15:29:55 <trinaths> #startmeeting ovn4nfv-weekly-meeting-15Jan2019 15:29:55 <collabot`> Meeting started Tue Jan 15 15:29:55 2019 UTC. The chair is trinaths. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot. 15:29:55 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic. 15:29:55 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'ovn4nfv_weekly_meeting_15jan2019' 15:30:24 <electrocucaracha> hey trinaths 15:30:25 <trinaths> #topic Agenda: https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/OV/Meeting+Agenda 15:30:34 <trinaths> hey electrocucaracha 15:30:40 <trinaths> ritu joining ? 15:30:46 <electrocucaracha> I think so 15:30:57 <electrocucaracha> she got the email about the meetings 15:31:16 <trinaths> yes. i sent it 15:31:18 <electrocucaracha> and she didn't tell me anything about it 15:31:35 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: how was the ONAP+OPNFV meetup at france 15:32:04 <electrocucaracha> it was interesting in the sense that new players were going 15:32:09 <electrocucaracha> like Reza from Mirantis 15:32:21 <electrocucaracha> he was exploring the capabilities of ONAP 15:32:50 <trinaths> ok. so there is an action for moving to production readiness 15:32:52 <electrocucaracha> from my point of view, the project that requires a lot of effort and resources is integration 15:34:05 <trinaths> ok. 15:34:17 <trinaths> true said, integration requires much more efforts 15:34:26 <trinaths> even test suite will dynamically change 15:34:30 <trinaths> ritusood: Hi 15:34:38 <ritusood> Hello everyone 15:34:58 <electrocucaracha> hey ritusood 15:35:33 <trinaths> ritusood: hello 15:35:39 <ritusood> Hi 15:36:02 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: attended Amir intern session ? 15:36:31 <electrocucaracha> yes, he was there in most of the sessions that I attended 15:37:27 <trinaths> ok 15:37:46 <trinaths> well, lets start with code reviews and discuss the work progress. 15:37:52 <trinaths> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/65961/ 15:38:27 <ritusood> Yes that is unit test cases 15:39:23 <ritusood> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/65829/ 15:39:39 <ritusood> that is code cleanup that should be reviewed first 15:40:06 <trinaths> https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/65961/1/internal/pkg/config/config_test.go 15:40:10 <trinaths> line 100-112 15:40:23 <trinaths> can we have that config file contents as var ? 15:40:35 <trinaths> and use that var in the function ? 15:40:58 <trinaths> comments ? 15:41:18 <electrocucaracha> I haven't take a look of the changes 15:41:21 <ritusood> Yes go allows this syntax 15:41:29 <electrocucaracha> so hopefully I can do it in this week 15:41:45 <ritusood> this code is comping and running and also passed Jenkins 15:42:21 <electrocucaracha> well, yes but it has a low code coverage isn't it? 15:42:38 <trinaths> ritusood: agree, it passed jenkins. What i'm looking is reusability. 15:42:46 <ritusood> you mean for this file? 15:42:53 <trinaths> yes. 15:43:11 <trinaths> the config contents from Line 100-112 15:43:25 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: yes. agree. 15:43:47 <trinaths> since its a inital test suite, i think we can move on and groom it as we go. 15:45:18 <ritusood> ok 15:47:11 <trinaths> ritusood: please change https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/65961/ as suggested. 15:47:26 <trinaths> any comments on this review ? please share 15:49:18 <ritusood> I'll try making this change as suggested but have to see if Ginkgo framework supports that 15:49:58 <trinaths> AFAIK, it support. please check it and post your comments. We will merge this soon. 15:50:24 <trinaths> next commit, #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/65829/ 15:52:12 <trinaths> https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/65829/3/cmd/ovn4nfvk8s/ovn4nfvk8s.go , L 58 15:52:18 <trinaths> its a log right ? 15:53:01 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: ritusood : I have a doubt why you have used logrus? why not Go provided logging ? 15:54:53 <electrocucaracha> I think that it's what ovn-kubernetes uses, right? 15:55:21 <trinaths> ok. 15:55:49 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: I have a basic doubt, are we implementing CNI again ? 15:57:26 <ritusood_> Sorry got disconnected 15:57:40 <electrocucaracha> that plugin provides a new cni binary 15:57:40 <ritusood_> the last comment I saw was baout logrus 15:58:05 <trinaths> agree. 15:58:11 <ritusood_> logrus provides better logging facilities 15:58:21 <trinaths> ritusood_: ok. got it 15:58:44 <trinaths> I feel there are more development for plugin to come-in. 15:58:56 <trinaths> ritusood_: thanks for README update https://www.amazon.in/Century-Novelty-AX-AY-ABHI-10611-Natural-Coconut/dp/B0032TG0BO 15:59:01 <ritusood_> I missed the cni binary comment 15:59:07 <trinaths> ritusood_: sorry 15:59:10 <trinaths> wrong link 15:59:18 <trinaths> https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/65829/3/internal/pkg/config/config.go 15:59:25 <electrocucaracha> hahaha 15:59:34 <trinaths> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/66331/ 15:59:56 <trinaths> ritusood_: I mean, are we re-implementing the CNI again ? 16:01:12 <ritusood_> We have a new CNI for ovn4nfv-k8s 16:01:35 <ritusood_> that CNI is used to add multiple interfaces 16:02:21 <trinaths> ok. can multus doesn't support that ? 16:02:21 <ritusood_> I needs to be used with Multus 16:02:26 <ritusood_> No 16:02:49 <ritusood_> Multus dosn't support dynamic network creation 16:03:10 <ritusood_> that is one of the requirements and that is the reason we are using OVN 16:03:31 <trinaths> ritusood_: got it. 16:03:38 <trinaths> ritusood_: thank you 16:04:43 <trinaths> ritusood_: i have couple of comments posted for the commits. kindly please review and update the same. 16:04:56 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: please review the commits. 16:04:58 <ritusood_> Sounds good 16:05:27 <electrocucaracha> ok, I'm going to look for some time do to it 16:05:43 <trinaths> #topic k8s-ovn4nfv-plugin - Next todo 16:06:12 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: ritusood_ : How we proceed next ? 16:06:40 <ritusood_> We are looking for resources to integrate with Compass 16:07:15 <ritusood_> We'll let you know if someone can do that soon 16:07:17 <trinaths> ritusood_: that is a priority item for OPNFV release. 16:07:23 <trinaths> ritusood_: thank you 16:07:50 <trinaths> ritusood_: regarding tests, we need a functionality test suite. 16:08:22 <ritusood_> We need a kubernetes deployment for that 16:08:40 <trinaths> that will come with Installer deployment i guess 16:09:03 <ritusood_> you mean with Compass? 16:09:42 <trinaths> ritusood_: yes. 16:10:07 <trinaths> we need to have test suite other than unit-tests to test the compass based deployment. 16:10:38 <ritusood_> Yes agreed 16:11:04 <trinaths> ritusood_: ok 16:12:05 <trinaths> electrocucaracha, ritusood_ : any proposals for OpenStack, KubeCon and ONS Americas 2019 ? 16:12:40 <electrocucaracha> I was thinking to submit something for the ONS 16:12:54 <electrocucaracha> but I haven't decided yet 16:13:04 <trinaths> ok 16:13:44 <trinaths> i was planning for OpenStack and ONS. 16:13:59 <electrocucaracha> any specific topic? 16:14:33 <trinaths> Open Infrastructure 16:15:09 <trinaths> AirShip, KataContainers and trying Sidecar Proxy for Kata Containers 16:15:30 <trinaths> some related topics to OpenStack+K8S+OpenInfra 16:16:13 <trinaths> for ONS, I was thinking for 2 topics. I dont think I get a travel support for ONS 2019. But some co-author can present it. 16:16:17 <electrocucaracha> there is an effort to integrate Airship in XCI 16:16:50 <trinaths> ok. May be that can is a session topic. 16:17:47 <trinaths> #topic Open Discussion. 16:18:33 <trinaths> please vote for "Prakash Ramchandran" contesting for "independent Board of Directors - 2019 - OpenStack". 16:19:16 <electrocucaracha> ok, I'll if I get the link 16:19:22 <ritusood_> ok 16:20:09 <trinaths> electrocucaracha: from OpenStack Berlin summit 2018, I have seen more on intro session on Open Infra, with K8S 16:20:57 <trinaths> we have 10 mins more. 16:21:13 <trinaths> please share if you have anything to discuss 16:22:11 <electrocucaracha> nope, basically that's from my side 16:22:34 <trinaths> ok. 16:22:36 <trinaths> ritusood_: ?? 16:23:29 <trinaths> ok. Let continue the good work. 16:23:31 <trinaths> Bye all 16:23:56 <trinaths> #action ritusood_ : work on recent commits. 16:25:04 <trinaths> #action ritusood_ : Compass and k8s-ovn4nfv-plugin integration 16:25:25 <trinaths> thanks electrocucaracha ritusood_ for attending the weekly meeting 16:25:30 <trinaths> #endmeeting