14:30:33 <debrascott> #startmeeting Brahmaputra Daily Standup
14:30:33 <collabot> Meeting started Fri Jan 22 14:30:33 2016 UTC.  The chair is debrascott. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:30:33 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
14:30:33 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'brahmaputra_daily_standup'
14:30:44 <debrascott> #link agenda https://wiki.opnfv.org/releases/brahmaputra/minutes
14:30:50 <debrascott> #topic roll call
14:31:00 <bin_> #info Bin Hu
14:31:10 <morgan_orange> #info Morgan Richomme
14:31:34 <joekidder> #info Joe Kidder
14:31:48 <ashyoung> #info Ashlee Young
14:32:12 <frankbrockners> #info Frank Brockners
14:32:13 <fdegir> #info Fatih Degirmenci
14:32:33 <trozet> #info Tim Rozet
14:32:37 <anac1> #info Ana Cunha
14:33:04 <debrascott> #topic Install/Deploy tools status (Quick status from all 4 installers)
14:33:26 <debrascott> JonasB:  * Update on Fuel testing/stabilization> ready to freeze?
14:34:09 <debrascott> is jonas here yet?
14:34:37 <trozet> debrascott: i can go if we want to move Fuel to go last and wait for Jonas?
14:34:42 <trozet> [1]JonasB: ping?
14:34:46 <debrascott> trozet: go ahead
14:35:06 <trozet> #info Apex got SFC and Aodh (Doctor) support merged last night
14:35:25 <trozet> #info The last thing we don't have is contrail support
14:35:33 <trozet> #info but we are ready to freeze, we are not sure if thats going to make it
14:35:42 <debrascott> trozet: claps and applause!
14:35:56 <trozet> debrascott: thanks :)
14:36:15 <debrascott> I don’t see Stuart on yet to answer status on Contrail.
14:36:36 <debrascott> trozet: did you receive the patch from him?
14:36:40 <trevor_intel> #info Trevor Cooper
14:37:04 <trozet> debrascott: no I don't think so.  The problem is we are trying to build the artifacts ourselves, because it looks like there is no RPM pre built for us with liberty support.
14:37:12 <trozet> debrascott: from what we found it only supports Juno
14:37:20 <trozet> debrascott: so radez is trying to hack at it to get it to work
14:37:29 <narindergupta_aw> #info Narinder Gupta
14:37:58 <trozet> debrascott: I don't have high hopes at this point, but we are still trying until code freeze, but dont hold up code freeze because of that
14:38:08 <debrascott> trozet: check with Stuart again. Yesterday sounded like he had a working patch to hand you.
14:38:23 <narindergupta_aw> #info for JOID we are ready for code freeze as last pending issue related to Orange pod has been fixed
14:38:35 <trozet> debrascott: will do
14:38:49 <debrascott> narindergupta_aw: awesome, claps and applause to you as well
14:39:18 <debrascott> #info last from Compass was they are also ready to freeze
14:39:44 <debrascott> OK, until JonasB: arrives lets move on to test
14:39:49 <debrascott> #topic Test
14:39:58 <StuartMacki> #info Stuart Mackie
14:40:07 <morgan_orange> #info Functest tests more stable, several successfull run done since 24h
14:40:16 <morgan_orange> #info all tables updated
14:40:29 <morgan_orange> #info onos first successfull run on apex and compass 11/11
14:40:48 <debrascott> morgan_orange: sighs of relief here. Good to hear stability is coming along
14:40:51 <ashyoung> woo hoo
14:41:23 <morgan_orange> #info some concerns on the config of some PoDs, we were able to run the same tempest suite on 3 different PoDs with the same scenario
14:41:46 <debrascott> morgan_orange: and same results?
14:42:01 <morgan_orange> we got very different results..on Orange Pod 91% OK, On Intel POD5 35%
14:42:38 <debrascott> well OK, being able to run is a good start…stability still an issue across pods
14:42:43 <morgan_orange> Intel POD5 14ù, Intel POD6 34%
14:42:58 <morgan_orange> yep but here it is a question of network config of the POD
14:43:25 <morgan_orange> other concern it seems that ODL suite may be provide different results according to ODL version...
14:43:32 <morgan_orange> all the installers do not use the same version
14:43:47 <morgan_orange> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/tempest_brahmaputra_page
14:43:59 <morgan_orange> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/onos_brahmaputra_page
14:44:01 <debrascott> morgan_orange: that can be documented though, right?
14:44:20 <debrascott> I mean if it is known & expected
14:44:26 <morgan_orange> yes
14:44:29 <frankbrockners> morgan_orange - what versions of ODL do the different installers use?
14:44:30 <morgan_orange> not a big deal
14:44:46 <frankbrockners> isn't everyone using Lithium SR3?
14:44:47 <morgan_orange> frankbrockners: good question...
14:45:14 <debrascott> maybe installers can jump in and answer?
14:46:14 <debrascott> trozet: ODL version used by Apex?
14:46:33 <debrascott> narindergupta: ODL version used by JOID?
14:47:10 <trozet> #info Apex uses Lithium SR3 for all scenarios, except Be for SFC
14:47:23 <morgan_orange> #info test DB ready for migration, mail sent for transfer to LF on Monday
14:47:41 <debrascott> morgan_orange: excellent
14:48:08 <debrascott> are we ready to move on to Yardstick?
14:48:20 <anac1> #info yardstick - ONOS first succesfull run on Compass
14:48:45 <anac1> #info continue troubleshooting ODL scenarios
14:48:59 <debrascott> anac1: claps and applause for you too considering yesterday you couldnt run anything!!
14:49:28 <debrascott> anac1: what issues do you have with ODL scenarios?
14:49:59 <anac1> debrascott: we are debugging resource creation in ODL
14:50:32 <ashyoung> woo hoo!
14:50:55 <fdegir> ashyoung: onos rocks :)
14:51:12 <ashyoung> :)
14:51:13 <debrascott> anac1: OK good. Keep us informed. Please reach out at any time for help from any team
14:51:26 <debrascott> ashyoung:+1
14:51:29 <anac1> debrascott: sure
14:52:07 <debrascott> JonasB: did you join us?
14:52:29 <debrascott> #topic project status
14:53:00 <debrascott> StuartMacki: what’s up with contrail, Apex says they don’t have the patch working yet?
14:54:13 <StuartMacki> Correct - they moved to a different set of puppet modules and got further, but need to use a new neutron plugin
14:54:26 <StuartMacki> I didn't hear back if they made more progress.
14:54:49 <StuartMacki> Our internal CI was down yesterday which held up our own efforts
14:55:04 <debrascott> StuartMacki: trozet says no and they need to freeze
14:55:30 <trozet> StuartMacki: is the new neutron plugin the one radez is using?
14:55:41 <debrascott> StuartMacki: any other installers successful with deploy?
14:55:58 <trozet> StuartMacki: https://github.com/Juniper/contrail-neutron-plugin on master branch?
14:56:09 <StuartMacki> Not with Liberty
14:56:30 <trozet> StuartMacki: radez is still hacking at that trying to get it into our build, it has some dependency python packages hes trying to resolve
14:56:37 <trozet> StuartMacki: so hes not stuck per say
14:56:57 <trozet> StuartMacki: but if you could confirm my question that would really help us
14:57:24 <StuartMacki> trozet: are you asking which one he is using or which one he should use
14:57:57 <trozet> StuartMacki: i'm asking which one we should be using
14:58:22 <StuartMacki> Latest on master is best place to be
14:58:24 <trozet> StuartMacki: master branch on https://github.com/Juniper/contrail-neutron-plugin compatible with liberty?
14:58:29 <trozet> StuartMacki: ok thanks
14:58:38 <trozet> debrascott: when is the code freeze going to happen?
14:59:25 <debrascott> trozet we need you to close down soon but Fuel is still outstanding so I think we can wait for that. Will have to follow up with JonasB off line since he didn’t join us today.
14:59:49 <debrascott> trozet: yesterday he expected that by today he’d be able to estimate time to freeze
15:00:11 <trozet> debrascott: yeah well the freeze should be across the entire project, so we will just work until you set the freeze time
15:00:11 <debrascott> If you can freeze then test teams can have easier time troubleshooting & testing w/Apex scenarios
15:00:38 <debrascott> When you make changes their troubleshooting scenarios change
15:01:34 <trozet> debrascott: we arent making any major feature additions to current scenarios
15:01:39 <debrascott> I would say try to get Contrail support in, with plan to freeze tonight. We’ll do day per day until Fuel can freeze
15:01:50 <trozet> debrascott: just trying to add contrail as a separate scenario, shouldnt have any impact on the others
15:02:07 <debrascott> trozet: yes but rebuilding changes test setup enough that issues change day to day
15:02:26 <trozet> debrascott: thats not fair, the code freeze should be the same for all installers?
15:02:48 <trozet> debrascott: why give fuel special permission?
15:03:03 <debrascott> trozet: agree- Fuel has too many components that only it installs
15:03:08 * fdegir prefers to stay silent
15:03:24 <trozet> frankbrockners: speak up
15:03:34 * fdegir leaves...
15:03:49 <debrascott> trozet: not trying to be unfair, just trying to get each ready and I don’t know yet when Fuel will be
15:04:13 <debrascott> trozet: asking that you plan day to day for freeze
15:04:17 * frankbrockners believes this is a larger TSC level debate
15:04:37 <debrascott> frankbrockners: agree
15:04:56 <trozet> debrascott: we are ready to freeze, and only working on bug fixes for the sceanrios we have support for, but until the common code freeze happens we will work for contrail
15:05:14 <debrascott> trozet: agree
15:05:23 <trozet> debrascott: ok
15:05:27 <trozet> debrascott: thanks
15:05:33 <debrascott> trozet: waiting to here from Fuel if they can freeze today
15:06:11 <trozet> debrascott: ok just drop me an email when the code freeze will be when you find out
15:06:33 <debrascott> trozet: will send out to tech-discuss and all installers
15:06:45 <debrascott> ok, past the hour
15:06:58 <debrascott> thanks everyone for attending
15:07:05 <debrascott> Good progress made
15:07:06 <ashyoung> Thanks!
15:07:12 <debrascott> #endmeeting