#opendaylight-meeting: boron release review

Meeting started by anipbu at 14:30:32 UTC (full logs).

Meeting summary

  1. roll call (anipbu, 14:30:38)
    1. PTL and TSC members please #info in (anipbu, 14:30:46)
    2. anipbu (anipbu, 14:30:51)
    3. Ryan Goulding (rgoulding) for AAA (rgoulding, 14:31:23)
    4. skitt (skitt, 14:31:24)
    5. Alec Leckey for NetIDE (aleckey, 14:31:42)
    6. colindixon for docs, and TSC (colindixon, 14:31:49)
    7. Jensen Zhang for ALTO (jensen_zhang, 14:32:09)
    8. Kai for ALTO (emiapwil, 14:33:16)
    9. Vratko polak for integration/distribution and integration/test (vrpolak, 14:34:09)
    10. VivekSri for Genius (VivekSri, 14:34:30)

  2. AAA (anipbu, 14:34:56)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/AAA:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:35:01)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/AAA:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:35:06)
    3. rgoulding is representing AAA (anipbu, 14:35:11)
    4. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/AAA:Boron:Release_Review (rgoulding, 14:40:02)
    5. idmlite is not a feature in aaa for boron. tests are failing, but they are invalid anyways. (anipbu, 14:41:18)
    6. all of AAA features are experimental (anipbu, 14:42:24)
    7. AAA has tested RC2 and found no problems (anipbu, 14:42:34)
    8. ACTION: rgoulding to follow up with shiro experimental state (anipbu, 14:45:37)
    9. ACTION: rgoulding to follow up on code coverage for the system test: "odl-aaa-cli and odl-aaa-cert features do not seem to be tested in the one passing job." (anipbu, 14:48:12)
    10. AAA approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 14:48:31)

  3. ODLPARENT (anipbu, 14:48:36)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/ODL_Parent:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:48:40)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/ODL_Parent:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:48:44)
    3. skitt is representing ODLPARENT (anipbu, 14:48:52)
    4. odlparent has no blockers in RC2 (tested). no experimental features. no user facing features (anipbu, 14:51:28)
    5. karaf 3.0.7 upgrade is complete (anipbu, 14:51:47)
    6. ODLPARENT has system test waiver approved by the integration team https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Simultaneous_Release/Boron/Waiver/System_Test (anipbu, 14:53:11)
    7. ODLPARENT approved for Boron. Congratulations! (anipbu, 14:55:00)

  4. NETIDE (anipbu, 14:55:05)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NetIDE:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:55:11)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/NetIDE:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:55:14)
    3. aleckey is representing NETIDE (anipbu, 14:55:24)
    4. netide has tested RC2 and found no issues (anipbu, 14:57:41)
    5. netide features are experimental (anipbu, 14:59:17)
    6. NetIDE feature repository is included in integration, but its features are commented out, so the do not participate in compatibility testing (-all- jobs) (anipbu, 14:59:38)
    7. ACTION: aleckey to follow up on pushing the docuemntation into reStructuredText so it's all in one place (anipbu, 15:00:41)
    8. NETIDE approved for Boron. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:01:11)

  5. ALTO (anipbu, 15:01:16)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/ALTO:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:01:21)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/ALTO:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:01:26)
    3. jensen_zhang is representing ALTO (anipbu, 15:01:30)
    4. alto has tested RC2 and found no blockers (anipbu, 15:04:19)
    5. all of alto features are experimental (anipbu, 15:04:37)
    6. ALTO approved for Boron. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:11:33)

  6. BGPCEP (anipbu, 15:11:41)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/BGP_LS_PCEP:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:11:47)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/BGP_LS_PCEP:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:11:51)
    3. milfabia is representing BGPCEP (anipbu, 15:11:56)
    4. CRITICAL: bug 6497 appears to be a blocking bug somewhere between bgpcep and yangtools, it's being debugged and a fix is hoped for by tomorrow (colindixon, 15:17:52)
    5. ACTION: milfabia to follow up with bug 6497 (anipbu, 15:18:24)
    6. ACTION: milfabia to update the target environment (anipbu, 15:22:09)
    7. https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/bgpcep-dev/2016-August/000729.html email with CSIT analysis. (jamoluhrsen, 15:22:34)
    8. ACTION: milfabia to update the list of features and if they are user-facing or experimental, etc. (anipbu, 15:22:44)
    9. 10 CSIT jobs (which is great), but 8 of them have unexpected failures. as vrpolak points out, they might be consistently failing but they should point to an open non-blocking bug if so. (jamoluhrsen, 15:23:28)
    10. ACTION: milfabia to update the release notes with reference on TCPMD5 migration (anipbu, 15:26:20)
    11. ACTION: milfabia to follow up on the CSIT failures. (if they are all experimental features, then okay. but for any non-experimental features, the CSIT must pass, etc) (anipbu, 15:27:13)
    12. ACTION: anipbu to follow up with BGPCEP over email (anipbu, 15:33:27)
    13. CAPWAP cannot made their release review. Will reschedule. (anipbu, 15:34:39)
    14. CONTROLLER was unresponsive. Will reschedule. (anipbu, 15:36:50)

  7. DLUX (anipbu, 15:38:01)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_DLUX:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:38:16)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_DLUX:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:38:28)
    3. mmcoulombe is representing DLUX (anipbu, 15:38:39)
    4. all dlux features should be considered experimental (jamoluhrsen, 15:40:25)
    5. ACTION: mmcoulombe to test RC2 today or (worst case) tomorrow and confirm if there are any blocking issues and update the spreadsheet appropriately: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zImtd764e-hOgJAxoJKl85fxHCPu2agLfqsBtf13zQY/edit#gid=199721620 (anipbu, 15:45:21)
    6. dlux docs are still accurate since nothing really change since helium release for DLUX (anipbu, 15:45:56)
    7. ACTION: mmcoulombe to update the release notes target environment (anipbu, 15:47:58)
    8. DLUX approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:49:26)

  8. DOCS (anipbu, 15:49:35)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Documentation/Boron/Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:49:36)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Documentation/Boron/Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:49:42)
    3. colindixon is representing DOCS (anipbu, 15:49:48)
    4. migration to reST is ongoing pending 12 projects https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/q/(topic:adoc2rst+OR+topic:adoc2rst-user)+status:open (anipbu, 15:51:43)
    5. docs does not need to test RC2: N/A (anipbu, 15:52:20)
    6. http://docs.opendaylight.org/ this is the big thing we delivered (colindixon, 15:55:00)
    7. we also no support inclusion of docs directly from project repos (colindixon, 15:55:13)
    8. ACTION: colindixon to update Non Code Aspects with appropriate links. (anipbu, 15:55:47)
    9. DOCS approved for Boron. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:58:17)
    10. EMAN cannot made their release review. Will reschedule. (anipbu, 15:58:59)

  9. GENIUS (anipbu, 15:59:25)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Genius:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:59:33)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Genius:Boron:Release_Note <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:59:40)
    3. VivekSri is representing GENIUS (anipbu, 15:59:45)
    4. https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/genius-dev/2016-August/000282.html email about CSIT analysis for Genius project (jamoluhrsen, 16:02:19)
    5. CSIT patches are pending merge. (anipbu, 16:02:24)
    6. NetVirt project is extensivey using genius features, and thus genius features are also tested with NetVirt CSIT (anipbu, 16:02:26)
    7. there is currently no csit so by definition all features would be experimental. (jamoluhrsen, 16:02:38)
    8. integration team needs to review those patches (jamoluhrsen, 16:02:51)
    9. netvirt is going to be labeled experimental all over the place too, so we can't use that project's CSIT for genius (jamoluhrsen, 16:03:22)
    10. ACTION: jamoluhrsen to review genius csit patches. (jamoluhrsen, 16:04:00)
    11. https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/39665/ (VivekSri, 16:04:13)
    12. genius has pending docs patches for review: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/39665/ (anipbu, 16:04:40)
    13. ACTION: VivekSri to follow up on docs patches (anipbu, 16:04:54)
    14. ACTION: VivekSri to follow up on CSIT tests and "experimental" tag for relevant features. (anipbu, 16:05:24)
    15. genius has tested RC2 and found no blockers (anipbu, 16:07:43)
    16. genius has no security considerations (anipbu, 16:11:15)
    17. GENIUS approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:15:19)

  10. L2SWITCH (anipbu, 16:17:01)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/L2_Switch:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 16:17:06)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/L2_Switch:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:17:10)
    3. evanz is representing L2SWITCH (anipbu, 16:17:19)
    4. https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/l2switch-dev/2016-August/001260.html csit analysis email. (jamoluhrsen, 16:17:45)
    5. looks like all l2switch features should have the experimental label. (jamoluhrsen, 16:18:16)
    6. l2switch to test RC2 and report the status of any blocking bugs (anipbu, 16:22:39)
    7. ACTION: evanz to update the list of features and if they are user-facing or experimental, etc. (anipbu, 16:24:19)
    8. ACTION: evanz to follow up on RC2 testing and update the spreadsheet (anipbu, 16:24:47)
    9. ACTION: evanz to figure out if the scale test is a real regression or just a test failure (colindixon, 16:25:47)
    10. https://jenkins.opendaylight.org/releng/view/l2switch/job/l2switch-csit-1node-periodic-host-scalability-daily-only-boron/plot/Inventory%20Host%20Scalability/ scalability test showing zero, but was 100 in the past (jamoluhrsen, 16:25:53)
    11. ACTION: anipbu evanz: l2switch to follow up over email to cover: rc2 testing, updating features list on release review template, and csit/scale test issues (anipbu, 16:33:18)
    12. MDSAL was unresponsive. Will reschedule. (anipbu, 16:35:22)
    13. NIC was unresponsive. Will reschedule. (anipbu, 16:36:26)

  11. cookies (anipbu, 16:38:54)


Meeting ended at 16:39:02 UTC (full logs).

Action items

  1. rgoulding to follow up with shiro experimental state
  2. rgoulding to follow up on code coverage for the system test: "odl-aaa-cli and odl-aaa-cert features do not seem to be tested in the one passing job."
  3. aleckey to follow up on pushing the docuemntation into reStructuredText so it's all in one place
  4. milfabia to follow up with bug 6497
  5. milfabia to update the target environment
  6. milfabia to update the list of features and if they are user-facing or experimental, etc.
  7. milfabia to update the release notes with reference on TCPMD5 migration
  8. milfabia to follow up on the CSIT failures. (if they are all experimental features, then okay. but for any non-experimental features, the CSIT must pass, etc)
  9. anipbu to follow up with BGPCEP over email
  10. mmcoulombe to test RC2 today or (worst case) tomorrow and confirm if there are any blocking issues and update the spreadsheet appropriately: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zImtd764e-hOgJAxoJKl85fxHCPu2agLfqsBtf13zQY/edit#gid=199721620
  11. mmcoulombe to update the release notes target environment
  12. colindixon to update Non Code Aspects with appropriate links.
  13. jamoluhrsen to review genius csit patches.
  14. VivekSri to follow up on docs patches
  15. VivekSri to follow up on CSIT tests and "experimental" tag for relevant features.
  16. evanz to update the list of features and if they are user-facing or experimental, etc.
  17. evanz to follow up on RC2 testing and update the spreadsheet
  18. evanz to figure out if the scale test is a real regression or just a test failure
  19. anipbu evanz: l2switch to follow up over email to cover: rc2 testing, updating features list on release review template, and csit/scale test issues


Action items, by person

  1. aleckey
    1. aleckey to follow up on pushing the docuemntation into reStructuredText so it's all in one place
  2. anipbu
    1. anipbu to follow up with BGPCEP over email
    2. anipbu evanz: l2switch to follow up over email to cover: rc2 testing, updating features list on release review template, and csit/scale test issues
  3. colindixon
    1. colindixon to update Non Code Aspects with appropriate links.
  4. evanz
    1. evanz to update the list of features and if they are user-facing or experimental, etc.
    2. evanz to follow up on RC2 testing and update the spreadsheet
    3. evanz to figure out if the scale test is a real regression or just a test failure
    4. anipbu evanz: l2switch to follow up over email to cover: rc2 testing, updating features list on release review template, and csit/scale test issues
  5. jamoluhrsen
    1. jamoluhrsen to review genius csit patches.
  6. milfabia
    1. milfabia to follow up with bug 6497
    2. milfabia to update the target environment
    3. milfabia to update the list of features and if they are user-facing or experimental, etc.
    4. milfabia to update the release notes with reference on TCPMD5 migration
    5. milfabia to follow up on the CSIT failures. (if they are all experimental features, then okay. but for any non-experimental features, the CSIT must pass, etc)
  7. mmcoulombe
    1. mmcoulombe to test RC2 today or (worst case) tomorrow and confirm if there are any blocking issues and update the spreadsheet appropriately: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zImtd764e-hOgJAxoJKl85fxHCPu2agLfqsBtf13zQY/edit#gid=199721620
    2. mmcoulombe to update the release notes target environment
  8. rgoulding
    1. rgoulding to follow up with shiro experimental state
    2. rgoulding to follow up on code coverage for the system test: "odl-aaa-cli and odl-aaa-cert features do not seem to be tested in the one passing job."
  9. VivekSri
    1. VivekSri to follow up on docs patches
    2. VivekSri to follow up on CSIT tests and "experimental" tag for relevant features.


People present (lines said)

  1. anipbu (197)
  2. colindixon (78)
  3. jamoluhrsen (25)
  4. rgoulding (21)
  5. VivekSri (16)
  6. vrpolak (16)
  7. milfabia (15)
  8. skitt (10)
  9. mmcoulombe (9)
  10. jensen_zhang (5)
  11. odl_meetbot (5)
  12. evanz (4)
  13. aleckey (4)
  14. Sai_ (3)
  15. emiapwil (3)
  16. LuisGomez (1)


Generated by MeetBot 0.1.4.