16:00:07 <trevor_intel1> #startmeeting OPNFV Pharos
16:00:07 <collabot> Meeting started Wed Feb  3 16:00:07 2016 UTC.  The chair is trevor_intel1. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
16:00:07 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
16:00:07 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'opnfv_pharos'
16:00:17 <trevor_intel1> #info Trevor Cooper
16:00:20 <jmorgan1> #info Jack Morgan
16:00:24 <fdegir> #info Fatih Degirmenci
16:00:32 * fdegir is commuting and will be slow typing
16:01:10 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: driving?!!?
16:01:16 <jmorgan1> fdegir: what is the differene between now and any other day ;)
16:01:18 <fdegir> trevor_intel1: metro
16:01:40 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: ok I feel a bit better
16:01:45 <fdegir> jmorgan1: there is no difference
16:01:51 <jmorgan1> fdegir: LOL
16:02:03 <trevor_intel1> Topics?
16:02:18 <trevor_intel1> 1. POD status
16:02:34 <trevor_intel1> 2. Docs
16:02:44 <trevor_intel1> 3. Other release stuff?
16:02:59 <trevor_intel1> Lets go over POD status ...
16:03:40 <trevor_intel1> #info yesterday Debra reported out that there were issues with Intel PODs 2 and 8
16:04:25 <trevor_intel1> We think there are no known issues
16:04:29 <trevor_intel1> Jack?
16:04:46 <trevor_intel1> Do you agree?
16:05:05 <trevor_intel1> I mean POD 2 and 8 specifically
16:05:21 <jmorgan1> I think the issues with Intel POD 2 and 8 are resolved as I've not heard back from the POD users
16:05:49 <jmorgan1> Intel POD 2 (Apex) was solved by moving to intel POD 7
16:05:57 <narindergupta> trevor_intel1: pod5 and pod6 bmc are not responding for few nodes
16:06:05 <fdegir> about pod8; they will be off next week
16:06:12 <jmorgan1> issue was Apex installer had problem with identifying network interfaces on different platforms
16:06:36 <fdegir> so if you don't get any info during next 2 days
16:06:37 <trevor_intel1> #info There are currently no known issues with PODs 2 and 8
16:06:53 <jmorgan1> Intel POD 8 issue was the information in the Wiki was wrong, 1Gb MAC mixed with 10Gbe MACs
16:06:56 <trevor_intel1> #info POD 2 was moved to POD 7 (Apex)
16:07:23 <fdegir> jmorgan1: so pod8 should be fine for compass then
16:07:47 <jmorgan1> fdegir: I'm assume so as I've not heard anything
16:08:01 <fdegir> ok
16:08:05 <jmorgan1> those systems in pod 8 have two type on 10Gbe nic (no 1gbe nic)
16:08:09 <trevor_intel1> #info All issues need to be reported and tracked through Jira ... process is here ... https://wiki.opnfv.org/pharos_rls_b_support
16:08:39 <jmorgan1> i mixed up the two differnet 10Gbe mac, mix was just to switch them in the wiki
16:08:48 <jmorgan1> s/mix/fix
16:09:18 <jmorgan1> as narindergupta mentioned, he is having trouble with the bmc as of last Friday in intel pod5/6
16:09:31 <jmorgan1> im looking into it (PHAROS-101) in JIRA
16:11:33 <jmorgan1> make sense
16:12:05 <trevor_intel1> Jack: what is time-line to resolve? Were you able to determine anything re. where the issue is yet?
16:12:39 <jmorgan1> I should be able to resolve them today
16:12:55 <trevor_intel1> narindergupta: I don't think anything changed on our side
16:13:17 <trevor_intel1> Jack: would it be worth doing a reboot?
16:13:18 <narindergupta> trevor_intel1: could be hardware failure
16:14:09 <narindergupta> trevor_intel1: may be hard power reset might solve. Looks like its keep the session active and ipmitool can not connect to it
16:15:29 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: already did a reboot
16:15:32 <narindergupta> trevor_intel1: reboot won't work as it bmc.
16:15:49 <trevor_intel1> ok
16:15:59 <narindergupta> trevor_intel1: it may be hard power reset where pull out power and pull back in
16:16:01 <trevor_intel1> Jack: I have reassigned the issue to you in Jira
16:16:14 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: i need to connect via the vpn profiles for intel pod 5/6, then i can troubleshoot
16:17:44 <trevor_intel1> Jack: what of status of Jira 97 (POD 9 jump host)?
16:18:58 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: you mean PHAROS-97? it needs to be done
16:19:56 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: this issue is really pod user learning to use the pod
16:20:02 <trevor_intel1> Jack: and 97
16:20:21 <trevor_intel1> undo
16:20:25 <trevor_intel1> #undo
16:20:25 <collabot> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0x1ba4dd0>
16:20:39 <trevor_intel1> Jack: 95?
16:20:51 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: the best thing to do is look at the comments in a JIRA task, that will give you the status
16:21:15 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: it needs to be done
16:21:41 <trevor_intel1> Jack: There are no comments yet on this issue
16:21:56 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: right, so there is no status
16:22:10 <trevor_intel1> Jack: that is why I am asking :)
16:23:16 <trevor_intel1> Jack: The version says for rls B ... and we are in the release cycle ... so are they blocking issues and if so what is estimate to resolve?
16:23:24 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: all the open JIRA tasks need to be done, I have 12 of them
16:24:12 <trevor_intel1> Jack: other than POD 5 and 6 ... are there blocking issues?
16:24:36 <jmorgan1> trevor_intel1: how do I know if its a blocking issue or not?
16:25:11 <trevor_intel1> Jack: Needs to be clarified with the reporter
16:27:40 <trevor_intel1> Are there any other POD issues to discuss now?
16:29:24 <trevor_intel1> #Topic Pharos documents
16:30:02 <trevor_intel1> #info Pharos docs have been organized and created for new doc toolchain
16:30:16 <trevor_intel1> #info All docs build without error form what I can tell
16:30:32 <trevor_intel1> #info Fixed Dell document issues
16:31:22 <trevor_intel1> #info However there is a lot of improvements we can make to the documents
16:31:55 <trevor_intel1> #Info Any volunteers who want to help improved the docs?
16:33:21 <trevor_intel1> We need more lab reps in these meetings :(
16:36:01 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: still there? Anything you need / would like to discuss now?
16:36:08 <fdegir> trevor_intel1:  is there any way to enforce it?
16:36:11 <trevor_intel1> Jack: Anything more?
16:36:28 <trevor_intel1> narindergupta: Anything other than POD 5/6 issues?
16:36:42 <narindergupta> trevor_intel1: ok
16:36:47 <narindergupta> trevor_intel1: no
16:37:26 <fdegir> not from me except how to make sure we have more people workng with pharos
16:38:14 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: this is the old problem
16:38:21 <fdegir> yes
16:38:49 <fdegir> maybemore drastic chamge needed
16:39:00 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: ideas?
16:39:02 <fdegir> tsc/board enforcement
16:39:24 <fdegir> 1 rep from each lab
16:39:24 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: how do you see it working?
16:39:28 <trevor_intel1> ok
16:39:47 <fdegir> we have this laas/maas/ reservation
16:39:53 <fdegir> pharos spec etc
16:40:07 <fdegir> which obviously require involvement
16:40:28 <fdegir> if certainlab doesn't provide representation
16:40:32 <fdegir> they're out
16:40:52 <fdegir> from ci or any future pharos stuff
16:41:13 <fdegir> you can't just put a pod and forget the rest
16:41:45 <fdegir> if resources come
16:41:53 <fdegir> they come with a person
16:42:11 <trevor_intel1> agree but up to now at least the TSC and marketing wanted to build a certain perception (regardless of the reality)
16:42:39 <fdegir> that's the ammunition and problem at the same time
16:43:04 <trevor_intel1> Which was maybe the right thing to get going ... but now it has to change if we are to be sustainable
16:43:21 <fdegir> 100% agree
16:43:35 <trevor_intel1> So lets make a proposal to the TSC?
16:43:45 <jmorgan1> fdegir: this should include maintaining pod status on the release resource page, specifically if a blocking issue comes up
16:43:50 <fdegir> we passed the point to do marketing and forget the reality
16:44:10 <fdegir> for c-release, this should be top item
16:44:26 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: so some strictly enforced rules?
16:44:30 <fdegir> match the names to labs and expect commitment
16:44:52 <fdegir> I don't see other way unfortubately
16:45:16 <fdegir> positive thinking didn't work
16:45:22 <trevor_intel1> :)
16:46:12 <fdegir> that's all I have
16:46:20 <trevor_intel1> I think we need to come at it by being clear on a set of requirements (very specific) ... and then show the gap
16:46:31 <fdegir> yes
16:46:36 <fdegir> all this wiki mess
16:46:46 <fdegir> booking time for activities
16:46:50 <fdegir> mails
16:46:52 <fdegir> etc
16:46:55 <fdegir> must end
16:47:16 <fdegir> like what you started doing with intel lab issue handling
16:47:40 <fdegir> it is similar with other pharos activities
16:48:53 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: Can you send me some bullet points of what requirements are from releng perspective (not solutions just the requirements)?
16:49:06 <fdegir> will do
16:49:13 <trevor_intel1> fdegir: great, thanks
16:50:10 <trevor_intel1> I am done for today, need to get back to docs and other urgent stuff
16:50:17 <fdegir> ok
16:50:20 <fdegir> thx
16:50:20 <trevor_intel1> bye
16:50:35 <trevor_intel1> happy commuting
16:50:44 <trevor_intel1> #endmeeting