#opnfv-meeting: Weekly Technical Discussion 151

Meeting started by bh526r at 13:00:03 UTC (full logs).

Meeting summary

  1. Roll Call (bh526r, 13:00:13)
    1. Bin Hu (bh526r, 13:00:19)
    2. Pierre Lynch (bh526r, 13:00:34)
    3. Mike Fix (bh526r, 13:01:27)
    4. Al Morton (bh526r, 13:01:45)
    5. Sridhar Rao (bh526r, 13:01:52)
    6. Mark Shostak (bh526r, 13:02:15)
    7. Sunku Ranganath (bh526r, 13:03:42)
    8. Murtuza Khan (bh526r, 13:03:58)
    9. 17326140906 (bh526r, 13:06:04)

  2. New Project Proposal CNTT-RI (Reference Implementation) (bh526r, 13:06:51)
    1. https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/PROJ/Project+Proposals%3A+CNTT-RI (bh526r, 13:07:08)
    2. Mike Fix, PTL of New Project Proposal gave a brief introduction of this proposal (bh526r, 13:07:50)
    3. All information in his slides are from the wiki (in above link) (bh526r, 13:08:23)
    4. Trevor Cooper (bh526r, 13:13:14)
    5. Cedric Ollivier (bh526r, 13:13:27)
    6. And wiki has more details of information (bh526r, 13:22:29)
    7. Al Morton indicated that testing projects are looking at RM and RA in order to determine the requirements of testing (bh526r, 13:23:25)
    8. Mike Fix responded that CNTT has looked into OPNFV projects as well, including Dovetail, FuncTest, Yardstick etc, and will leverage those we have today as much as possible. (bh526r, 13:24:58)
    9. Those existing projects are very impressive. (bh526r, 13:25:24)
    10. CNTT is finalizing Chapter 8, and all review and comments are very welcome (bh526r, 13:26:17)
    11. We want to leverage all great work there. (bh526r, 13:27:05)
    12. Mike Fix also reiterated that it is CNTT's formal long-term engagement with OPNFV (bh526r, 13:27:59)
    13. Trevor Cooper asked how to align with OPNFV's release cadence (bh526r, 13:31:09)
    14. Mike Fix indicated that the desire is to align with OPNFV's release cadence (bh526r, 13:31:33)
    15. Sridhar Rao asked if we can share the communication with OPNFV (bh526r, 13:36:18)
    16. CNTT is using its own mailing list for work in progress. Mike will add opnfv-tech-discuss in the communication as well. (bh526r, 13:38:25)
    17. Cedric indicated that current QA criteria is low, and lots of APIs testing and benchmark testing are not executed in passing the gate of OPNFV and CVC. (bh526r, 13:56:07)
    18. Cedric suggested that we should raise the bar of QA / testing by making those tests mandatory in CNTT RM specs (bh526r, 13:57:07)
    19. Cedric will join the CNTT meeting on Wednesdays to discuss those test requirement in Chapter 8 of CNTT RM specs (bh526r, 14:01:04)
    20. No further questions or comments (bh526r, 14:01:16)
    21. However, community requested one more week to review and comment. (bh526r, 14:01:54)
    22. Mike Fix indicated that Project Proposal formally submitted and socialized on 8/23/2019 (bh526r, 14:24:36)
    23. Mike said that The CNTT Governance reviewed the proposal on 8/29, and aligned after no material feedback received when the collection period expired 9/8. (bh526r, 14:25:27)
    24. Mike further indicated that due to 9/2 US Holiday, the formal OPNFV Community presentation and review was held 9/9, two weeks after formal submission on 8/23. (bh526r, 14:28:28)
    25. So OPNFV Community feedback is desired through EOD 9/15 (Sunday), for final acknowledgement/support on 9/16 from the OPNFV Community. Goal is to receive and incorporate OPNFV Community feedback, resolve comments and achieve community consensus by 9/16 so that OPNFV TSC can take care of it on 9/17, or prior to the Antwerp face-to-face on 9/26. (bh526r, 14:31:01)
    26. Bin indicated that although there was no more question or comment, since community requested one more week for review and comment, and Mike agreed to get more feedback from OPNFV community through EOD 9/15 Sunday in order to incorporate OPNFV community feedback, resolve comments if any in order to achieve community consensus before it can be brought to TSC, Bin suggested that we continue to discuss it on (bh526r, 14:34:55)
    27. All agreed that we continue to discuss it on 9/16 and make conclusion at that time - whatever the conclusion will be. (bh526r, 14:36:10)

  3. AOB (bh526r, 14:36:17)
    1. Meeting adjourned (bh526r, 14:36:27)


Meeting ended at 14:36:31 UTC (full logs).

Action items

  1. (none)


People present (lines said)

  1. bh526r (43)
  2. collabot` (3)


Generated by MeetBot 0.1.4.