02:28:36 <dmcbride> #startmeeting APAC OPNFV release meeting
02:28:36 <collabot`> Meeting started Wed Apr  5 02:28:36 2017 UTC.  The chair is dmcbride. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
02:28:36 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
02:28:36 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'apac_opnfv_release_meeting'
02:28:42 <dmcbride> #topic roll call
02:28:48 <dmcbride> #info David McBride
02:30:03 <dmcbride> ok guys lets get started
02:30:10 <kubi001> #info kubi
02:30:21 <chigang> #info Justin chi
02:31:18 <dmcbride> #topic Danube release
02:31:33 <dmcbride> how was the release last week?
02:31:41 <dmcbride> anyone have any questions or comments?
02:32:20 <dmcbride> the technical release was completed over the weekend
02:32:40 <dmcbride> the download page went live this morning (Pacific time)
02:33:01 <kubi001> dmcbride: should we have a security scan for all projects ?
02:33:29 <dmcbride> #info dmcbride notes that the technical release of D1 was completed and that the download page went live on Tuesday morning (Pacific)
02:34:09 <dmcbride> kubi001: there is an email thread about that topic on the mailing list
02:34:34 <dmcbride> kubi001: I believe that will come up in the retrospective that is planned next week
02:35:12 <kubi001> dmcbride: OK
02:35:20 <dmcbride> kubi001: the PTL indicated that he hasn't had an opportunity to engage with OPNFV as much as he'd hoped, so I think that the community needs to evaluate the status of security scan
02:35:25 <dmcbride> kubi001: good question
02:35:38 <dmcbride> #info kubi001 asks about security scan
02:36:02 <dmcbride> #info dmcbride says that  the PTL indicated that he hasn't had an opportunity to engage with OPNFV as much as he'd hoped, so I think that the community needs to evaluate the status of security scan
02:36:25 <dmcbride> #info likely topic for the retrospective
02:36:50 <dmcbride> kubi001: also note that we will probably be discussing some of these topics at the plugfest at the end of the month
02:36:56 <dmcbride> kubi001: will you be attending?
02:38:16 <dmcbride> #info we will use the main release meeting for a Danube retrospective on April 11
02:38:19 <kubi001> dmcbride: yes, I just registered the plugfest two days ago, I 'm prepareing for Visa
02:38:44 <dmcbride> #info we will also follow up some topics at the plugfest in Paris at the end of April
02:39:00 <dmcbride> kubi001: glad to hear that
02:39:12 <dmcbride> #topic Danube 2.0
02:39:51 <dmcbride> #info the schedule for D2 was not affected by the schedule change for D1.  The date is still May 4.
02:40:17 <kubi001> dmcbride: is there new scenario for D2?
02:40:44 <dmcbride> #info note that everyone that released for D1 will also need to support D2.  If there are changes that impact your project or scenarios, you will need to resolve them.
02:41:19 <dmcbride> kubi001: there will likely be a small number of additional scenarios for D2
02:42:06 <dmcbride> any more questions about D2?
02:42:17 <kubi001> dmcbride: one question about D1 :)
02:42:25 <dmcbride> kubi001: go ahead
02:43:10 <kubi001> Is there a list for D1 scenarios which finally are released ?
02:44:04 <dmcbride> #info kubi001 asks about a list of scenarios released for D1
02:44:40 <dmcbride> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/Danube+Scenario+Status
02:45:32 <dmcbride> #info if you look at the "Intent to release 1.0" column (sortable), the scenarios that were released are marked with a "Y"
02:45:54 <dmcbride> make sense?
02:46:25 <kubi001> dmcbride: a little confuse about that
02:46:42 <kubi001> dmcbride: I think that is intent to release 1.0
02:47:11 <kubi001> dmcbride: all the scenario which marked with a"Y" have been released?
02:47:22 <dmcbride> kubi001: yes, that was used as the basis for what was released
02:48:02 <kubi001> dmcbride:  so all released scenario have passed the functest's validation?
02:48:15 <dmcbride> kubi001: noooo
02:48:57 <dmcbride> kubi001: we aren't doing that.  The consensus is that there are two many exceptions and issues to use functest to gate releases
02:49:24 <kubi001> dmcbride: OK, I see, thanks for clarify
02:49:31 <dmcbride> kubi001: so, the only requirement we have is that the scenario passes deployment, and that any exceptions are documented in the release notes
02:49:44 <kubi001> dmcbride: got it
02:50:09 <dmcbride> kubi001: basically, we're leaving it up to the judgment of the project/scenario owners
02:50:30 <kubi001> dmcbride: sounds reasonable for now :)
02:50:34 <dmcbride> kubi001: I'd like to see us tighten that up over time
02:51:02 <yujunz> I have another question on D1 to D2, dmcbride
02:51:17 <dmcbride> yujunz: go ahead
02:51:18 <yujunz> If no changes are made between D1 and D2, do we still tag danube.2.0 in the project, on the same git ref as danbue.1.0
02:51:27 <yujunz> ?
02:52:01 <dmcbride> yujunz: that is an interesting question that I've been thinking about, as well
02:52:20 <dmcbride> yujunz: I need to talk it over with Ray and the release engineering guys
02:52:28 <dmcbride> yujunz: do you have an opinion?
02:52:51 <yujunz> Thanks. I would suggesting adding tag danube.2.0 even if no change
02:53:18 <dmcbride> yujunz: ok - I'll keep that in mind.  Thanks for your input.
02:53:20 <yujunz> That could be easier to align the baseline of all projects
02:53:53 <dmcbride> #info yujunz asks whether projects will be tagged for D2 if no changes since D1
02:54:05 <kubi001> dmcbride:  at least, we need to change the "Release_note.rst" .
02:54:30 <dmcbride> #info yujunz recommends that all projects should be tagged, regardless of changes
02:55:01 <dmcbride> #info kubi001 says that we at least need to change release_note.rst
02:55:12 <kubi001> http://docs.opnfv.org/en/stable-danube/submodules/yardstick/docs/release/release-notes/release-notes.html
02:55:41 <kubi001> dmcbride: there is a "Date" field which we need to fill in
02:56:45 <dmcbride> kubi001: good point
02:57:23 <dmcbride> #topic Euphrates intent-to-participate
02:57:47 <dmcbride> #info intent to release window open 03/27 - 04/24
02:58:33 <dmcbride> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/DEV/Project+Inclusion+in+OPNFV+Release
02:58:51 <dmcbride> #info process for stating intent to participate ^^
02:59:09 <dmcbride> basically an email to the TSC mailing list from the PTL
02:59:34 <dmcbride> chigang: have not heard from Compass
03:00:17 <dmcbride> heard from QTIP, heard from Yardstick
03:00:28 <chigang> dmcbride: Just come back from vacation, I will send mail in days
03:00:48 <dmcbride> chigang: no excuses!
03:01:42 <kubi001> chigang:  no excuses!
03:02:19 <chigang> I do :)
03:02:34 <dmcbride> kubi001:  or chigang do you know Howard?
03:02:50 <dmcbride> I don't see him online, unless I'm just missing his nic
03:03:03 <yujunz> Howard from Parser ?
03:03:10 <chigang> dmcbride: Maybe he is in US, for ONF summit.
03:03:14 <dmcbride> right
03:03:27 <dmcbride> I haven't received a notice from the Parser team, either
03:03:36 <yujunz> I think he has resigned from Parser PTL as mentioned in mailing list
03:03:51 <dmcbride> ah - ok
03:04:38 <dmcbride> #topic Euphrates release planning
03:05:26 <dmcbride> #info note that in addition to closing the intent-to-participate window, April 24 is also the deadline for release planning (MS1)
03:06:29 <dmcbride> #info 1) document your release plan in the OPNFV wiki, as you've done previously
03:06:43 <kubi001> dmcbride: I have connect with Howard, he will online soon.
03:07:19 <dmcbride> #info 2) complete the release plan summary
03:07:24 <dmcbride> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/Summary+of+Release+Plans+for+Euphrates
03:07:36 <dmcbride> kubi001: ok - thanks
03:08:26 <zhipeng> hi david
03:08:41 <dmcbride> hi Howard
03:08:53 <dmcbride> are you at ONS?
03:09:15 <zhipeng> no i'm not attending ONS :(
03:09:27 <dmcbride> neither am I
03:09:40 <dmcbride> but I will be at the plugfest
03:10:04 <dmcbride> zhipeng: excuse me for forgetting this, but did you resign at the PTL for the Parser project?
03:10:20 <zhipeng> yes I have, starting E release
03:10:39 <zhipeng> however I could still handle matter before our new ptl swear in :P
03:10:40 <dmcbride> ok - has a new PTL been elected?
03:10:51 <zhipeng> hopefully next week
03:11:06 <zhipeng> i'm now officially an interim PTL :P
03:11:25 <dmcbride> zhipeng: for now, I just need an email to the TSC mailing list saying that Parser plans to participate in Euphrates
03:11:35 <zhipeng> okey no problem
03:11:42 <dmcbride> template is here:  https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/DEV/Project+Inclusion+in+OPNFV+Release
03:12:04 <zhipeng> got it
03:12:52 <dmcbride> does anyone know the Open Retrieve PTL, Xuan Jia?
03:13:20 <kubi001> dmcbride: yes, I have his wechat ID
03:13:27 <dmcbride> I guesss he's China Mobile
03:13:46 <dmcbride> I need to add his name to the invitee list for this meeting
03:14:03 <dmcbride> ok - guys, that's it for now
03:14:20 <dmcbride> any final questions / comments / insults?
03:14:40 <kubi001> dmcbride: anything I can do for contact with Xuan Jia?
03:15:07 <dmcbride> kubi001: could you let him know about this meeting?
03:15:17 <dmcbride> kubi001: it would be helpful if he could attend
03:15:24 <kubi001> dmcbride: sure, will do
03:15:34 <dmcbride> I will also add him to the invitee list
03:15:42 <dmcbride> kubi001: thanks!
03:15:57 <dmcbride> ok - have a good day
03:15:59 <kubi001> :)
03:16:02 <kubi001> bye
03:16:06 <yujunz> bye
03:16:09 <dmcbride> bye
03:16:10 <chigang> bye
03:16:18 <dmcbride> #endmeeting