14:00:04 <rprakash> #startmeeting mano-wg
14:00:04 <collabot`> Meeting started Wed May 31 14:00:04 2017 UTC.  The chair is rprakash. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
14:00:04 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
14:00:04 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'mano_wg'
14:00:55 <rprakash> #chair rprakash aimee bryan_att
14:00:55 <collabot`> Warning: Nick not in channel: aimee
14:00:55 <collabot`> Current chairs: aimee bryan_att rprakash
14:01:08 <rprakash> chair aimeeu
14:01:58 <rprakash> #pease key in ypur info we are on irc only if need be I can open GTM link let me know
14:03:18 <trinaths> Hi all- this is Trinath
14:03:50 <rprakash> welcome
14:04:03 <aimeeu> Hi - I'm here
14:04:23 <aimeeu> #info Aimee Ukasick
14:04:26 <rprakash> Sure shall we try GTM link
14:05:30 <aimeeu> I'm fine with IRC only
14:05:52 <rprakash> OK
14:06:11 <rprakash> Lets start with agenda bashing
14:06:21 <rprakash> #topic Agnda bashing
14:07:04 <rprakash> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=6827111
14:07:52 <rprakash> we have 3 topics anythng more you want to cover
14:07:54 <rprakash> 1.Agenda Bashing  2. Containers Packaging and On-boarding considerations for nfvo and vnfm + common practices checklist to consider  3. MNAO WG - focus areas to  facilitate Delivering E release priority & plan for F  4. China Summit preparation by  MANO projects and any presentation/ feedback for speakers.
14:08:29 <rprakash> OK lets move to next topic
14:08:50 <rprakash> #topic   Containers Packaging and On-boarding considerations for nfvo and vnfm + common practices checklist to consider
14:09:32 <rprakash> #info current usage in VNF as conatiner in OPNFV, lets consolidate that first
14:09:56 <rprakash> #info EUAG requirements
14:10:12 <rprakash> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/EUAG/VNF+Onboarding+and+Deployment
14:12:02 <rprakash> #info summary here is OPNFV platform to  validate a VNF Package
14:14:13 <rprakash> # info for VNF Provider and Operator both must be ab;le to onaboard for all configuration options to validate  and deploy the VNF without any errror
14:14:48 <trinaths> agree
14:15:46 <rprakash> Further requirments deal with Packaging options,  structure, content, and actors using them
14:16:38 <rprakash> #So far so good and lets get to the specs from ETSI
14:16:56 <rprakash> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/mano/VNF+Onboarding
14:18:52 <rprakash> #info here we find in section NF Packaging use-cases  page 12
14:19:27 <rprakash> #info here we find in section VNF Packaging use-cases  page 12
14:20:49 <trinaths> page 12?
14:20:56 <rprakash> #here we have steps involving the VNF  Package as it transitions from the VNF Provider to the  Service Provider.
14:22:03 <rprakash> #correction the ETSI IFA 011 is in link http://www.etsi.org/deliver/etsi_gs/NFV-IFA/001_099/011/02.01.01_60/gs_NFV-IFA011v020101p.pdf
14:22:50 <trinaths> thank you
14:23:30 <rprakash> The previous link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/mano/VNF+Onboarding is for mano-wg wiki reference
14:23:46 <trinaths> yes. im confused at page 12
14:23:55 <trinaths> got it now
14:25:55 <rprakash> #info so most im[portant is corelating EUAG requirments with ETSI IFA 011 VNF Pacakaging specs and mano-wg arriving at b est practices in MANO related projects in OPNFV
14:27:35 <rprakash> #so the VNF validation requires describing the VNF design in terms of VNFC and ulimately providing realtions shipd through Connecting points and links and ensure its strutured as pacakge with files and metadata
14:30:02 <rprakash> #info as long as this is met by a OPNFV project we need the documentaion on structure and use of the description of VNF Package content
14:30:40 <rprakash> #so lets just visit what OpenBaton does this week and cover others later
14:31:09 <rprakash> #info mano-wg wiki reference
14:31:22 <trinaths> VNF packaging requires connection links between VNFCs ?
14:32:07 <rprakash> #yes
14:32:26 <trinaths> w.r.t line, "VNF must be able to detect whether it has been deployed correctly" in https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/EUAG/VNF+Onboarding+and+Deployment
14:32:47 <aimeeu> rprakash: I have to drop off to deal with a situation at work.
14:33:04 <rprakash> Ok
14:33:11 <trinaths> can you give more info. how VNF is intelligent here.
14:34:56 <rprakash> #info in static senseno smarts just metedata , but when instantiated it must send some keep alive or heath check so if it fails it can notify  some sort of integlligence here
14:35:37 <trinaths> okay.
14:36:02 <rprakash> health check, notifciation, loctaion info on rquest etc. plus ability to recognize early failure signs etc.
14:36:43 <trinaths> agree.
14:37:07 <rprakash> #info so going back to OpenBaton in mano wg link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/mano/VNF+Onboarding
14:39:26 <trinaths> link doesn't give any info on OpenBaton
14:40:31 <rprakash> #info here we have Development, Onboarding and Production requirments of VNF and has description of CSAR and latest TOSCA descriptors used by most MANO projects
14:41:19 <trinaths> okay.
14:42:10 <rprakash> #Yes it does not the OpenBaton is listed under  MANO project Guidance
14:42:18 <rprakash> #link https://wiki.opnfv.org/display/mano/MANO+Project+Guidance
14:42:49 <trinaths> ok
14:42:57 <rprakash> #inof under Orchestra link NFVO API
14:43:13 <rprakash> #info under Orchestra link NFVO API
14:44:15 <rprakash> #info see Package structure
14:44:16 <trinaths> got it.
14:44:29 <trinaths> #link: http://openbaton.github.io/documentation/vnfpackage/
14:45:01 <trinaths> got it
14:45:05 <trinaths> thank you
14:47:40 <rprakash> #info there is tutorial and can go through that, once Giuseppe PTL of Otchestra project is available will try to get updates on what excpetions or alterations they did as specs were incomplete when they started on this and hat will leave it to next meeting
14:49:03 <rprakash> #info will skip topic 2 as Aimee has left and no other project members to work with
14:49:10 <rprakash> #topic  China Summit preparation by  MANO projects and any presentation/ feedback for speakers.
14:50:08 <rprakash> #info so trinaths do you have any questions or need any feedbacks
14:50:50 <trinaths> we replied and requesting further feedback
14:50:51 <rprakash> #info was it Distributed VNFM?
14:50:57 <trinaths> yes
14:51:11 <trinaths> another ppt, security, there was no feedback
14:53:26 <rprakash> OK  send email will folow up and rest we can end the meeting if there is no other topic
14:53:38 <trinaths> ok
14:55:06 <rprakash> #actio Document the VNF Pacakging and or update wiki for best practices for VNF Onbaording (Giuseppe) for OpenBaton
14:55:26 <rprakash> #endmeeting mano-wg