14:30:25 <debrascott> #startmeeting Brahmaputra Daily Standup
14:30:25 <collabot> Meeting started Thu Feb  4 14:30:25 2016 UTC.  The chair is debrascott. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:30:25 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
14:30:25 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'brahmaputra_daily_standup'
14:30:35 <debrascott> #link agenda https://wiki.opnfv.org/doku.php?id=releases/brahmaputra/minutes
14:30:51 <debrascott> #topic roll call
14:31:03 <ashyoung> #info Ashlee Young
14:31:11 <jonasbjurel> #info Jonas Bjurel
14:31:14 <debrascott> HKirksey: good morning!
14:31:27 <ebrjohn__> #info ebrjohn Brady Johnson
14:31:32 <anac1> #info Ana Cunha
14:31:36 <morgan_orange> #info Morgan Richomme
14:32:11 <debrascott> #Topic test status
14:32:32 <debrascott> morgan_orange: good morning, how is functest today?
14:32:47 <narindergupta> #info Narinder Gupta
14:32:51 <bin_> #info Bin Hu
14:33:05 <morgan_orange> #info functest: I tried to capture the situation per scenario/per installer for Functest
14:33:05 <morgan_orange> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/functextnexttaks
14:33:15 <morgan_orange> info functest: it is static => if you want something dynamic => go to dashboard
14:33:15 <morgan_orange> #link http://testresults.opnfv.org/proto/index-pod.html
14:33:23 <radez> #info Dan Radez
14:33:26 <morgan_orange> #info functest: according to success criteria, we have already 1 validated scenario: compass/onos
14:33:26 <morgan_orange> #info functest: another one jst needs iterations to be validated: compass/nosdn
14:33:26 <morgan_orange> #info functest: some are closed but the criteria of 90% of success on Tempest is not reached
14:33:26 <morgan_orange> #info functest: support on troubleshooting the Tempest error / scenario / installer welcome --
14:33:37 <morgan_orange> #info functest: morning errors on CI were not due to tests but to result pushed in artifacts (need config on jumphosts), now artifacts are pushed
14:33:44 <morgan_orange> #info functest: joid has better results on non CI POD (Orange POD2) regarding Tempest (92%), so just considering CI POD could be unfair fo installer if PODs have some network issues
14:33:57 <morgan_orange> #link http://artifacts.opnfv.org/logs/functest/opnfv-jump-1/brahmaputra/2016-02-03_19-05-12/brahmaputra/tempest/tempest.log
14:34:12 <morgan_orange> #info ex of log pushed to artifact (here tempest log on apex)
14:34:19 <morgan_orange> #link http://artifacts.opnfv.org/logs/functest/opnfv-jump-1/brahmaputra/2016-02-03_19-05-12/brahmaputra/rally/opnfv-neutron.html
14:34:25 <morgan_orange> #info functest: new release of the LF test dashboard (still things to fix especially the installer versions)
14:34:42 <morgan_orange> that is all for me
14:35:17 <trevor_intel> #info Trevor Cooper
14:35:49 <joekidder> #info Joe Kidder
14:35:50 <debrascott> morgan_orange: thank you. wiki status link yoiu shared is very helpful!!
14:35:55 <wshao> #info Weidong Shao
14:36:08 <morgan_orange> debrascott: yes but I do not like wiki status...
14:36:14 <morgan_orange> especially when we have CI
14:36:29 <morgan_orange> it is impossible to reflect the reality as things ar emoving all the time...
14:36:34 <debrascott> morgan_orange: I understand, struggling with wiki status updates myself
14:36:44 <morgan_orange> I prefer dynamic dashboard
14:36:50 <morgan_orange> same info but reflecting the reality
14:37:11 <debrascott> morgan_orange: we’ll get to the dynamic one. Hopefully for C
14:37:28 <debrascott> Let’s move on
14:37:40 <debrascott> anac1: good morning, how is yardstick doing today?
14:37:44 <anac1> #info yardstick run on odl scenario successful for ODL Be
14:38:11 <debrascott> anac1: this is with workaround in place?
14:38:27 <anac1> #info investigation on-going to understand whether functest before or after has effect on the success
14:38:35 <anac1> #info no workaround
14:38:57 <debrascott> anac1: WOW! that is good news!!!
14:39:08 <anac1> #info at this point, we'll execute more experiments before reaching conclusions
14:39:24 <jose_lausuch> viktor sent an email about how to check if we dont clean things properly, we could include it in the jjobs
14:39:41 <anac1> #info need to understand from the installers whether ODL Be is an intall option
14:39:52 <anac1> install*
14:40:10 <debrascott> jose_lausuch: +1
14:40:20 <ashyoung> I thought it was
14:40:33 <ashyoung> In fact, I thought it was desirable
14:40:51 <debrascott> trozet, narindergupta ^^?
14:41:13 <narindergupta> debrascott: default is Lithium but there is option to do berilium
14:41:20 <radez> Apex is the same
14:41:36 <radez> we have an sfc option that is based on Be
14:41:48 <narindergupta> debrascott: in case of joid one config option has to change in yaml file which can be done using jjb
14:41:50 <anac1> radez: could you provide us with a fresh install of ODL Be in LF POD1 ?
14:42:18 <debrascott> jonasbjurel:^^?
14:42:26 <radez> anac1: we're very close to being able to, will yardstick not work on Li?
14:42:33 <radez> or are we going to do both?
14:42:34 <anac1> narindergupta: same for you, could you provide us with a fresh install (and help us with the access to the POD) ?
14:43:00 <debrascott> wshao:^^??
14:43:08 <narindergupta> anac1: we need a pod where i can run the install. Currently pod5 has for ci
14:43:12 <anac1> radez: on ODL Li, we have the ping+ssh faults, need a workaround that is temporary, i'd prefer ODL Be
14:43:37 <anac1> narindergupta: ok, thanks
14:43:39 <jonasbjurel> debrascott: Yes supported by Fuel
14:43:55 <radez> anac1:k, I was planning to see if I can get you a clean Li env today or tomorrow for yardstick, and as soon as we can have Be too we'll stand that up for you
14:43:57 <wshao> we do not have ODL Be yet.
14:44:20 <anac1> radez: great, thanks ! let's get sfc done
14:44:49 <radez> anac1: would your rather we focus on Be for yardstick? or do you still want li?
14:45:07 <anac1> i'd prefer Be
14:45:30 <ChrisPriceAB> Hi folks, I'm not able to join today.  But can I ask us to keep the very latest information up on https://etherpad.opnfv.org/p/steps_to_brahmaputra
14:45:55 <debrascott> ChrisPriceAB: my next topic for today
14:45:58 <ChrisPriceAB> The sections at the bottom can show the successive deploys etc in order that we are able to start to pick "release ready" scenario's asap
14:46:06 <ChrisPriceAB> thanks debra, will run away now.  :D
14:46:10 <debrascott> #Topic Schedule building ot relase
14:46:13 <wshao> question on ODL Be, is it desirable to use it? We can try that in Compass, if that is the goal
14:46:16 <anac1> we will use the workaround for Li, if the installer don't have Be yet
14:47:14 <anac1> wshao: can you try ODL Be with compass ?
14:48:14 <wshao> ok ,we will try it tomorrow (China time).
14:48:31 <debrascott> anac1: Good discussion, ready to move on?
14:48:59 <anac1> wshao: thanks, yardstick guys n China can help - they are also on top of the issues
14:49:09 <anac1> debrascott: sure
14:49:20 <debrascott> Ok, thanks.
14:49:25 <wshao> anac1: ok cool
14:49:32 <debrascott> https://etherpad.opnfv.org/p/steps_to_brahmaputra
14:50:02 <debrascott> in order to keep a schedule that I can work real time we need to have more details in the above link
14:50:43 <debrascott> We may be asked to make tradeoff’s with different scenarios
14:50:50 <debrascott> what to cut and what to keep
14:51:15 <debrascott> and what time could be saved if dropping certain scenarios
14:51:58 <debrascott> anac1: can you do something similar for yardstick as morgan_orange has done for functest?
14:52:35 <debrascott> we need to understand what features might be dropped in yardstick if we drop certain scenarios
14:53:04 <debrascott> we also need to understand what has already been working/failing/not tested yet in a high level overview
14:53:06 <jonasbjurel> Debrascott: The selected scenarios need to be coordinated across functest and yardstick
14:53:24 <ashyoung> Sounds like if we can get Compass to support, Be, we might be able to get the largest portion of features supported
14:53:36 <ashyoung> I mean scenarios
14:53:36 <jonasbjurel> We cannot run different sets of scenarios for functest and yardstick
14:53:38 <debrascott> jonasbjurel: yes, which is why we need a similar view to compare
14:54:20 <debrascott> jonasbjurel: we need to see what is running successfully in both yardstick & functest scenarios
14:54:20 <ashyoung> Something in the way Be vs Li handle the security groups
14:54:39 <anac1> ashyoung: could be other faults too
14:54:44 <ashyoung> right
14:54:59 <ebrjohn__> Regarding the Security Groups in ODL-Li, do you know if ODL Group Based Policy is installed?
14:55:22 <ebrjohn__> if so, GBP "uses" (interracts with) security groups
14:55:30 <jonasbjurel> debrascott: Are we basing releasecontent primarily on what is working or not?
14:55:32 <anac1> ebrjohn_: maybe a question for the installers ?
14:55:41 <ebrjohn__> from the ODL karaf console, try this: feature:list -i | grep grou+
14:55:52 <ebrjohn__> feature:list -i | grep group
14:56:05 <anac1> ebrjohn_: as i wrote, there might be other faults on Li causing the failure
14:56:38 <ebrjohn__> anac1: ok, just a possibility
14:57:16 <anac1> question is what ODL version to focus on
14:57:38 <debrascott> jonasbjurel: that’s a place to start, but may have other factors too which is why we need to understand features view
14:59:13 <ashyoung> I recommend progressing on what is working, while others dive in to seeing how to fix the broken scenarios
14:59:26 <debrascott> anac1: my question above?
14:59:33 <ashyoung> So, I suggest continue with Be, while we look into Li
14:59:57 <anac1> debrascott: i'll get to it as soon as I can
15:00:36 <debrascott> anac1: thank you. The board will give us pressure to understand this view, HKirksey has asked for it already
15:00:50 <anac1> ashyoung: makes sense to me
15:01:19 <debrascott> ashyoung: +1
15:01:37 <debrascott> OK, top of the hour already…how does it go so fast?
15:02:37 <debrascott> Thank you for attending everyone. I’m looking at your Jira Dashboards for some status but if you have any specific blocking issues or successes please send me an email to high light those in daily update.
15:02:46 <ashyoung> Flies by when we're having fun
15:03:10 <debrascott> assuming I can get my browser  + wiki update working again
15:03:19 <debrascott> ashyoung: +1
15:03:20 <ashyoung> Gonna keep digging into the Li issues and also into getting compass/Be working
15:03:25 <debrascott> Endmeeting
15:03:31 <ashyoung> Thanks!!!
15:03:32 <debrascott> #endmeeting