13:01:15 <bin_> #startmeeting Weekly Technical Discussion 13:01:15 <collabot`> Meeting started Thu Nov 3 13:01:15 2016 UTC. The chair is bin_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 13:01:15 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 13:01:15 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'weekly_technical_discussion' 13:03:56 <bin_> #info Bin Hu 13:04:00 <rprakash> #info rprakas 13:04:10 <rprakash> #info rprakash 13:04:39 <bin_> #info Aimee Ukasick 13:04:47 <bin_> #info Dan Druta 13:04:56 <bin_> #info Leon Wang 13:06:04 <rprakash> #topic Project Proposals Rescuer 13:07:30 <rprakash> #info Data protection service for OPNFV 13:08:07 <bin_> #info Dan Radez 13:08:13 <bin_> #info Dave Neary 13:08:18 <rprakash> #info focus on developing use cases, requirement documents, and test cases 13:09:34 <rprakash> #info Karbor in OpenStack as the main upstream project for Rescuer to start with 13:12:52 <bin_> #info Use cases etc. will be submitted as blueprints to upstreams 13:13:29 <rprakash> #info https://wiki.openstack.org/wiki/Karbor 13:13:56 <bin_> Prakash: can you also info your question? 13:16:30 <rprakash> #info based on requirements gathering for OPNFV modules like SDN controllers, Karbor in upstream will be extended to support the same 13:17:27 <rprakash> #info https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/availability/High+Availability+For+OPNFV 13:19:49 <bin_> #info Bryan suggested collaboration with HA project for data protection 13:20:19 <rprakash> #Bryan mentions looking at HA project as this Rescuer is Storage Projetction why not work with that as API and develop and deliver it 13:22:20 <bin_> #info It is suggested to socialize with HA PTL Qiao Fu 13:22:26 <rprakash> #info If we can particpate directly in HA by socialize with fuqiao will help 13:24:30 <rprakash> #info Bin and Bryan both want Leo to look at particpating along with HA project 13:25:58 <rprakash> #leo mentions that DR and Data recovery is not in HA , and Bryan mentions that there are other tools to segment clouds into diff region, cells, multi-site etc to do similar DR capabaility 13:27:10 <rprakash> #Leo thinks the goal of OPNFV Rescuer is to create the bridge between OPNFV and upstream as suggested like Karbor 13:29:23 <bin_> #info Dave indicated that data protection (or data high availability) seems to be part of HA in nature. But HA's focus may not be data HA 13:30:21 <bin_> #info The question is which approach will be the best for the success of data protection - part of HA, or standalone project 13:30:32 <bin_> #info There is no answer yet 13:30:43 <rprakash> #Dave sees benifits in both arguments of being in HA or separte Rescuer is diffciult to decide. So Data Protection (Rescuer) can be doen as part of HAor as sepearte depending on narrow focus and resource availability 13:32:48 <rprakash> #Bin suggests talk with Rescuer delivearbles with both HA and Multisite and see if they are ready to accept the Rescure scope in their plans or they would suggest a seperate project 13:34:44 <rprakash> Talk to fucqiao of china Mobile for HA and joehuang of Multisite if you can work together with them and get bakc next week or later when Rescuer / Leo is ready to present the conclusion 13:36:41 <rprakash> contact: fuqiao@chinamobile.com and joehuang@huawei.com 13:38:21 <rprakash> #Dave wants to know any efforts for certaiciation and Dovetail program, talking to Functest and Polestar. 13:38:59 <rprakash> Bin suggests capture those topics and plan for discussion next week Dovetail project as what thay are doing 13:41:26 <rprakash> #Bryan wants to add backlog of topics to be presented like Certiciation Program and Dovetail, Polestar, EUG (real world deployment, support for artifacts, Repo for artifacts in CI/CD ) etc. 13:42:26 <rprakash> #Bain mentioned Tapio's vision on OPNFV etc. 13:43:53 <bin_> #info Those topics are added as standing agenda 13:44:18 <bin_> #info we will start with certification program and dovetail next week Nov 10 13:44:26 <bin_> #info meeting adjourned 13:44:29 <bin_> #endmeeting