16:02:05 <frankbrockners> #startmeeting OPNFV BGS daily synch
16:02:05 <collabot> Meeting started Wed May 27 16:02:05 2015 UTC.  The chair is frankbrockners. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:02:05 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
16:02:05 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'opnfv_bgs_daily_synch'
16:02:14 * ChrisPriceAB ah no we did not
16:02:23 <frankbrockners> #info Frank Brockners
16:02:29 <ChrisPriceAB> #info Chris Price
16:02:42 <morgan_or> #info Morgan Richomme
16:02:47 <fdegir> #info Fatih Degirmenci
16:02:53 <trevor_intel> #info Trevor Cooper
16:02:56 <radez> #info Dan Radez
16:02:58 <pbandzi> #info Peter Bandzi
16:04:06 <frankbrockners> looks like we have a quorum
16:04:18 <HKirksey> #info Heather Kirksey
16:04:34 <frankbrockners> let's get started
16:05:09 <frankbrockners> #info updates/status on functest, POD1/2 autodeployment, docs
16:05:15 <frankbrockners> let's start with functest as usual
16:05:27 <frankbrockners> #info functest updates
16:05:32 <[1]JonasB> #info Jonas Bjurel
16:05:35 <frankbrockners> morgan_orange?
16:05:46 <frankbrockners> or morgan_or?
16:05:59 <morgan_or> #info short day today POD2 and POD1 not available before mid day
16:06:30 <morgan_or> #Info POD1 used for ODL tests
16:06:43 <morgan_or> #Info time used to update doc
16:08:12 <morgan_or> #Info POD2 functest relaunched 2 hours ago.  Issue on vPing un der investigation but Jenkins refactoring seems ok
16:08:21 * ChrisPriceAB Yay Morgan!
16:08:23 <frankbrockners> morgan_or - quick clarification: POD1 isn't ODL testing - it is for ODL-O/S integration testing right?
16:08:35 <morgan_or> Yes
16:09:07 <frankbrockners> apart from vPing - are there any other tests which we believe we can resolve for Arno?
16:09:07 <ChrisPriceAB> Are we running the test suite on POD1 yet?  (I had assumed so if not automated)
16:09:09 <morgan_or> That is all for me for today
16:09:54 <morgan_or> The 4 testcases small be runnable for Arno
16:10:42 * ChrisPriceAB they shall be run! ... flee you fools (sorry long day)
16:11:19 <HKirksey> We shall overcome!
16:11:35 <morgan_or> On POD1 we run 3 of them on the HA version. No run since switch to non HA + ODL
16:12:14 <morgan_or> Sorry for the speed. ..I am on my mobile
16:12:29 <ChrisPriceAB> Ok, will be good to understand if they are "Helium specific" or OPNFV specific issues.
16:13:03 <frankbrockners> let's go to the POD1 and POD2 updates in this case...
16:13:14 <frankbrockners> but prior to going there
16:14:01 <[1]JonasB> #info The only thing I have for POD1 is that Danie and Jose is working on the ODL integration&getting the ODL testcases to run cleanly
16:14:02 <frankbrockners> back on the earlier question: the 3 tests suites all run so far - the only one which has some issues still is vping?
16:14:05 <frankbrockners> correct?
16:14:50 <morgan_or> No it vPing was always ok on POD1
16:15:26 <morgan_or> Only issue was ODL in CI +functest cleaning. Manuel ODL was fine
16:15:27 * ChrisPriceAB May be a sticking point on POD 1 with auto-deploy of ODL integration... to be seen.
16:15:57 <frankbrockners> morgan_or - thanks for the clarification
16:17:15 <frankbrockners> [1]JonasB: Do you feel like we'll have the integration working and tested by sometime later this week?
16:17:16 <morgan_or> Before ODL intégration POD1 was very stable ..there were more network related errors on POD2. We will see with ODL integration if we face the same   errors
16:18:17 <frankbrockners> morgan_or: ack - the issue is just that one key thing we bring to the table with Arno is the integration of O/S and ODL.
16:18:59 <frankbrockners> let's move to POD2
16:19:08 <frankbrockners> radez: any quick update on POD2
16:19:10 <frankbrockners> ?
16:19:36 <[1]JonasB> frankbrockners> That must be the absolute goal to be ready by Fri, but as said / there seems to be instabilities across POD1 and POD2 which maybe related to Helium_
16:19:52 <[1]JonasB> sudo reboot
16:19:56 <radez> not from me, I've been distracted on other things leading to the Openstack summit and I haven't been in touch with Tim this week as he's out
16:20:11 * radez Going down for reboot
16:21:10 <[1]JonasB> ifconfig
16:21:39 * ChrisPriceAB oh dear, I feel beer may be required to restart the system at this point.
16:22:14 <frankbrockners> radez, morgan_or: any updates on the bootable ISO image - and the associated testing?
16:22:52 <ChrisPriceAB> For POD2, are we continuing to troubleshoot and identify stability issues?  I assume continuous deploy testing is still ongoing.
16:23:22 <morgan_or> Yes
16:23:29 <frankbrockners> ChrisPriceAB: We don't deploy POD2 from ISO but via deploy.sh script
16:23:29 <jose_lausuch> deployment is completed in pod 2 now, so testing currently
16:24:05 <ChrisPriceAB> Ack frankbrockners.
16:24:32 <frankbrockners> radez, morgan_or: Any updates on the ISO testing?
16:24:46 <morgan_or> No from my side
16:24:51 <radez> nope not there either, but I'm back on the scene today with the iso
16:25:06 <radez> hope to have more feedback in the next day or tow
16:25:08 <radez> two
16:25:13 <frankbrockners> who is orange was testing the ISO? was that arnaud?
16:25:55 <morgan_or> Yes arnaud tested it before openstack summit
16:26:38 <frankbrockners> ok - radez: could you check with Arnaud (morgan_or - maybe you could help as well)
16:26:39 <radez> I spoke with him at summit
16:26:49 <frankbrockners> ah - even better
16:26:59 <radez> we'll be in touch
16:27:00 <frankbrockners> sounds like you're already ahead of me
16:27:02 <frankbrockners> cool
16:27:28 <frankbrockners> any additional progress on docs?
16:27:48 <morgan_or> It seems that it was working to setup centos with  the genesis repo cloned in it
16:27:57 <ChrisPriceAB> Docs editing ongoing, will push a patch tonight for the install_instructions that align the layout and content of the docs
16:28:07 <morgan_or> But then the setup wasn't working well
16:28:10 <ChrisPriceAB> for the fuel and foreman instructions.
16:28:19 <morgan_or> Due to issues on network configuration
16:28:20 <ChrisPriceAB> Then the same for the release notes.
16:28:33 <frankbrockners> #info docs update: Docs editing ongoing, will push a patch tonight for the install_instructions that align the layout and content of the docs (ChrisPriceAB)
16:28:34 <morgan_or> This is a current work in progress with tim
16:28:35 <ChrisPriceAB> Once done it is only final state that needs to be captured.
16:28:40 <radez> frankbrockners: there's a patch out there that needs you to rebase on master for the foreman install docs
16:29:11 <frankbrockners> radez: likely easier to just abandon my patch rather than rebasing
16:29:16 <radez> I've got another meeting in 2 mins so I need to sign off here, see everyone tomorrow
16:29:20 <radez> frankbrockners: ack
16:29:21 <ChrisPriceAB> radez: I pulled an hour ago for my current activity.
16:29:38 <radez> cool sounds good ChrisPriceAB
16:29:39 <ChrisPriceAB> #info will begin review of test and pharos docs tomorrow
16:29:52 * ChrisPriceAB coming for you morgan_orange!!!!
16:30:25 <frankbrockners> ok - let's check were we are with out overall laundry list for Arno:
16:30:50 <frankbrockners> looks like the list on https://wiki.opnfv.org/meetings/bgs#may252015 is still mostly valid
16:31:14 <frankbrockners> with (1) being a placeholder for getting ODL+O/S on POD1 to work
16:32:05 <frankbrockners> any additional news/updates?
16:33:05 <HKirksey> June 4 still looking good?
16:33:50 <ChrisPriceAB> It's a shining star in our dark night HKirksey.  ;)
16:33:58 <frankbrockners> HKirksey: You've seen the updates
16:34:39 <HKirksey> Yes I have, frankbrockners
16:34:55 <HKirksey> Just thought I’d ask at the end...
16:35:07 <frankbrockners> I'm hoping that we can get towards more predictable and at least similar test results across both PODs
16:35:15 <HKirksey> OK
16:35:19 <frankbrockners> for this autodeploy and autotest would need to work
16:35:25 <frankbrockners> and I don't yet see this...
16:35:49 <frankbrockners> so let's keep fingers crossed that folks continue to make good progress
16:36:12 <ChrisPriceAB> My toes are cross at my fingers as well...
16:36:13 <jose_lausuch> I want to point out something
16:36:21 <jose_lausuch> and ask a question about priorities
16:36:49 <jose_lausuch> what level of priority does the Fuel deployment nonHA with ODL testing have?
16:36:55 <jose_lausuch> (for R1 of course)
16:37:17 <frankbrockners> jose_lausuch: priority relative to what?
16:37:20 <jose_lausuch> POD1 is currently block for this activity
16:37:31 <jose_lausuch> to get the failing test fixed
16:37:34 <jose_lausuch> at least as many as possible
16:38:21 <frankbrockners> IMHO this is very important: The desired scenario was O/S w/ HA plus ODL deployed to bare metal.
16:38:45 <morgan_or> I have to sign off
16:38:55 <frankbrockners> Given that HA with Fuel isn't feasible so far - we should at least show O/S plus ODL deployed to bare metal as "mature as possible"
16:39:15 <frankbrockners> thanks morgan_or
16:39:27 <frankbrockners> any other opinions?
16:39:40 <jose_lausuch> you mean , the nonHA deployment with ODL
16:40:14 <frankbrockners> yes - O/S (non HA) plus ODL
16:40:25 <jose_lausuch> ok
16:40:37 <frankbrockners> just showing O/S doesn't prove much
16:40:40 <jose_lausuch> just want to make sure we are focusing on the right things
16:40:45 <jose_lausuch> agree
16:40:54 <ChrisPriceAB> Agree, the priority is to have Fuel/ODL deployed.  If HA is a Jira ticket carried to SR1 so be it.
16:41:02 <jose_lausuch> for POD1 are 2 options
16:41:16 <jose_lausuch> 1) Full HA and functest without ODL tests
16:41:28 <jose_lausuch> 2) O/S (no HA) with ONLY ODL tests
16:41:48 <frankbrockners> hmm ... why not O/S and functest with ODL tests?
16:41:55 <jose_lausuch> so, we should continue working on 2) ok?
16:42:02 <frankbrockners> leaving out the HA tests of course
16:42:21 <jose_lausuch> I got some feedback (can send you an email later) that the O/S deployment is very limited in terms of Opetnsatck things
16:43:02 <frankbrockners> ok
16:43:04 <jose_lausuch> that for sure, but I got some emails from Daniel about that deployment is not yet ready to run functest stuff, at least not yet, but it will be soon
16:43:09 <jose_lausuch> but its ok
16:43:18 <jose_lausuch> I just wanted to set priorities for Fuel deployment
16:43:30 <frankbrockners> ok
16:43:31 <jose_lausuch> so prio is : Fuel O/S + functest (including ODL)
16:43:31 <jose_lausuch> ok
16:43:32 * ChrisPriceAB is turning blue holding his breath...
16:43:33 <jose_lausuch> thanks
16:43:46 <frankbrockners> yes
16:44:00 <frankbrockners> ChrisPriceAB: Please start breathing again
16:44:13 <ChrisPriceAB> June 4th frankbrockners  ;)
16:44:32 <frankbrockners> not bad if you can hold your breath that long... I can only do a few min
16:46:00 <frankbrockners> jose_lausuch: could you compile a list for tomorrows meeting that shows which functests work / don't work on the "Fuel O/S + ODL  functest'ing"?
16:46:11 <jose_lausuch> yes
16:46:16 <jose_lausuch> that is the goal
16:46:22 <frankbrockners> great - that would at least give us some status
16:46:22 <jose_lausuch> :)
16:46:43 <HKirksey> Oxygen deprivation is not allowed for anyone in the technical community, Chris
16:47:21 * frankbrockners mountaineers cheat with supplemental oxygen at times...
16:47:24 <frankbrockners> ok... - 2nd try to close the meeting for today
16:47:26 <ChrisPriceAB> Nah, just sit in a chair.  I'm expendable
16:47:32 <frankbrockners> anything else?
16:47:37 <ChrisPriceAB> not from me
16:47:39 <jose_lausuch> nop
16:47:51 <frankbrockners> thanks everyone!
16:47:52 <HKirksey> Thanks for hanging in there and continuing to slog through all this
16:48:04 <frankbrockners> #endmeeting