14:30:05 <debrascott_> #startmeeting Brahmaputra Daily Standup
14:30:05 <collabot`> Meeting started Mon Feb 22 14:30:05 2016 UTC.  The chair is debrascott_. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:30:05 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
14:30:05 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'brahmaputra_daily_standup'
14:30:13 <debrascott_> #topic roll call
14:30:24 <jonasbjurel> #info Jonas Bjurel
14:30:27 <radez> #info Dan Radez
14:30:32 <morgan_orange> #info Morgan Richomme
14:30:58 <anac1> #indo Ana Cunha
14:31:07 <anac1> #info Ana Cunha
14:31:08 <HKirksey> #info HEather Kirksey
14:31:42 <debrascott_> #link agenda same as Th/Fri https://wiki.opnfv.org/releases/brahmaputra/minutes
14:32:18 <debrascott_> #info the PTLs approved freeze of scenario troubleshooting on Sunday 2/21
14:32:20 <narindergupta1> #info Narinder Gupta
14:32:24 <bin_> #info Bin Hu
14:32:56 <debrascott_> #Topic Test Status and final scenario list for this release
14:32:59 <frankbrockners> #info Frank Brockners
14:33:18 <ashyoung> #info Ashlee Young
14:33:19 <debrascott_> morgan_orange welcome back!
14:33:38 <morgan_orange> #info page on the status updated this morning https://wiki.opnfv.org/functextnexttaks
14:34:21 <morgan_orange> #info scenario ready for B: - apex/odl_l2
14:34:21 <morgan_orange> - compass/odl_l2
14:34:21 <morgan_orange> - compass/onos
14:34:21 <morgan_orange> - compass-nosdn
14:34:21 <morgan_orange> - fuel/nosdn
14:34:22 <morgan_orange> - fuel/old_l2
14:34:22 <morgan_orange> - fuel/onos
14:34:23 <morgan_orange> - fuel/nosdn-ovs
14:34:23 <morgan_orange> - joid/odl_l2
14:34:24 <morgan_orange> - joid/nosdn
14:34:40 <narindergupta1> morgan_orange:  joid/onos  will that pass?
14:35:44 <morgan_orange> narindergupta1: joid/onos still issue with vPing + high error rate on tempest and run only 2 times over the week end
14:35:59 <narindergupta1> morgan_orange:  ok
14:36:09 <debrascott_> morgan_orange: these all pass functest, do the same also pass yardstick?
14:36:18 <anac1> debrascott: no
14:36:39 <anac1> not all
14:36:45 <debrascott_> anac1: which do not pass yardstick (assume that is the shortest list)
14:37:08 <anac1> joid, no scenarios verified
14:37:43 <anac1> fuel: is there any difference from nosdn and ovs until last week ?
14:38:20 <morgan_orange> anac1: for joid the issue is probably linked to authentication issues on heat
14:39:03 <narindergupta1> anac1: it was in your to do list to debug last week. Any status?
14:39:09 <anac1> morgan_orange: yes, probably - but i don't have 4 runs paseed
14:39:39 <anac1> narindergupta: we found no issues in yardstick, works for apex, compass and fuel
14:39:45 <jonasbjurel> anac1: billyoma fixed a bug, but we didnt have resources to run the ovs scenarios
14:40:24 <anac1> jonasburel: thanks, so the above listed nosdn-ovs is not yet ready, right?
14:40:48 <jonasbjurel> anac1: Correct, not yet ran.
14:42:05 <debrascott_> OK so I think these can be noted it release notes: what was not fully tested
14:42:15 <morgan_orange> From functest perspective, I shall also precise that I do not respect stricly our Tempest criteria (> 90% OK) otherwise only compass scenario will be OK. fuel is (80-90 depending on the scenario but reproducible from one run to another), apex variable (60-90, not very reproducible but less tests run that on the other installers)
14:43:18 <debrascott_> morgan_orange: also good for release notes
14:43:54 <jonasbjurel> morganorange: I have a lab-config patch that will likely make fuel pass more Tempest, (too few floating IPs currently) - havnt had resources to run that patch yet
14:43:55 <debrascott_> Are there any features that are not supported by at least one scenario?
14:44:50 <jonasbjurel> debrascott_ NFVOVS, KVM4NFV, SFC, BGP-VPN
14:45:39 <debrascott_> jonasbjurel: thank you, this will be important for marketing to refine their messaging
14:45:41 <morgan_orange> jonasbjurel: cool it shall fixe almost 5-10 errors - but I put a clear status because the number of errors is limited, one dealt with the nb of floatting IP, there is another one linked to heat
14:46:25 <morgan_orange> doctor is also in progress in any apex scenario but not supported yet
14:47:02 <debrascott_> any additional discussion about what it/is not in first release of B?
14:47:17 <debrascott_> morgan_orange: thanks
14:47:45 <debrascott_> OK lets move on to docs
14:48:01 <debrascott_> ChrisPriceAB: are you with us today?
14:48:10 <ChrisPriceAB> not quite...
14:48:19 <debrascott_> :)
14:48:29 <ChrisPriceAB> #info opnfvdocs call scheduled for 16:00 to review content and status of all release docs.
14:48:55 <debrascott_> 16:00 which time zone?
14:49:48 <morgan_orange> CET just after this meeting
14:49:59 <morgan_orange> ChrisPriceAB: I will join at 16h30..
14:50:08 <debrascott_> morgan_orange: thanks
14:50:16 <ChrisPriceAB> ok thanks morgan_orange
14:50:21 <anac1> ChrisPriceAB: same for me, join at 16:30
14:50:58 <debrascott_> anac1, morgan_orange: are you feeling confident with the remaining time to document test results? Do you have resources you need?
14:51:15 <anac1> debrascott_: yes
14:51:28 <ChrisPriceAB> #info opnfvdocs goto meeting details: https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/156364589
14:51:41 <morgan_orange> debrascott_: yes ... copy/paste of jenkins logs...
14:52:15 <debrascott_> anac1, morgan_orange: good!
14:52:48 <debrascott_> OK we are down to the end of 1st release do we need to start talking about 2nd release?
14:53:17 <debrascott_> We target end March for that
14:53:29 <debrascott_> Which scenarios are likely to make it in by that time?
14:54:33 <jonasbjurel> This is not 1'st release, its the 3'rd :-)
14:54:34 <narindergupta1> debrascott_: is it possible to add the scenarios like onos for joid
14:54:36 <narindergupta1> ?
14:55:21 <debrascott_> jonasbjurel: I mean 1st release of B and 2nd release of B (not C release)
14:55:35 <morgan_orange> just to be sure..for joid scenario, heat shall be fixed to allow yardstick on joid scenarios 4 times until when? otherwise no joid scenario will be in B release...Do I understand correctly?
14:55:41 <jonasbjurel> debrascott_: I understand
14:57:19 <narindergupta1> morgan_orange: i think odl_l2 and nosdn is in as those passes other test and heat issue need to find the root cause as it started failing.
14:57:52 <anac1> morgan_orange: who will fix heat ?
14:58:16 <anac1> morgan_orange: i have the same understanding as you
14:59:06 <debrascott_> narindergupta1, morgan_orange: vIMS is the issue for JOID in functest, correct? the fix for vIMS is in already or not?
14:59:26 <morgan_orange> vIMS is not a critical criteria for release
15:00:02 <morgan_orange> restriction must be documented
15:00:33 <anac1> i have to leave for another meeting
15:00:51 <debrascott_> If not troubleshooting, but test run only then I don’t have a problem with having the test run but if fix is not in then I think we document and release without it being supported
15:01:14 <debrascott_> it can be in next B release
15:01:34 <debrascott_> OK, time to go. Thanks everyone for joining
15:01:38 <debrascott_> #endmeeting