01:02:10 <trinaths1> #startmeeting ovn4nfv 01:02:10 <collabot> Meeting started Tue Oct 31 01:02:10 2017 UTC. The chair is trinaths1. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 01:02:10 <collabot> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 01:02:10 <collabot> The meeting name has been set to 'ovn4nfv' 01:03:06 <trinaths1> #chair trinaths 01:03:06 <collabot> Warning: Nick not in channel: trinaths 01:03:06 <collabot> Current chairs: trinaths trinaths1 01:06:20 <SridharP1> Hello 01:08:37 <trinaths1> Hi 01:09:27 <trinaths1> lets wait for virkram 01:10:53 <trinaths1> #chair trinaths vdham 01:10:53 <collabot> Current chairs: trinaths trinaths1 vdham 01:11:01 <trinaths1> #agenda https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/OV/Meeting+Agenda 01:11:23 <trinaths1> Project Roadmap and Release plan [1] for F Release[2]. 01:11:31 <trinaths1> #topic Project Roadmap and Release plan [1] for F Release[2]. 01:11:56 <trinaths1> Hi vdham SridharP1 01:12:10 <vdham> Hi Trinath and Sridhar 01:12:38 <vdham> I am not able to access the page, it seems password limited access 01:13:13 <trinaths1> vdham: oh! logged in ! 01:13:41 <vdham> For f release suggest - a. We look at couple of new scenarios, investigate support in xci and work on sfc 01:14:32 <trinaths1> vdham: +1 01:15:09 <trinaths1> vdham: what is the procedure to get into xci ? 01:15:13 <vdham> For sfc suggest trinaths1 you may want to look at work done by john mcdowall 01:15:38 <SridharP1> Hi Vikram 01:16:01 <trinaths1> vdham: yes, 01:16:03 <trinaths1> #link http://openvswitch.org/support/ovscon2016/7/1400-fourie.pdf 01:16:11 <vdham> One option for xci would be to work with narinder gupta from canonical he has k8s scenario with ovn, might want to integrate it with xci 01:16:18 <vdham> Hi Sridharp1 01:16:33 <vdham> Yes same sfc deck 01:16:37 <trinaths1> vdham: guide me how do we implement SFC scenario into other installers, 01:17:07 <vdham> Might need to have sfc running in devstack with ovn first 01:17:41 <vdham> If it works use apex installer and work with Dan Radez 01:17:54 <trinaths1> vdham: fine, we will have OVN SFC tested with openstack-devstack 01:18:25 <trinaths1> then how we integrate with other installers. 01:18:38 <vdham> For f release i wouldnt advise committing anything more than couple of scenarios and sfc testbed 01:18:39 <trinaths1> this scenario for joid ? 01:18:47 <trinaths1> vdham: agree. 01:19:10 <vdham> K8s is in joid 01:19:13 <vdham> With ovn 01:19:23 <vdham> Narinder is your guy 01:19:43 <trinaths1> vdham: container-vnf and ovn sfc ? 01:19:58 <vdham> Sfc is seperate 01:20:06 <vdham> Scenario 01:20:13 <vdham> K8s is seperate for now 01:20:19 <trinaths1> vdham: agree. 01:20:21 <trinaths1> vdham: ok. 01:20:55 <trinaths1> vdham: then we dont add any new fucntionality/scenario to joid 01:20:57 <trinaths1> ? 01:21:06 <vdham> If dont want to do sfc in f other option would be to do vm and container hybrid scenario which only ovn can do 01:21:35 <vdham> Suggest commit very less 01:21:52 <vdham> - xci scenario 01:21:59 <trinaths1> vdham: we want to sfc.. since vCPE is a Edge NFV solution where SFC is important 01:22:28 <vdham> Would require looking at latest status of sfc on ovs thread 01:23:02 <trinaths1> vdham: agree. them, lets only propose OVN-SFC for now and have time, then propose hybrid scenarios. 01:23:42 <vdham> Want to take a day investigate sfc status before committing? 01:24:06 <vdham> Hybrid might be low hanging unique value addition 01:26:39 <trinaths1> yes, we need to investigate SFC.. but less time for me.. since sydney summit and preperations 01:26:52 <trinaths1> lets have hybrid scenario. 01:27:06 <trinaths1> if ovn-sfc works, can we update the release plan ? 01:27:15 <vdham> For hybrid might get help from container4nfv team as well 01:27:25 <vdham> Yes we can add sfx later 01:27:32 <trinaths1> ok 01:27:35 <vdham> Commit less minimal for now 01:27:44 <trinaths1> vdham: sure. +1 01:28:09 <vdham> So os and k8s scenarios in xci 01:28:23 <vdham> Talk with dan and narinder to scope 01:28:28 <trinaths1> vdham: ok 01:28:32 <vdham> Or if they plan to do it 01:28:48 <vdham> Secondly work on hybrid scenario vm plus container 01:28:55 <trinaths1> #action 1. OS and K8S scenarios in XCI - Dan and Narinder help required. 01:29:19 <vdham> +1 01:29:24 <trinaths1> #action 2. OVN fabric for Hybrid environment Container and VM 01:29:32 <vdham> Great 01:30:00 <trinaths1> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/OVN4NFV+Release+Plan+for+OPNFV+Euphrates 01:30:03 <vdham> Optional for marketing showcase edge scenario on arm 01:30:17 <vdham> Trivial edge scenario 01:30:51 <trinaths1> vdham: yes, after SFC is working. 01:30:57 <trinaths1> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/Fraser+Scenario+Status 01:31:23 <trinaths1> vdham: I think we need to discuss with dan and Narinder for update of the scenario status 01:31:50 <trinaths1> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/OVN4NFV 01:32:13 <trinaths1> vdham: the above link os for projects F release plan 01:32:15 <vdham> They are generally available on irc if you ping them or else email 01:32:53 <trinaths1> vdham: I will ping them also will aks for their contact number (if they give) 01:33:11 <trinaths1> need convince narinder and dan to attend this meeting 01:34:05 <vdham> Ok 01:34:44 <trinaths1> ok. vdham please review this #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/OVN4NFV 01:35:31 <trinaths1> vdham: OS and K8S scenarios in XCI - Dan and Narinder help required. - Do we need to move the existing scenarios to XCI ? fatih is the guy for xci 01:35:42 <vdham> Please sync with Srinivas for hybrid scenario and he can help ovn4nfv would suggest making him committer 01:36:02 <vdham> Yes Fatih can give pointers 01:36:06 <vdham> For xci 01:36:10 <trinaths1> vdham: srinivas ? 01:36:23 <vdham> From intel 01:36:28 <trinaths1> vdham: :) 01:36:49 <trinaths1> vdham: he is our x CTO , we worked in his team for 11 years.. 01:37:03 <vdham> Ohhh :)) 01:37:38 <trinaths1> i'm working for container4nfv for arm cpe scenrios. 01:37:51 <vdham> He should definitely be able to assign some intel resource for ivn4nfv 01:38:15 <vdham> Especially only ovn can support hybrid scenario 01:38:26 <trinaths1> he did not attend the meeting now. yes he can.. but intel platforms.. 01:38:45 <trinaths1> vdham: I will ping him sometime today. 01:38:52 <vdham> Ok 01:40:27 <trinaths1> vdham please review this #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/OVN4NFV 01:41:15 <trinaths1> I just used the data from E release. 01:41:25 <vdham> Ok 01:41:50 <trinaths1> do we need to give a detailed release plan for F release ? 01:42:10 <trinaths1> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/SWREL/Suggested+Release+Plan+Template 01:42:12 <vdham> Let me check tonight and get back to you on it 01:42:22 <trinaths1> ok 01:42:25 <trinaths1> #topic Scenarios and Installer support [3]. 01:42:49 <trinaths1> we agreed on Apex and JOID. with existing scenarios 01:43:04 <trinaths1> vdham: with hybrid in place, we get a new scenario ? 01:43:19 <vdham> Yes 01:44:17 <trinaths1> what can be new status name. ? also, to include the new status, we need to get Narinder and Dan approve it 01:44:51 <trinaths1> ?? 01:45:17 <trinaths1> os-ovn-nofeature-ha => os-ovn-hybrid-ha 01:45:30 <trinaths1> K8-ovn-lb-noha => K8-ovn-lb-hybrid-noha 01:45:32 <vdham> Yes 01:46:26 <trinaths1> since we have very less time, (nov 3rd for proposals) lets have os-ovn-nofeature-ha and K8-ovn-lb-noha have in place. 01:47:03 <trinaths1> in mean time lets talk to dan and narinder for these new scenarios. for this, we required OVN Containter and VM usecase tested and ready 01:47:10 <trinaths1> vdham: comments ? 01:47:43 <vdham> Need to check if ovn is ha ready 01:48:10 <vdham> Believe ben had pushed patch for ha couple of mnths back 01:48:19 <trinaths1> vdham: ok. 01:48:41 <trinaths1> #action 3. Check OVN is HA ready. refer to Ben patches for HA in OVN 01:49:01 <trinaths1> #topic F release milestones 01:49:06 <trinaths1> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/download/attachments/12390157/OPNFV%20Release%20%2522Fraser%2522%20r4.pdf?version=1&modificationDate=1508970501000&api=v2 01:50:23 <trinaths1> #info Nov - 3rd - Planning Complete and Deliverables defined 01:50:59 <trinaths1> #info Nov - 17th - Test cases documented in Testcases database 01:51:35 <trinaths1> vdham: for the above 17th dead line, do we need to post test scripts to functests 01:51:37 <trinaths1> ? 01:51:47 <vdham> Too close 01:51:56 <trinaths1> vdham: yes. 01:52:32 <trinaths1> #info Dec - 4th - Plugfest 01:52:46 <trinaths1> #info Dec - 15th - E 5.2 01:53:05 <vdham> Mnot going to plugfest 01:53:14 <vdham> Change of plan 01:53:53 <trinaths1> # info Feb'18 - 2nd - Integration with OpenStack 01:54:15 <trinaths1> vdham: oh! ok. no issues. is it mandatory that every project has to participate at plugfest ? 01:54:36 <vdham> No 01:54:51 <trinaths1> ok 01:55:02 <trinaths1> #topic E Release - Review. 01:55:25 <trinaths1> vdham: do we have any work for E release. 01:55:33 <trinaths1> i remember release notes 01:55:46 <vdham> Release notes and jira cleanup 01:55:55 <trinaths1> jira cleanup is done 01:55:59 <trinaths1> release notes is pending 01:56:25 <trinaths1> #action Complete E release notes - trinaths, vdham 01:56:33 <vdham> Ok 01:56:41 <trinaths1> vdham: for the above 17th dead line, do we need to post test scripts to functests 01:57:24 <vdham> Only docs 01:57:52 <trinaths1> vdham: please point me to E docs 01:58:03 <trinaths1> we have 3 minutes more.. ! 01:59:05 <trinaths1> #topic OpenStack Summit – Sydney – Interesting talks for the Project. 01:59:15 <trinaths1> #link https://www.openstack.org/summit/sydney-2017/summit-schedule/events/20416/whats-new-with-ovs-and-ovn-2-8 01:59:23 <trinaths1> Ben is giving this talk. 01:59:33 <vdham> Nice 01:59:40 <trinaths1> I will try meet him for some tech talk 02:00:33 <trinaths1> thanks vdham, I will update the release plan and work on the action items. 02:00:50 <trinaths1> thanks vdham, SridharP1 02:00:50 <vdham> Ok thanks 02:00:58 <trinaths1> #endmeeting