00:35:12 <rbbratta> #startmeeting Yardstick Work Meeting 00:35:12 <collabot`> Meeting started Tue Mar 21 00:35:12 2017 UTC. The chair is rbbratta. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 00:35:12 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 00:35:12 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'yardstick_work_meeting' 00:35:27 <rbbratta> Kubi said he couldn't make the meeting 00:35:55 <rbbratta> #topic roll call 00:36:16 <JingLu> #info Jing 00:36:42 <rbbratta> #info Ross 00:36:50 <rbbratta> Not sure how to start gotomeeting 00:37:29 <JingLu> I don't have the account to start GMT, either. 00:37:43 <JingLu> So may be IRC only. 00:37:54 <rbbratta> okay 00:38:35 <rbbratta> #topic action-item follows up 00:39:18 <JackChan> #info Jack 00:39:34 <rbbratta> #info AP1 rbbratta will work with the MD5SUM and vivid 00:39:47 <rbbratta> #info MD5SUM and vivid patches submitted 00:40:47 <rbbratta> any other action items? 00:41:31 <JingLu> that's all, I think 00:41:42 <rbbratta> #info CI status 00:42:14 <JingLu> #link https://build.opnfv.org/ci/view/yardstick/ 00:42:21 <rbbratta> any update on CI? 00:43:01 <JingLu> Not so much so far, I will keep monitoring. 00:44:10 <rbbratta> Okay 00:44:20 <rbbratta> #info stable branch 00:45:15 <rbbratta> what do we need for stable branch? maybe https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/31109 00:46:18 <JingLu> You mean cherry picking patch to the stable branch? 00:46:37 <rbbratta> Yes, what do we need to cherry-pick to stable 00:46:58 <rbbratta> supposed to be bugfixes only 00:47:37 <JingLu> Yes, all patches that fix CI 00:47:48 <rbbratta> 31109 looks like it is bugfix 00:48:12 <rbbratta> Not sure about CPU/NUMA pinning support. 00:48:20 <JingLu> yes, this is a bugfix for apex scenarios. 00:49:14 <rbbratta> which? CPU/NUMA is for Apex scenarios? 00:50:03 <rbbratta> or 31109 00:50:11 <JingLu> I discussed with kubi, he thought CPU/NUMA should be picked to stable, but if anyone against, I will abandon them. 00:50:25 <JingLu> 31109 is the bugfix 00:51:12 <rbbratta> well I was working on a different method of calling ansible, but I don't have it ready yet 00:52:03 <JackChan> Using python? 00:52:35 <rbbratta> Yes, dynamic inventory and extra-vars. It is code we use from another project internally. 00:53:12 <JackChan> rbbratta: Great! 00:53:33 <rbbratta> I would also prefer we use ansible openstack modules with shade module, and run the openstack commands from the yardstick host. 00:54:59 <JackChan> But shade do not support some openstack options. 00:55:54 <rbbratta> oh? do you have details? It depends what we need to do. 00:55:56 <JackChan> sorry, options->operations 00:56:51 <Mingjiang> JackChan: do you know what shade support now, a list maybe? 00:58:10 <Mingjiang> #link https://docs.openstack.org/infra/shade/genindex.html 00:58:11 <rbbratta> But for stable branch, the question is risk, are the CPU/NUMA changes stable/tested, will they impact stable branch much? 00:58:14 <JackChan> Mingjiang: It is the documentation of all modules, We can check from this. 00:58:58 <JingLu> rbbratta they will not affect the stable branch. 00:59:04 <rbbratta> we wouldn't use shade directly, just the ansible 2.2 openstack modules that call shade. 00:59:05 <JackChan> But the shade module do not support many operations. And some operations will be supported in ansible 2.3.0 00:59:35 <rbbratta> Okay, so we can cherry-pick to stable branch 00:59:45 <JackChan> rbbratta: yes, some operations only supported in ansible 2.3.0 01:00:23 <Mingjiang> i see, we're only using the ansible openstack module 01:00:35 <JackChan> I am trying to find a example. 01:00:59 <JackChan> #link http://docs.ansible.com/ansible/os_nova_flavor_module.html 01:01:12 <JackChan> see extra_specs option 01:01:42 <rbbratta> #info CPU/NUMA pinning okay to cherry-pick to stable 01:02:31 <rbbratta> anything else for stable branch? 01:02:41 <Mingjiang> also it may require some extra libs to be installed on the node/host if we use openstack module, is it right? 01:03:03 <rbbratta> Mingjiang: ansible should run from the docker container 01:03:40 <JingLu> I think MD5 and vivid patches are ready to merge today and will be picked to stable branch 01:03:48 <JackChan> Mingjiang: Maybe we should install shade on the host. 01:04:19 <rbbratta> Yes, we should install shade in the docker container 01:04:58 <Mingjiang> rbbratta: i mean the host/node to be configured may also need something to be installed 01:05:23 <rbbratta> #info MD5 and vivid patches are ready to merge today and will be picked to stable branch 01:05:48 <rbbratta> Mingjiang: shade should use openstack rest API, there should be no need to touch the nodes 01:06:47 <rbbratta> I lost track, what topic are we on? MS8, MS9? 01:07:31 <Mingjiang> rbbratta: Thanks for your info, if it only use openstack API, i think it's a clean and clear way 01:08:21 <JackChan> rbbratta: got it. 01:08:24 <Mingjiang> rbbratta: no new topic typed in 01:08:37 <rbbratta> #topic MS8, MS9 01:08:51 <rbbratta> #info ACTION: please update the the fix version of JIRA tickets which you won't implement within Danube 1.0 01:09:15 <rbbratta> #undo 01:09:15 <collabot`> Removing item from minutes: <MeetBot.ircmeeting.items.Info object at 0x2366190> 01:09:24 <rbbratta> #action please update the the fix version of JIRA tickets which you won't implement within Danube 1.0 01:09:57 <rbbratta> anything else on MS8, MS9? 01:11:07 <Mingjiang> #link https://jira.opnfv.org/issues/?jql=project%20%3D%20YARDSTICK%20and%20fixVersion%20%3D%20%22Danube%201.0%22%20and%20status%20not%20in%20(Closed%2CCancelled%2CResolved) 01:11:40 <Mingjiang> i've seen 49 01:11:48 <Mingjiang> 49->47 tickets 01:12:16 <Mingjiang> i'll update it today asap 01:12:38 <JackChan> I will also update it today. 01:12:50 <JingLu> Me too 01:14:36 <rbbratta> okay, next topic 01:14:50 <rbbratta> #topic others 01:15:16 <OPNFV-Gerrit-Bot> Merged yardstick: Bugfix: netperf_bottleneck execute failed because is_same_heat_context return True https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/31025 01:15:21 <rbbratta> I'm working on add Centos support for docker, and VNFs 01:15:46 <rbbratta> Deepak should have some more patches to submit soon, Ixia support and other stuff. 01:16:17 <rbbratta> For Centos support I am converting everything to ansible, should have a draft soon. 01:17:22 <Mingjiang> look forward to the centos support 01:17:47 <rbbratta> Also Deepak should be adding apachebench/nginx support for traffic generator 01:18:31 <rbbratta> Then also eventually adding KPI support for barometer and ceilometer 01:18:44 <rbbratta> So we need to make some Jira tickets. 01:19:41 <Mingjiang> great 01:20:27 <rbbratta> #info Ross working on adding CentOS support for docker and VMs 01:21:38 <rbbratta> I'm having problems with shade authenticating inside the docker though, something with identity_api_version. Hard to debug. 01:22:43 <rbbratta> okay, end meeting? 01:22:58 <JingLu> okay 01:23:03 <rbbratta> #endmeeting