#opnfv-meeting: OPNFV TSC

Meeting summary

1. roll call (dmcbride, 12:57:56)
   1. Wenjing Chu (Wenjing, 12:59:38)
   2. Fatih Degirmenci (fdegir, 13:01:11)
   3. Tim Irnich (timirnich, 13:01:28)
   4. Brian Skerry (bjskerry, 13:01:29)
   5. Bin Hu (bh526r, 13:01:37)
   6. Rossella Sblendido (rossella_s, 13:02:28)
   7. Tim Rozet (trozet, 13:03:10)
   8. Tapio Tallgren (ttallgren, 13:03:41)
   9. Xavier Costa (XavierCosta, 13:04:07)
   
   
2. minutes (dmcbride, 13:05:00)
   1. no comments - minutes approved (dmcbride, 13:05:51)
   
   
3. agenda bashing (dmcbride, 13:06:42)
   1. exception for secondary repo for barometer deferred to next week (dmcbride, 13:07:02)
   2. added topic for test scope for different tiers of CI (Fatih) (dmcbride, 13:07:58)
   
   
4. test scope for different CI stages (dmcbride, 13:08:19)
   1. who decides what test cases are added for different tiers (dmcbride, 13:09:04)
   2. in addition, what process should be followed to add new test cases? (dmcbride, 13:09:28)
   3. until this week, HC contained 3 testcases (dmcbride, 13:10:00)
   4. the number of test cases has expanded without notification (dmcbride, 13:10:47)
   5. The Functest healthcheck tier contained 3 test cases and used for patchset verification (fdegir, 13:15:21)
   6. These testcases were connection_check, api_check, and snaps_healthcheck (fdegir, 13:15:37)
   7. The latest changes added additional test cases to healthcheck can be seen from the links below (fdegir, 13:16:10)
   8. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/58969/ (fdegir, 13:16:17)
   9. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/58957/ (fdegir, 13:16:24)
   10. Julien (julien-zte, 13:16:26)
   11. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/58659/ (fdegir, 13:16:29)
   12. https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/58655/ (fdegir, 13:16:33)
   13. First 2 changes we self +2d and submitted without giving opportunity to the project committers and OPNFV community-at-large (fdegir, 13:16:59)
   14. Apart from that, this has not been communicated to OPNFV community clearly and on time (fdegir, 13:17:18)
   15. The issue here is not about altering the list of testcases. The issue is how it is done - unilaterally (fdegir, 13:17:52)
   16. ACTION: ollivier to disable additional test cases in HC until we can agree on process for making changes to HC (dmcbride, 13:29:01)
   17. ACTION: ollivier to give presentation in weekly technical discussion about reasons for expanding HC (dmcbride, 13:34:33)
   
   
5. release update (dmcbride, 13:41:37)
   1. Gambia MS3.1 - June 29 (dmcbride, 13:42:03)
   2. Fraser 6.2 scheduled same day (timirnich, 13:42:34)
   3. no additional scenarios joining (timirnich, 13:42:48)
   4. installers look healthy, recommendation is to approve the release (timirnich, 13:43:04)
   5. VOTE: Voted on "Does the TSC approve the release of Fraser 6.2 on Friday, June 29?" Results are (dmcbride, 13:48:41)
   
   
6. OVP test scope (dmcbride, 13:49:20)
   1. ACTION: timirnich ask for agreement by email on https://lists.opnfv.org/g/opnfv-tech-discuss/message/21330?p by Thursday EOB (timirnich, 13:51:22)

Action items

1. ollivier to disable additional test cases in HC until we can agree on process for making changes to HC
2. ollivier to give presentation in weekly technical discussion about reasons for expanding HC
3. timirnich ask for agreement by email on https://lists.opnfv.org/g/opnfv-tech-discuss/message/21330?p by Thursday EOB

Action items, by person

1. timirnich
   1. timirnich ask for agreement by email on https://lists.opnfv.org/g/opnfv-tech-discuss/message/21330?p by Thursday EOB
2. UNASSIGNED
   1. ollivier to disable additional test cases in HC until we can agree on process for making changes to HC
   2. ollivier to give presentation in weekly technical discussion about reasons for expanding HC

People present (lines said)

1. dmcbride (26)
2. fdegir (17)
3. collabot_ (9)
4. timirnich (6)
5. Wenjing (3)
6. bh526r (2)
7. trozet (2)
8. julien-zte (2)
9. bjskerry (2)
10. ttallgren (2)
11. rossella_s (2)
12. XavierCosta (2)