13:01:02 <fuqiao> #startmeeting OPNFV High availability project meeting
13:01:02 <collabot`> Meeting started Wed Feb 28 13:01:02 2018 UTC.  The chair is fuqiao. Information about MeetBot at http://wiki.debian.org/MeetBot.
13:01:02 <collabot`> Useful Commands: #action #agreed #help #info #idea #link #topic.
13:01:02 <collabot`> The meeting name has been set to 'opnfv_high_availability_project_meeting'
13:01:21 <fuqiao> #chair fuqiao
13:01:21 <collabot`> Current chairs: fuqiao
13:01:28 <fuqiao> #info fuqiao
13:01:40 <mardim> #info Dimitrios Markou
13:02:29 <fuqiao> please #info yourself for the HA project. Thanks
13:02:52 <Kanglin> #info Kanglin
13:05:21 <fuqiao> a few others told me they are at the openstack PTG, and mayby can't make it.
13:05:40 <fuqiao> #topic HA test case progress update
13:06:13 <fuqiao> #info the MS6 is March 16. all test cases have to be merged before that if we like to be included in the F release
13:06:34 <fuqiao> @Dimitrios, how about the progress of the SDN cases?
13:06:34 <collabot`> fuqiao: Error: "Dimitrios," is not a valid command.
13:06:41 <mardim> Hello
13:06:55 <mardim> I am trying currently to implement a HA testacse
13:07:00 <georgk> #info Georg Kunz
13:07:02 <georgk> hi
13:07:15 <mardim> But I am having some problems
13:07:15 <fuqiao> hi, Georg, welcome
13:07:21 <georgk> sorry for being late
13:07:39 <mardim> Can we discuss in this topic ?
13:07:45 <georgk> I am at the OpenStack PTG and need to leave in 30min again :-/
13:08:15 <fuqiao> Georg: OK
13:08:39 <fuqiao> Mardim: you can ask questions to Kanglin, they are familiar with the framework
13:08:56 <mardim> ok thanks so I am trying to implement this  Spec
13:09:02 <fuqiao> if the question is too complecated, you may use email or offline discussion
13:09:42 <mardim> fuqiao, ok I will use the mail because I have many questions
13:10:03 <mardim> fuqiao, FYI I am having a problem with this : https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/YARDSTICK-1031
13:10:04 <fuqiao> OK. you can send email to Kanglin and Qiujuan
13:10:15 <mardim> ok sure thanks a lot
13:10:46 <fuqiao> Mardim: what is the problem with jira?
13:11:22 <mardim> The probem is that I cannot create the topology which this testcase requires
13:11:25 <mardim> #link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/49245
13:11:38 <mardim> Because of this Jira ticket
13:11:57 <mardim> So I opened a Jira ticket to Yardstick so they can fix it somehow
13:12:17 <mardim> #link https://jira.opnfv.org/browse/YARDSTICK-1031
13:12:37 <fuqiao> OK. @kanglin, could you please help look into this?
13:13:32 <Kanglin> mardim: I think it can be implemented by adding context information in test cases, but I'm not sure
13:13:47 <mardim> Kanglin, YEs I am doing exactly that
13:14:11 <mardim> Kanglin, but yardstick doesn't support the specific topology which is described in the Jira ticket
13:14:29 <mardim> Kanglin, we should make a python patch to Yardstick so we can fix that
13:14:53 <mardim> Kanglin, We need changes in the code base of Yardstick
13:14:57 <fuqiao> #info Dimitrios is now working on SDN HA test cases, but has problem with the topology. A jira ticket is raised for that bug
13:16:03 <Kanglin> mardim: you mean the topology of instances?
13:16:32 <mardim> Yes exactly
13:16:36 <mardim> Kanglin, ^
13:17:10 <mardim> You cannot create a topology with two instances which are in a different subnet and communicate to eachother over Router
13:17:16 <mardim> the same router*
13:17:21 <mardim> Kanglin, ^
13:18:11 <Kanglin> mardim: the topology of instance is supported in yardstick, but current ha test case haven't used yet
13:18:43 <mardim> Kanglin, Not sure that I understood what you mean
13:18:43 <Kanglin> mardin: but I'm not sure whether the topology you described is supported
13:19:03 <mardim> I think it is not
13:19:13 <mardim> I read the code base of yardstick
13:19:35 <mardim> and I found out that you cannot connect two different netwrks to the same Router
13:19:42 <mardim> if I am not mistaken
13:20:18 <fuqiao> Mardim: is this bug easy to fix? is it possible for us to catch the March 16 deadline?
13:20:49 <georgk> we could also aim for a simplified test case
13:20:50 <mardim> fuqiao, I think is not an easy fix
13:21:09 <georgk> and not include the router initially, but just use 2 VMs on a L2 network
13:21:26 <mardim> georgk, That could worl
13:21:28 <mardim> work*
13:21:44 <mardim> But I have several problems which I will describe in a mail later
13:21:55 <mardim> right now I am trying to find them
13:22:04 <georgk> ok, let´s go a ¨minimal viable test¨
13:22:06 <mardim> because everyday I am discovering something new
13:22:06 <georgk> :-)
13:22:10 <Kanglin> I'll confirm with other guys in yardstick too
13:22:18 <mardim> ok sure Thanks :)
13:24:03 <fuqiao> OK, seems SDN cases are not that easy to finish before the deadline
13:24:21 <wangmeng> #info Wangmeng
13:24:31 <fuqiao> Kanglin: how about new test cases you proposed in the previous call? I see no new TC discription file uploaded on Gerrit?
13:24:48 <fuqiao> are you still plan to add new HA test cases for this release
13:26:16 <Kanglin> fuqiao: I'll upload both the TC description and test case a few days later.
13:26:25 <fuqiao> OK, great
13:26:43 <fuqiao> #info Kanglin will upload new TC description and TC in a few days
13:26:45 <georgk> Kanglin: cool, does that inculde the implementation as well?
13:26:49 <Kanglin> Tomorrow is the deadline of my paper so I'm struggling with it these days, sorry for that
13:27:02 <mardim> Guys if you want to take a look for the progress so far you can : https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/52159/
13:27:11 <Kanglin> georgk: yes
13:27:21 <fuqiao> @Wangmeng, how about the VM HA and hypervisor HA cases? can they be finished before March 16th?
13:27:21 <collabot`> fuqiao: Error: "Wangmeng," is not a valid command.
13:28:07 <fuqiao> #info SDN TC link https://gerrit.opnfv.org/gerrit/#/c/52159/
13:28:15 <fuqiao> Mardim: Thank you
13:28:22 <mardim> No pro!
13:29:59 <wangmeng> I have received the new TC descriptions, and I think I can finish them before March 16th
13:31:08 <fuqiao> Wangmeng: OK. We can consider upload on gerrit for review, the TC must be merged before Mar. 16, which means you should upload before head to give the community time to review
13:31:58 <fuqiao> #info Wangmeng will finish the VM HA and hypervisor HA TC before Mar. 16
13:32:35 <fuqiao> OK, I think we have go through all the test cases for this release
13:32:50 <wangmeng> fuqiao: yes, I will finish the VM HA and hypervisor HA TC as soon as possible
13:32:57 <fuqiao> If no one has further to add, I will end the meeting.
13:33:07 <fuqiao> Thank you for everyone to join this.
13:33:18 <fuqiao> Wangmeng: thanks!
13:33:45 <fuqiao> #endmeeting