was my mistake in config. I keep trying many different variations to get it working that I've mistakenly left wrong ipmi settings there. 13:29:40 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: :) this happens which lab are you trying joid currently? 13:30:27 <Martin__nokia> We're trying to deploy it in a new lab pod here but I've been trying since June with limited success so far. 13:31:17 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: it should be straighnt forward as soon as you have labconfig.yaml defined correctly? I can help you in rectifying error 13:31:46 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: if you can provide me access or share your screen? 13:31:51 <Martin__nokia> Our problem seems to be especially the network configuration. 13:32:55 <Martin__nokia> We've summed it up in one email here: https://lists.opnfv.org/pipermail/opnfv-tech-discuss/2017-June/016833.html 13:35:06 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: yeah Danube it got mixed up because with Juju 2.2 we started supporting advance ntworking as well. 13:35:48 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: if you would go for master branch it is more clear now and documentation still has to be updated. 13:36:01 <narinder`> now lets talk about your questions one by one 13:36:47 <Martin__nokia> Yeah, I have been trying mostly master branch. But I usually end up with networking problems. Generally the issue is no outside connectivity on the bootstrap VM 13:37:28 <narinder`> question 1 only admin/management network needs internet access. but floating ips network need a gateway as well so that tenant_vm can be reached. 13:38:03 <narinder`> looks like your admin network do not have internet connectivity where dhcp by MAAS is running 13:38:15 <narinder`> can i login in your jumphost? 13:38:58 <narinder`> normally i do ip forwading on admin network to external network 13:39:23 <narinder`> so any connection make on brAdm would go via brExt 13:40:08 <narinder`> question 4 answer is yes 13:40:45 <narinder`> question 5 admin/data i expect atleast /24 13:41:05 <narinder`> for floating it could be as per your needs 13:41:24 <narinder`> not brPublic 13:41:52 <narinder`> onlt floating ips can be others can be atleast /24 13:42:03 <narinder`> as we reserve few ips 13:42:09 <Martin__nokia> I'm a bit confused about differences floating vs public, some of the labconfigs are not quite clear on the difference I think. 13:42:39 <narinder`> public would be used for openstack ppublic API... 13:43:02 <narinder`> and floating is for tenant floating ips network 13:43:54 <narinder`> unfornately both can not be same as floating ip network is configured by openvswitch and can not shared on physical host 13:43:57 <Martin__nokia> My question would then be, which IPs need to be reachable from the outside network? Because I don't want to occupy too many public IPs (as we have a limited number of them) 13:44:52 <narinder`> floating definetely 13:45:15 <narinder`> rest of the network can be ip ward to this floating ip network 13:45:28 <narinder`> specially on jumphost 13:45:52 <narinder`> data network do not need internet access. 13:46:10 <Martin__nokia> Ok, that sounds good. I was trying to put something like that together but I couldn't figure out how to do the forwarding/redirecting, so that other networks (except the floating) can remain internal. 13:46:42 <narinder`> yes but atleast admin network needs to ip warding then 13:47:24 <narinder`> admin is pxe nwtwork and which needs internet for deployment and can be ipward on jumphost 13:49:28 <Martin__nokia> So how can I perform the correct ipwarding on the jumphost please? I played with various routing options but was unable to get it to work as needed, i.e. through the floating network 13:50:14 <narinder`> i am hoping all of your interface are bridges. 13:50:24 <Martin__nokia> yep 13:50:31 <narinder`> let me point you of script which can do 13:51:01 <Martin__nokia> https://lists.opnfv.org/pipermail/opnfv-tech-discuss/attachments/20170628/28a54c9e/attachment-0002.obj 13:52:38 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: i have to go and will be back in 30 minutes. Will let you know by then 13:53:29 <Martin__nokia> Thanks for your help! Not sure if I can stay here that late today but if you're available tomorrow or in the next days, I'd be thankful for all advice to get it running properly. 14:08:40 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: u there 14:08:47 <Martin__nokia> Yes 14:09:13 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: let me give you port forwarding sccript just wait for 5 min. 14:09:29 <Martin__nokia> Thanks! 14:11:39 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: can u access this http://bazaar.launchpad.net/~narindergupta/+junk/hp-moonshot/view/head:/usr/bin/orange-box-setup-nat 14:11:40 <narinder`> ? 14:12:00 <Martin__nokia> Yes 14:12:04 <narinder`> ok cool 14:12:17 <narinder`> heyou can start from line 58 14:12:38 <narinder`> and export internal and internal value 14:12:51 <narinder`> run it upto line 80 14:13:07 <narinder`> but it will remove all iptable rules 14:13:20 <narinder`> and i am hoping you have Ubuntu 16.04 on jumphost 14:14:18 <Martin__nokia> Yes, 16.04.2 or something like that 14:14:24 <narinder`> ok cool 14:14:30 <narinder`> this should work then 14:14:43 <narinder`> let me know in case face any issues 14:14:49 <Martin__nokia> I'm currently trying to reinstall the ubuntu system but seems like I've messed the networking up somehow, my jumphost is not even showing up among the switches 14:15:00 <Martin__nokia> I mean "in the switch" 14:15:04 <narinder`> oh 14:15:20 <Martin__nokia> But I'll give it a try once I figure it out. 14:15:29 <narinder`> sure 14:15:33 <Martin__nokia> I've been testing too much networking magic probably 14:15:40 <narinder`> :) 14:17:27 <Martin__nokia> But it's weird that even the connected MAC does not show up in the switch... Now I'm unable to install the networking inside of the jumphost ubuntu install. 14:17:43 <Martin__nokia> Maybe it will just magically work tomorrow again. 14:20:20 <narinder`> :) 14:29:19 <Martin__nokia> narinder`: While I'm at it, one more configuration that is not clear to me is the `ext-port` and `public-api-ip` parameters. Do I need to specify then and what are they for? 14:36:55 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: floating-ip-range and ext-port are needed 14:37:25 <narinder`> ext-port should be interface where your floating ips exist 14:37:31 <narinder`> and :q 14:37:35 <narinder`> :q 14:38:23 <Martin__nokia> :q ? 14:38:24 <narinder`> take examples in ../labconfig/lenovo/pod1/labconfig.yaml for two interfaces only 14:38:31 <narinder`> without seperate data network 14:38:42 <narinder`> admin and floating ip network only 14:39:06 <Martin__nokia> There it's br-intf101 14:39:50 <Martin__nokia> Also, floating links to public bridge 14:40:03 <Martin__nokia> and additionaly there's external space too 14:44:32 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Narinder Gupta proposed joid: Adding the OS_DOMAIN_PROJECT_ID https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38633 14:45:09 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Merged joid: Adding the OS_DOMAIN_PROJECT_ID https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/38633 14:51:57 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: here floating is not on external 14:52:49 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: here external is to access to the jumphost 14:53:20 <narinder`> and we floating they have seperate gateway 14:54:22 <Martin__nokia> Confusing... 14:54:58 <Martin__nokia> So in my case, if my nodes are connected to the floating space with interface ens255f1, should also my ext-port be ens255f1? 15:14:23 <Martin__nokia> Ok, gotta go now, thanks again for the help, I'll test it tomorrow if I get the networking working. 15:58:33 <narinder`> yes 15:58:43 <narinder`> Martin__nokia: answer is yes 16:01:35 <Martin__nokia> thanks 16:03:22 <collabot> narinder`: Error: Can't start another meeting, one is in progress. Use #endmeeting first. 16:03:30 <narinder`> #endmeeting JOID