#opendaylight-meeting: boron release review

Meeting started by anipbu at 14:30:59 UTC (full logs).

Meeting summary

  1. roll call (anipbu, 14:31:04)
    1. PTL and TSC members please #info in (anipbu, 14:31:09)
    2. TSDR (yuling_, 14:31:19)
    3. anipbu (anipbu, 14:31:23)
    4. sdninterfaceapp (RafatJahan, 14:31:33)
    5. Vratko Polak for integration (vrpolak, 14:31:43)
    6. vijay for snbi (vjanandr, 14:31:52)

  2. TSDR (anipbu, 14:32:55)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Boron_Release_Review (yuling_, 14:33:04)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:33:17)
    3. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/TSDR:Beryllium:Release_Review (yuling_, 14:33:30)
    4. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Boron_Release_Review (yuling_, 14:33:54)
    5. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Boron_Release_Notes (yuling_, 14:34:33)
    6. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:34:45)
    7. yuling_ is representing TSDR (anipbu, 14:34:58)
    8. ACTION: yuling_ to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 14:36:18)
    9. TSDR has tested RC2 and found no problems (anipbu, 14:38:13)
    10. all features are non-experimental, except for Cassandra, which is currently tagged as experimental. However, the TSDR team believes cassandra should be nonexperimental. (anipbu, 14:41:16)
    11. ACTION: yuling_ jamoluhrsen to follow up with CSIT test adn experimental tag of cassandra (anipbu, 14:41:54)
    12. TSDR to follow up on action items (anipbu, 14:45:14)
    13. ACTION: anipbu to follow up with TSDR (anipbu, 14:45:21)

  3. SDNINTERFACEAPP (anipbu, 14:45:51)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/ODL-SDNi:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:45:57)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/ODL-SDNi:Boron_Release_Review (RafatJahan, 14:45:58)
    3. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/ODL-SDNi:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:46:01)
    4. RafatJahan is representing SDNINTERFACEAPP (anipbu, 14:46:18)
    5. ChristineH is representing SNMP4SDN (ChristineH, 14:46:34)
    6. SDNINTERFACEAPP tested RC2 and found no problems (anipbu, 14:48:44)
    7. RafatJahan has agreed to make mark all features as experimental (anipbu, 14:50:07)
    8. https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/34875/ (colindixon, 14:51:15)
    9. ACTION: RafatJahan to review this patch: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/34875/ (anipbu, 14:51:46)
    10. ACTION: RafatJahan to update release view wiki page with the links to the asciidocs/rst files (anipbu, 14:52:49)
    11. rovarga asked about removal of forked BGPCEP code somewhere on the roadmap (anipbu, 14:54:13)
    12. RafatJahan responds regarding bgcep fork: there are plans, but will need to check with PTL Sirisha (anipbu, 14:55:25)
    13. ACTION: RafatJahan to follow up with rovarga in addressing the fork of BGCEP in Carbon (anipbu, 14:55:52)
    14. SDNINTERFACEAPP approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 14:57:01)

  4. SNBI (anipbu, 14:57:05)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/SecureNetworkBootstrapping:BoronReleaseReview <--- Release Review (anipbu, 14:57:09)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/SecureNetworkBootstrapping:BoronReleaseReview (vjanandr, 14:57:12)
    3. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/SNBI_Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 14:57:13)
    4. frankbrockners is representing SNBI (anipbu, 14:57:24)
    5. vjanandr is representing SNBI (anipbu, 14:57:49)
    6. ACTION: vjanandr to test RC2 (anipbu, 15:00:51)
    7. vjanandr has agreed that all features will be marked experimental (anipbu, 15:01:15)
    8. ACTION: vjanandr to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 15:01:32)
    9. https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/44983/ (vjanandr, 15:02:37)
    10. ACTION: colindixon to review https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/44983/ (anipbu, 15:02:50)
    11. SNBI approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:04:50)
    12. ACTION: SNMP to reschedule. (anipbu, 15:05:58)

  5. SNMP4SDN (anipbu, 15:06:05)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/SNMP4SDN:Beryllium_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:06:11)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/SNMP4SDN:Boron_Release_Note (ChristineH_, 15:10:51)
    3. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/SNMP4SDN:Boron_Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:11:00)
    4. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/SNMP4SDN:Boron_Release_Note <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:11:05)
    5. ChristineH is representing SNMP4SDN (anipbu, 15:11:10)
    6. SNMP4SDN has tested RC2 and found blocking bug: https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6607 (anipbu, 15:11:31)
    7. ACTION: ChristineH to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 15:13:29)
    8. the user-facing features: odl-snmp4sdn-all and odl-snmp4sdn-snmp4sdn (anipbu, 15:16:01)
    9. ChristineH_ has agreed to mark all features as experimental for now (will be updated once the external test results are published) (anipbu, 15:19:07)
    10. ACTION: ChristineH_ and jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and the experimental tag. (anipbu, 15:20:21)
    11. ACTION: ChristineH_ to add adoc/rst links to release review (anipbu, 15:25:47)
    12. SNMP4SDN approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:25:52)

  6. TTP (anipbu, 15:25:57)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Table_Type_Patterns/Boron/Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:26:03)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Table_Type_Patterns/Boron/Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:26:07)
    3. colindixon is representing TTP (anipbu, 15:26:10)
    4. ACTION: colindixon to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 15:28:22)
    5. ACTION: colindixon to test TTP for RC2 and report status of testing on here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zImtd764e-hOgJAxoJKl85fxHCPu2agLfqsBtf13zQY/edit#gid=199721620 (anipbu, 15:29:19)
    6. All TTP features are experimental (anipbu, 15:29:39)
    7. user facing features: odl-ttp-model (anipbu, 15:29:51)
    8. the CLI tools is a serpate non-karaf feature. It is described in more details in the documentation. This docs is linked form the release review template (anipbu, 15:31:52)
    9. TTP approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:33:18)
    10. VPNSERVICE has dropped out of boron so there will be no release review for that project. (anipbu, 15:33:53)
    11. ACTION: YANG-PUSH to reschedule (anipbu, 15:35:44)

  7. YANGIDE (anipbu, 15:35:59)
    1. David Karr for yangide (davidmichaelkarr, 15:36:02)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/YangIDE/Boron/Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:36:03)
    3. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/YangIDE/Boron/Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:36:07)
    4. davidmichaelkarr is representing YANGIDE (anipbu, 15:36:20)
    5. davidmichaelkarr has tested RC2 in the sense that the yangide was downloaded today and tested. Did not see any issues (anipbu, 15:40:34)
    6. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/CrossProject:Integration_Group:Feature_Integration_System_Test_Template (jamoluhrsen, 15:43:48)
    7. davidmichaelkarr has agreed to mark all YANGIDE features as experimental (anipbu, 15:48:02)
    8. ACTION: davidmichaelkarr jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and updating the experimental tag as appropriate. (anipbu, 15:48:38)
    9. YANGIDE approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 15:51:41)

  8. YANGTOOLS (anipbu, 15:52:28)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/YANG_Tools:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 15:52:33)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/YANG_Tools:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 15:52:37)
    3. rovarga is representing YANGTOOLS (anipbu, 15:52:41)
    4. ACTION: rovarga to update spreadsheet on RC2 testing for yangtools (anipbu, 15:55:32)
    5. yangtools has system test waiver (anipbu, 15:55:45)
    6. All yangtools features are marked as experimental (anipbu, 15:56:11)
    7. the plan is to introduce stable features in Carbon by splitting current features into smaller chunks (rovarga, 15:56:56)
    8. yangtools has tested RC2. Status is green with no problems found. (anipbu, 15:57:00)
    9. no deprecation of api in yangtools for Boron release. only remove previously deprecated things (anipbu, 16:00:18)
    10. ACTION: rovarga to mentioned in the release notes the previously-deprecated things that have been removed in Boron (anipbu, 16:01:44)
    11. ACTION: anipbu to look into https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5340 for future enhancement (anipbu, 16:05:03)
    12. YANGTOOLS approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:05:18)

  9. EMAN (anipbu, 16:05:43)
    1. https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/eman-dev/2016-August/000022.html <--- csit analysis email for EMAN (jamoluhrsen, 16:07:40)
    2. all features experimental (jamoluhrsen, 16:07:48)
    3. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Eman:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:07:57)
    4. ACTION: george to generate release review template (anipbu, 16:10:16)
    5. ACTION: EMAN to reschedule (anipbu, 16:10:17)

  10. HONEYCOMB/VBD (anipbu, 16:11:01)
    1. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Honeycomb/vbd:Boron:Release_Review <--- Release Review (anipbu, 16:11:05)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/Honeycomb/vbd:Boron:Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:11:10)
    3. wojdec1 is representing HONEYCOMB/VBD (anipbu, 16:11:32)
    4. no CSIT for honeycomb/vbd. all features expiremental (jamoluhrsen, 16:12:03)
    5. vbd has tested RC2. RC2 status now green with no problem found. (anipbu, 16:15:04)
    6. all vbd features are marked as experimental in boron (anipbu, 16:17:53)
    7. HONEYCOMB/VBD approved for Boron pending action items. Congratulations! (anipbu, 16:21:45)
    8. NIC has asked to reschedule (anipbu, 16:22:05)
    9. ACTION: NIC to reschedule (anipbu, 16:22:10)

  11. OPENFLOWPLUGIN (anipbu, 16:22:38)
    1. https://lists.opendaylight.org/pipermail/openflowplugin-dev/2016-September/005943.html <--- email for boron csit analysis for openflowplugin (jamoluhrsen, 16:23:52)
    2. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_OpenFlow_Plugin:Boron_Release_Review (abhijitkumbhare, 16:24:10)
    3. https://wiki.opendaylight.org/view/OpenDaylight_OpenFlow_Plugin:Boron_Release_Notes <--- Release Notes (anipbu, 16:25:00)
    4. abhijitkumbhare is representing OPENFLOWPLUGIN (anipbu, 16:25:13)
    5. openflowplugin has tested RC2 and found 3 blockers (anipbu, 16:28:15)
    6. https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6554 (jozef bacigal) (abhijitkumbhare, 16:28:50)
    7. https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6176 (probably andrej leitner or tomas slusny) (abhijitkumbhare, 16:29:29)
    8. the three blocker bugs found in RC2 is: https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6595 (shuva ), https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6554 (jozef bacigal), https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6176 (probably andrej leitner or tomas slusny) (anipbu, 16:30:39)
    9. only limitied documentation has been merged on or around openflowplugin (anipbu, 16:31:37)
    10. ACTION: abhijitkumbhare to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes (anipbu, 16:33:08)
    11. ACTION: jamoluhrsen: abhijitkumbhare: to follow up on CSIT tests and experimental tags for openflowplugin (anipbu, 16:40:45)
    12. ACTION: abhijitkumbhare to update the section under "Changes Since Previous Releases" including clarifying more content for "Migration", "Compatibility", "Deprecation" with some mention of the He design. (anipbu, 16:42:30)
    13. ACTION: openflowplugin to follow up with action items (anipbu, 16:43:23)
    14. ACTION: anipbu to follow up with openflowplugin (anipbu, 16:43:33)

  12. cookies (anipbu, 16:46:19)


Meeting ended at 16:46:26 UTC (full logs).

Action items

  1. yuling_ to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
  2. yuling_ jamoluhrsen to follow up with CSIT test adn experimental tag of cassandra
  3. anipbu to follow up with TSDR
  4. RafatJahan to review this patch: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/34875/
  5. RafatJahan to update release view wiki page with the links to the asciidocs/rst files
  6. RafatJahan to follow up with rovarga in addressing the fork of BGCEP in Carbon
  7. vjanandr to test RC2
  8. vjanandr to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
  9. colindixon to review https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/44983/
  10. SNMP to reschedule.
  11. ChristineH to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
  12. ChristineH_ and jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and the experimental tag.
  13. ChristineH_ to add adoc/rst links to release review
  14. colindixon to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
  15. colindixon to test TTP for RC2 and report status of testing on here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zImtd764e-hOgJAxoJKl85fxHCPu2agLfqsBtf13zQY/edit#gid=199721620
  16. YANG-PUSH to reschedule
  17. davidmichaelkarr jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and updating the experimental tag as appropriate.
  18. rovarga to update spreadsheet on RC2 testing for yangtools
  19. rovarga to mentioned in the release notes the previously-deprecated things that have been removed in Boron
  20. anipbu to look into https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5340 for future enhancement
  21. george to generate release review template
  22. EMAN to reschedule
  23. NIC to reschedule
  24. abhijitkumbhare to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
  25. jamoluhrsen: abhijitkumbhare: to follow up on CSIT tests and experimental tags for openflowplugin
  26. abhijitkumbhare to update the section under "Changes Since Previous Releases" including clarifying more content for "Migration", "Compatibility", "Deprecation" with some mention of the He design.
  27. openflowplugin to follow up with action items
  28. anipbu to follow up with openflowplugin


Action items, by person

  1. abhijitkumbhare
    1. abhijitkumbhare to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
    2. jamoluhrsen: abhijitkumbhare: to follow up on CSIT tests and experimental tags for openflowplugin
    3. abhijitkumbhare to update the section under "Changes Since Previous Releases" including clarifying more content for "Migration", "Compatibility", "Deprecation" with some mention of the He design.
  2. anipbu
    1. anipbu to follow up with TSDR
    2. anipbu to look into https://bugs.opendaylight.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5340 for future enhancement
    3. anipbu to follow up with openflowplugin
  3. ChristineH
    1. ChristineH to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
  4. ChristineH_
    1. ChristineH_ and jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and the experimental tag.
    2. ChristineH_ to add adoc/rst links to release review
  5. colindixon
    1. colindixon to review https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/44983/
    2. colindixon to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
    3. colindixon to test TTP for RC2 and report status of testing on here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zImtd764e-hOgJAxoJKl85fxHCPu2agLfqsBtf13zQY/edit#gid=199721620
  6. davidmichaelkarr
    1. davidmichaelkarr jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and updating the experimental tag as appropriate.
  7. george
    1. george to generate release review template
  8. jamoluhrsen
    1. yuling_ jamoluhrsen to follow up with CSIT test adn experimental tag of cassandra
    2. ChristineH_ and jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and the experimental tag.
    3. davidmichaelkarr jamoluhrsen to follow up on publishing the test results and updating the experimental tag as appropriate.
    4. jamoluhrsen: abhijitkumbhare: to follow up on CSIT tests and experimental tags for openflowplugin
  9. RafatJahan
    1. RafatJahan to review this patch: https://git.opendaylight.org/gerrit/#/c/34875/
    2. RafatJahan to update release view wiki page with the links to the asciidocs/rst files
    3. RafatJahan to follow up with rovarga in addressing the fork of BGCEP in Carbon
  10. rovarga
    1. RafatJahan to follow up with rovarga in addressing the fork of BGCEP in Carbon
    2. rovarga to update spreadsheet on RC2 testing for yangtools
    3. rovarga to mentioned in the release notes the previously-deprecated things that have been removed in Boron
  11. vjanandr
    1. vjanandr to test RC2
    2. vjanandr to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
  12. yuling_
    1. yuling_ to update the release review with the list of features and their attributes
    2. yuling_ jamoluhrsen to follow up with CSIT test adn experimental tag of cassandra
  13. UNASSIGNED
    1. SNMP to reschedule.
    2. YANG-PUSH to reschedule
    3. EMAN to reschedule
    4. NIC to reschedule
    5. openflowplugin to follow up with action items


People present (lines said)

  1. anipbu (257)
  2. jamoluhrsen (48)
  3. colindixon (41)
  4. yuling_ (39)
  5. abhijitkumbhare (27)
  6. RafatJahan (19)
  7. davidmichaelkarr (18)
  8. ChristineH_ (18)
  9. rovarga (16)
  10. vjanandr (15)
  11. odl_meetbot (10)
  12. vrpolak (9)
  13. george (5)
  14. wojdec1 (5)
  15. LuisGomez (4)
  16. zxiiro (3)
  17. ChristineH (3)


Generated by MeetBot 0.1.4.