13:00:31 <mbuil> #startmeeting XCI-biweekly 13:00:31 <collabot`> Meeting started Wed Sep 11 13:00:31 2019 UTC. The chair is mbuil. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 13:00:31 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 13:00:31 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'xci_biweekly' 13:00:41 <mbuil> #topic rollcall 13:00:47 <mbuil> #info Manuel Buil 13:01:22 <nick_kar> #info Nikos Karandreas 13:02:37 <mbuil> hey nick_kar, how is it going? 13:03:02 <nick_kar> hey Manuel, i'm fine 13:03:13 <nick_kar> what about you? 13:03:36 <mbuil> Fine, I came yesterday from vacation 13:03:54 <nick_kar> have you had a good time? 13:03:58 <mbuil> let's wait one minute for more people to join 13:04:12 <mbuil> nick_kar: yes! It was a lot of work but fine ;) 13:04:39 <nick_kar> you worked in vacation??! 13:06:01 <mbuil> nick_kar: yes, I am part of an organization that organizes the big festivals in my town. We organize dinners, parties, concerts, hikes... 13:06:43 <nick_kar> I see, sounds interesting 13:07:00 <mbuil> yes, very rewarding :) but very intense 13:07:09 <mbuil> let's start but it seems it is only you and me :P 13:07:09 <nmimi> #info Nikos Mimigiannis 13:07:18 <mbuil> now we are three :D 13:07:24 <sarpkoksal> #info Sarp Köksal 13:07:45 <mbuil> hello nmimi and sarpkoksal 13:07:46 <nick_kar> four! :P 13:08:02 <sarpkoksal> hi Manuel 13:08:07 <nmimi> hi Manuel! 13:08:13 <dbalsige> hello everybody :) this is the channel for the XCI meeting, right ? 13:08:17 <mbuil> this is the agenda we have, add topics if you want --> https://etherpad.opnfv.org/p/xci-meetings 13:08:24 <mbuil> dbalsige: yes, it is 13:08:38 <dbalsige> hello Manuel 13:08:49 <mbuil> dbalsige: hello Daniel 13:08:50 <mbuil> #topic Meeting day/time/occurrence 13:08:59 <mbuil> #link https://doodle.com/poll/6eswe8pbgdifmp7i 13:09:43 <mbuil> #info we have a draw between this time and one hour earlier 13:10:04 <mbuil> sarpkoksal: you voted for one hour earlier, is 13h UTC ok for you too? 13:10:30 <mbuil> nmimi: same for you 13:11:00 <nmimi> yes it is fine for me 13:11:12 <sarpkoksal> I prefer 1 hour earlier but if it will be at 13h, it is okey for me 13:12:17 <mbuil> if nobody is against it, then let's leave it as it is. We can change it if somebody has problems in the future of course. ANybody against it? 13:13:06 <mbuil> #info: We keep the current slot 13h Wednesday bi-weekly 13:13:12 <mbuil> #topic OSH Integration 13:13:32 <mbuil> OSH = OpenStack Helm ;) 13:13:38 <mbuil> #info The integration is completed. We can deploy OpenStack-helm with XCI using mini and noha flavor. Both Ubuntu and opensuse are supported 13:14:01 <mbuil> #info There are a couple of problems that must be solved to fix the integration with functest 13:14:20 <mbuil> nmimi, nick_kar: did you have time to look at why there are problems with cinder? I did not 13:14:32 <nick_kar> i think that noha flavor fails 13:14:50 <nick_kar> before going to test-it script 13:15:05 <nick_kar> it started a couple of weeks ago 13:15:20 <mbuil> nick_kar: it was working for me two weeks ago but perhaps something broke in the meanwhile 13:15:30 <mbuil> three weeks ago, sorry 13:15:32 <mbuil> ok 13:15:36 <nick_kar> yes 13:15:57 <nick_kar> i hadn't chance to look at it 13:16:12 <nmimi> i haven't looked at it either 13:16:18 * fdegir in a parallel meeting and will try to join 13:16:27 <mbuil> #info: nick_kar noticed that noha is not working since a couple of weeks 13:16:28 <nick_kar> probably not before next week for me 13:16:57 <mbuil> I would also like to have a look but I am busy with other stuff too 13:17:16 <fdegir> i've been looking into cinder issue but my mini deployments failing 13:17:16 <mbuil> any other point to mention on this topic? 13:17:28 <nmimi> I think we should get cinder to be deployed with NFS 13:17:50 <nmimi> instead of the default one(CEPH) 13:17:58 <fdegir> i think one of the reasons why it fails to deploy cinder is deprecated get-all option to kubectl so we need an older (1.14) version of k8s for osh 13:17:59 <mbuil> fdegir: what step do you see failing? 13:18:18 <fdegir> show-all option, sorry 13:18:29 <fdegir> register ceph script is failing i think 13:18:51 <fdegir> i see ceph pods are up and when the scripts tries to do namespace registration, it fails due to that deprecated kubectl option 13:19:14 <mbuil> nmimi +1 to that. We should probably first make it work with NFS and then move to CEPH. I consider NFS easier to debug and less problematic 13:19:24 <fdegir> so i pin k8s to 1.14 versioin for osh osn-nosdn-nofeature scenario: https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/releng-xci-scenarios/+/68435/3/scenarios/os-nosdn-nofeature/osh/xci_overrides 13:19:47 <fdegir> with nfs approach, we won't be able to introuduce functest 13:20:25 <fdegir> cinder is included in functest-healthcheck and if we enable functest-healthcheck, we won't be able to pass the verify gate 13:21:01 <fdegir> on top of cinder issue, one more testcase fails: tempest.api.identity.v3.test_domains.DefaultDomainTestJSON.test_default_domain_exists 13:21:10 <fdegir> which might be related to policy or whatever 13:21:22 <fdegir> so i think we are pretty close to enable functest if we can get cinder working 13:22:06 <fdegir> that's all from me for this topic 13:22:10 <fdegir> i'll keep trying 13:22:33 <mbuil> fdegir: but cinder could use NFS in the backend too. I saw that in the mini flavor we are not deploying cinder. We are mimicking what OSH is doing upstream in the gate where it tests everything. I wonder why they don't deploy cinder helm, I can ask 13:22:49 <fdegir> mbuil: that would help 13:23:02 <fdegir> i'm happy whatever way we can get cinder enabled 13:23:22 <mbuil> ok, let me ask, and come back with an answer 13:23:36 <dbalsige> is there any other reason going for cinder (NFS) than for cinder (CEPH) than complexity ? 13:23:56 <fdegir> i believe ceph is not tested in osh gates 13:24:03 <fdegir> i might be mistaken 13:24:17 <nick_kar> I agree with fdegir 13:24:40 <mbuil> brb 13:26:08 <fdegir> mbuil was saying xci osh works fine on baremetal as well so again, we are pretty close to get things in shape 13:26:20 <fdegir> need small touches 13:26:52 <fdegir> the next topic is How to track bugs and missing features 13:26:53 <fdegir> #topic How to track bugs and missing features 13:26:57 * fdegir is not chair 13:27:03 <mbuil> back 13:27:14 <mbuil> #chair fdegir 13:27:14 <collabot`> Current chairs: fdegir mbuil 13:27:23 <fdegir> #topic How to track bugs and missing features 13:27:42 <dbalsige> I would recommend using opnfv jira for bug tracking / features... 13:27:45 <fdegir> we have xci project on jira and there are some items there already 13:27:54 <mbuil> #info We have a releng-xci section in opnfv.jira 13:28:02 <mbuil> #link https://jira.opnfv.org/secure/RapidBoard.jspa?projectKey=XCI&rapidView=237&view=planning 13:28:50 <fdegir> i've been adding some items to the backlog while i was trying to make functest work 13:28:56 <mbuil> #info Our backlog has plenty of tasks. Everyone is welcome to pick one! 13:28:59 <fdegir> so you are welcomed to take over any tasks 13:29:15 <mbuil> is the link working for you? It is very slow for me? 13:29:39 <dbalsige> works good here 13:29:56 <mbuil> dbalsige: ok thanks 13:30:25 <mbuil> #topic XCI demo in the OPNFV booth at ONS Europe 13:30:41 <mbuil> #info XCI baremetal deployment demo was selected to be part of the OPNFV booth at ONS Europe 13:31:05 <mbuil> #info Currently mbuil is the only presenter. If somebody attends ONS Europe and would like to be part of the demo, that would be great 13:31:18 <dbalsige> great congrats manuel 13:31:21 <mbuil> anyone? ;) 13:31:28 <dbalsige> I will be at ONS 13:31:37 <dbalsige> I could join if it helps 13:31:56 <fdegir> i arrive wednesday evening, missing ons 13:32:16 <mbuil> dbalsige: I think it is already too late to make it official but for sure it would be nice if you can cover me a couple of hours so that the booth is not empty 13:32:57 <fdegir> anyone plans to attend to CNTT meeting? 13:33:05 <mbuil> fdegir: me 13:33:12 <dbalsige> clear ! that was the proposal. of course I can help you out for some hours.. 13:33:43 <fdegir> dbalsige: are you staying for CNTT? 13:35:07 <dbalsige> fdegir: When will it take place ? 13:35:18 <fdegir> dbalsige: thursday and friday 13:35:38 <fdegir> details: https://wiki.lfnetworking.org/display/LN/CNTT+Developer+F2F+Workshop%2C+Sept+%2719 13:35:56 <fdegir> you need to register and registration is free 13:37:05 <fdegir> mbuil: next topic? 13:37:14 <dbalsige> fdegir: thx I will try to make it. I will have to adjust my travel plans 13:37:20 <mbuil> #topic Dovetail Support 13:37:33 <fdegir> dbalsige: i think there will be discussiions around xci during that 13:37:36 <mbuil> not sure who brought this one into the agenda. It was there last time 13:38:02 <fdegir> mbuil: not sure 13:38:06 <mbuil> I guess panos but he is not in the meeting 13:38:48 <mbuil> let's move on 13:38:49 <mbuil> #topic Documentation 13:39:05 <mbuil> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/c/releng-xci/+/68390 13:39:17 <mbuil> #info please review it if you have time 13:39:22 <mbuil> I updated part of our documentation 13:39:44 <mbuil> oh, I have just realized fdegir reviewed it 13:39:52 <mbuil> please -1 it ;) 13:39:54 <fdegir> you see 13:40:07 <fdegir> got your -1 13:40:27 * mbuil adding it to my backlog 13:41:14 <mbuil> #topic Supporting multiple vlans per physical int 13:41:41 <mbuil> I think this comes from Parker. I'll tell him to add this to the Jira so that it becomes a task there and can be tracked 13:42:18 <mbuil> #topic Tungsten Fabric integration into XCI 13:42:26 <mbuil> Is anybody from TF in the meeting? 13:43:12 <fdegir> mbuil: we can perhaps add a task to the backlog for TF integration and assign it to the guys 13:43:28 <fdegir> to Alex perhaps 13:43:51 <mbuil> I know they are working upstream in OSH with that. For example --> https://review.opendev.org/#/c/663390/ 13:44:16 <mbuil> fdegir: ok. Let me contact Alex and ask him 13:44:29 <mbuil> #topic aob 13:44:36 <mbuil> anyone? 13:45:09 <fdegir> not from me 13:45:30 <mbuil> ok, then let's close it here 13:45:38 <mbuil> #endmeeting